• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Totally Flavorless Mafia! from the Disco Room: DGames Reject Copy

¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,115
Location
Chicago, IL
I don't think I'm defending DZLE at all. I said I thought he was town, you guys asked why I thought so, and I gave my opinion. Speaking of which, you haven't really answered my question: has DZLE made any scummy moves, in you opinion? Because if he has, I'd be glad to see them. I'm not infallible, so if there's something I've missed, I'd like to hear it.
I was referring to this:


Agreeing with NdayDADDY.
Being a odd night cop when he role claimed wouldve been important, and he wouldnt have left it out unless he left it out on purpose to mindgame us, which is unlikely. And never completely answering frown is suspicious.
But I can't completely take suspicion off you, either, Nday.

I'll break the ice, but of course this is 100% subject to change.

Vote: rPSI
Starts the PSI bandwagon which ends in a lynch of a townie.

Fun fact: DZLE didn't vote for Roxy either.

The only four people to not vote for Roxy were Roxy (scum), Matt (who provided evidence for not voting and was the doctor), Lyth, and DZLE.
Actually, Ndayday started the PSI bandwagon. Either way, you voted for PSI too, and we all had good reason for doing so. rPSI was looking scummy and had to go. Even if we were wrong, we all thought it was the right thing to do at the time.

DZLE was a replacement, and you'll notice that he made his first game post right before Roxy was lynched: http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?t=267618&page=19

DZLE didn't actually take part in the game until D3. Of course, he wouldn't have voted for Roxy, who was lynched on D2.
Looks like defending to me.

Those were the only things regarding DZLE that I thought for scummy, so I guess that answers your question.


Lyth, I'd like to know who your scum candidates are.

And my point from before still holds true. If you really were town, why are you alive? With frag's vote on you, the remaining two scum could finish you off. There is nothing stopping this. Your rebuttal to my post was logical, but that still irks me.
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
Vrael makes a valid point, but with so much negativity towards Lythium, I'm curious why he didn't just vote for her when he had the chance to Lynch her.
I'm going to go through with this lynch for a few reasons:
1: In hopes Lythiums here-and-there suspicious playstyle really means she is Mafia, and we kill a Mafia member.
2: She seemed to miss and or dodge a few questions here and there.
3: Vrael made some good points on why she seems suspicious, and even called her out on a few things, but never did anything other than a Strong FOS.
and 4: What Frown said is true. She has been just hanging on for awhile it seems. The game could do without her ESPECIALLY if she truly is Mafia like believed.

In Day 4, I wan't to hear from Vrael why severe suspicion should not be cast upon him.

VOTE: Lythium
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
Keep in mind you guys, Vrael could easily be putting on a Charade with Lythium in hopes of confusing us. They would do a few valid back and forths, and in the end get suspicion cast elsewhere. Seems like a risky plan, but could work. It seemed, if thats the case, it backfired and got people voting for Lythium. Whether that is because she couldnt be as active as she'd like or that not being a factor at all, I don't know.
 

fragbait

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
4,230
Location
Over the skies of Emeria.
I think I just picked up on something. DZLE, you said that you want to hear from Vrael as to why we should not be suspicous of him. This means that, since you are confident there will be a day 5 (I assume a typo above) you can't really be scum.
 

Frown

poekmon
Joined
Nov 1, 2007
Messages
8,538
Location
Right here, not quite now
I think I just picked up on something. DZLE, you said that you want to hear from Vrael as to why we should not be suspicous of him. This means that, since you are confident there will be a day 5 (I assume a typo above) you can't really be scum.
If Lythium is town, we have lost already so it doesn't really matter.

If Lythium is scum, however, we either win or get to move on to the last day. If this is true, we know for sure that there are no two mafia members cooperating.

Right now, I trust Fragbait more than anyone else. It will take a lot for me to vote for him.
 

DtJ Jungle

Check out my character in #GranblueFantasy
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
24,020
Location
Grancypher
FINAL D4 VOTE COUNT!

Lythium (3): fragbait, Frown, DZLE

Not Voting: Lythium, Vrael




Lythium, the mafia hitman has been lynched! it is night 4! ALL ACTIONS DUE BY THE LAST SECOND OF 3/31 EST!
 

fragbait

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
4,230
Location
Over the skies of Emeria.
ALRIGHT! Good call DZLE. I no longer am suspicious of you.

Frown, it's impossible for me to be scum. Town Cop pegged me as Vanilla and his flip confirmed his role.
 

DtJ Jungle

Check out my character in #GranblueFantasy
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
24,020
Location
Grancypher
Frown, the vanilla townie has been killed!

Day 5 begins!

Deadline is the last second of 4/5/10 EST!

With 3 Alive it takes 2 to lynch!
 

Purple

Hi guys!
Joined
Mar 26, 2009
Messages
10,383
Location
Duluth, Georgia
(real talk guys, as much as i didn't mind posting during the night, it's now daytime and this type of discussion is kind of what we expected from the disco room.)
 

¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,115
Location
Chicago, IL
Well played DZLE. Great effort, if I were a bystander I would fall for your scheme no question. The only problem is, you're scum. Frag is town and I'm town. And town is going to win this.

Here we go:

I think I just picked up on something. DZLE, you said that you want to hear from Vrael as to why we should not be suspicous of him. This means that, since you are confident there will be a day 5 (I assume a typo above) you can't really be scum.
If you were confident there would be a day 5, then that means that you have to be scum. The only way you could be completely certain that the game would continue is if you knew Lythium was scum. The only way you would know Lythium is scum is if you were scum as well. It is because of this slip up that I will Vote: DZLE. Frag, I hope you understand my logic and see that town wins this game.

Make everyone suspect me at the last minute, kill off Frown, who hadn't done much the entire game, and make everyone (well, frag at this point) believe everything you said because you nailed the scum.

The Lyth bandwagon wouldn't have started without my posts. Frag wouldn't have voted her without me, and the game might even be over.

But why were you the only person Lythium ever defended? Because you're scum.

Vrael makes a valid point, but with so much negativity towards Lythium, I'm curious why he didn't just vote for her when he had the chance to Lynch her.
I already had explained this. I wanted to wait it out. But you seized the perfect opportunity (while I was offline) to not only wipe suspicion off yourself, but also put suspicion onto me. Well played.

3: Vrael made some good points on why she seems suspicious, and even called her out on a few things, but never did anything other than a Strong FOS.
Again, I was waiting. I didn't want to make a rash decision. But you didn't have to worry about that because you knew exactly which role she had.

Isn't it obvious to throw suspicion on me? Of course, since I didn't vote, I have to be scum! Mmhm.

I'd like to see what frag has to say.

All in all, here are my thoughts as to why DZLE is scum:

1. He wanted to know my thoughts on Day 5 during Day 4. Only scum could know that Lyth would be scum and that there would be a Day 4. A townie may be confident that Lyth was scum, but only a Mafia member would know for sure.

2. Lyth defended DZLE in this post (near the bottom). Lythium is scum. Why would she defend a townie?

3. DZLE started the rPSI bandwagon. Ndayday may have cast suspicion, but DZLE admittedly got the ball rolling.

Frag, I hope you can see through his little scheme. There's a lot stacked against me here, I've done my best to try to get out of this. Eh, I'll probably die. It's OK, this game was really fun. Good job to everyone, well played. Let's just hope it ends up the right way ;)

Let's get a win for town!
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
Well played DZLE. Great effort, if I were a bystander I would fall for your scheme no question. The only problem is, you're scum. Frag is town and I'm town. And town is going to win this.
I could say the very same thing to you, Vrael.
Here we go:



If you were confident there would be a day 5, then that means that you have to be scum. The only way you could be completely certain that the game would continue is if you knew Lythium was scum. The only way you would know Lythium is scum is if you were scum as well. It is because of this slip up that I will Vote: DZLE. Frag, I hope you understand my logic and see that town wins this game.
This doesnt prove I am scum. I could easily have been banking on the fact that Lythium was scum, and due to the deduction of evidence we had, she was the most suspicious next to you (in my opinion), and we could only believe there were 3 mafia total this game. Therefor, I vote for the Lynch on Lythium, in hopes to take it today.
Make everyone suspect me at the last minute, kill off Frown, who hadn't done much the entire game, and make everyone (well, frag at this point) believe everything you said because you nailed the scum.
Sounds like a desperate cry to throw more suspicion on me.
The Lyth bandwagon wouldn't have started without my posts. Frag wouldn't have voted her without me, and the game might even be over.
This being true, you did get the Lyth Bandwagon started, but you never acted on it. Just like scum would have done. Accused in order to confuse, but not vote in fear of killing your fellow scum.
But why were you the only person Lythium ever defended? Because you're scum.
She simply could have been defending me to make it seem like I was suspicious in the end, to get votes on me, and so you could win. And it looks like you are pushing for that.


I already had explained this. I wanted to wait it out. But you seized the perfect opportunity (while I was offline) to not only wipe suspicion off yourself, but also put suspicion onto me. Well played.



Again, I was waiting. I didn't want to make a rash decision. But you didn't have to worry about that because you knew exactly which role she had.

Isn't it obvious to throw suspicion on me? Of course, since I didn't vote, I have to be scum! Mmhm.
The fact you didn't vote, and never acted on your pure suspicion of Lythium, definitely leans toward you being scum.
I'd like to see what frag has to say.

All in all, here are my thoughts as to why DZLE is scum:

1. He wanted to know my thoughts on Day 5 during Day 4. Only scum could know that Lyth would be scum and that there would be a Day 4. A townie may be confident that Lyth was scum, but only a Mafia member would know for sure.
I didn't know for sure, Already explained this.
2. Lyth defended DZLE in this post (near the bottom). Lythium is scum. Why would she defend a townie?
Again, in order to place suspicion on me during today, so you could lynch me out. Maybe after you got the wagon rolling, and saw the votes, you panicked, conspired with Lythium for her to die, and since she had defended me, now that we know she was Mafia, it makes me seem super suspicious.
Well played.

