#HBC | Kary
Fiend of Fire
How is my post scummy? What did I say in there that seems like scum trying to pull something? You want my opinion of these players? I'm pretty sure I've posted that reads list twice now. I've been operating under the assumption that they're both town. However, given the current claim situation, it seems likely (not guaranteed, but likely) that there's at least one scum between them. So what's the harm? Why shouldn't I be willing to let the situation play out, and find the likely scum? The scenario he lays out allows for my actual scumread, Rajam, to still die by bullet. Why should I, as town, not be open to this?
Let me be completely clear. By 'letting this scenario play out' do you mean you're fine with lynching Rake toDay, because at some point it will give you a scum?I'm not, like super happy about it, but one of my townreads is claiming a guilty on the other one. I'm not above being wrong. The situation suggests that one of the 2 of my reads, in this case, is wrong. Allowing it to play out would help me figure out which one it is. Knowing which one is wrong, would help me find scum. What am i supposed to do, just ignore a GUILTY because "lol, no that's not possible, because I read you both as town, therefore this situation is illogical. Ignore.". I don't love it, but it happened.
Secondly, I would have thought that whether or not WATT is town, a Rajam shot is not going to work out. If WATT is lying, Rajam won't get shot. If WATT is telling the truth, he'll be roleblocked, or just allowed to shoot town Rajam.
p.s. Vanilla Townie