3. DZLE started the rPSI bandwagon. Ndayday may have cast suspicion, but DZLE admittedly got the ball rolling.
I did admit to get the ball rolling, but I also said in the beginning I was just doing it to see where It went, and it was 100% subject to change.
Frag, I hope you can see through his little scheme. There's a lot stacked against me here, I've done my best to try to get out of this. Eh, I'll probably die. It's OK, this game was really fun. Good job to everyone, well played. Let's just hope it ends up the right way ;)

Let's get a win for town!
I agree with you there, It's been a fun game and we are nearing the end, and I PROMISE YOU, Town will win. Because YOU are scum, not me. And I KNOW this, because I am town, FRAG is town, which leaves you. The last piece of scum in this town. Well played to all indeed.

All we can do is wait for Fragbait.

VOTE: Vrael
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
Theres no such thing as a Tie, If there is one Mafia and one Town remaining, Mafia wins >.<
Because mafia kills the final town at the night. >.<
 

fragbait

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
4,230
Location
Over the skies of Emeria.
Question to the remaining two town.

Assume for a moment that you are scum. What are you going to do in order to make it through the night? How would you make yourself look unsuspicious in the eyes of the rest?
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
Eyes of the rest? To be honest, the only one that matters here is you. You are garunteed town. Vrael thinks i'm mafia, I think he's mafia. It's obvious one of us is lying, because there are 3 people left.

To make it through the night as a mafia, you'd have to get the only remaining town, You, to vote for the other remaining town, Vrael, in this situation because you are having me roleplay as mafia. Once you vote for the other town, mafia hammers, and game over. Night doesnt matter at that point.
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
For me to survive the day, IF I was Mafia, would be trying to lay as much suspicion on Vrael as possible. If I can make it seem like He is the most suspicious, and get you, a guaranteed town to lean towards voting on him, then when you vote, mafia hammer, mafia win.

That's how a Mafia player would play out this situation.

Which is exactly what Vrael tried to do with his long post concerning me, and where he voted for me.
 

¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,115
Location
Chicago, IL
dzle, you essentially just admitted ti being scum. "if i were scum, id put as much suspicion on vrael as possible." thats exactly what you did yesterday and today.

ill expand when i get on a computer. please dont vote or anything until i can post. i dont have too much more to say but id lik to formulate my thoughts effectively and using my phone is annoying.
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
How is that admitting i'm scum? You seem desperate, Vrael.

Let me quote Fragbait:
"Assume for a moment that you are scum. What are you going to do in order to make it through the day?"

Therefor, I told him what scum would do. Obviously. It doesnt take a genius to see that any person with a brain would do that as scum. And yeah I'm putting suspicion on you, but are you saying you are NOT putting it on me? You are trying to get rid of me, for your win, as much as I'm trying to get rid of you, for towns win.

It's up to frag. He is the middle man.

I was simply explaining what you, too, were doing.
 

¯\_S.(ツ).L.I.D._/¯

Smash Legend
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
12,115
Location
Chicago, IL
How is that admitting i'm scum? You seem desperate, Vrael.

Let me quote Fragbait:
"Assume for a moment that you are scum. What are you going to do in order to make it through the day?"

Therefor, I told him what scum would do. Obviously. It doesnt take a genius to see that any person with a brain would do that as scum. And yeah I'm putting suspicion on you, but are you saying you are NOT putting it on me? You are trying to get rid of me, for your win, as much as I'm trying to get rid of you, for towns win.

It's up to frag. He is the middle man.

I was simply explaining what you, too, were doing.
That wasn't my point. Yes, it makes sense for scum to throw suspicion on people. But you said "If I were scum, I would throw suspicion on Vrael." That's exactly what you just did. You said that's what you would do as scum, so are you saying that you would play the same way whether you were scum or town ? I'm confused.

If I were scum, I would try to clog frag's mind with as much doubt as possible. If I (as scum) were able make him unsure of who to vote for, then he would have to either guess (50% chance I would win) or not vote (100% chance I would win). So yeah. Clarity is a good town weapon.

frag, I'd like to know your thoughts at this point.
 

DZLE

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
4,955
Location
Planar Fields
This is my first game. I'd probably play the same way no matter what side I was on. So yeah, if that answers your question.

I too would like to hear from Frag. He's up for a prod soon.
 

fragbait

Smash Master
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
4,230
Location
Over the skies of Emeria.
I've been looking through some of the previous pages, the previous days. I really don't feel like making a huge quote, so I'm just going to fire and hope that it's Town's win.

VOTE:DZLE
Nothing personal dude.

GO TOWN.
(deuces)
 

DtJ Jungle

Check out my character in #GranblueFantasy
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
24,020
Location
Grancypher
GAME OVER


....






DZLE, mafia goon has been lynched!


TOWN WINS

HOORAY!


I will post role PM's, actions, and thoughts on each player in a moment
 
Top Bottom