Changed my mind. My head still feels like **** but it's not as bad as it was this morning.
@Watt: The point still stands that you were slow onto the BSP wagon and only after it'd picked up a lot of steam. Despite most of the hate on BSP coming from his #144 and you posting shortly after it, you didn't really have much to say about it. Instead of taking your own stance on him, you instead ask someone else for their stance first.
hey kev you should explain why bsp is so scummy already.
You also didn't have anything to say about him at all, despite there being a fairly decent wagon forming and plenty of BSP discussion. These are some of your posts (page 6 for reference)
how solid is that rf town read badwolf? X/100=your read, what does X equal?
vinyl, why are you stifling discussion?
I mean, considering how topical BSP was back on page 5/6 and people were actually calling BSP out on avoiding the RadFic/Soup issue, I'm very surprised your play like this went unnoticed.
I mean yes you did eventually jump onto the BSP wagon after apparently ISO'ing him and deciding he was scummy, but I seriously don't see the need to ISO a player after 300 total posts.
It seriously looks like an attempt to justify your late jump onto the wagon:
Finished my ISO (and some toast).
Glad there was actually substance there so I no longer have to give KevMo the quizzical eye for pulling out a wagon all of a sudden.
Vote: BSP
BSP: when you get here answer my previous question about Soup's intent, then explain to me what you hoped your 244 was going to clear up wrt IR. (Because the message I got out of it was just you saying "You can't prove anything" without actually going anywhere afterwords)
When I mention "prior approval" I'm talking about the approval of other town members, i.e. waiting until BSP wagon had 5 votes before jumping on.
To say you were one of two leading forces in lynching BW is also a bit of a stretch from what I've read. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't see your involvement in that incredibly clearing or obvtown.
@Rake: I believe Swiss/RadFic had your slot as town, I'm pretty sure he said somewhere that he confused you and Badwolf in his notes.
@Vanz
I've been townreading WATT because of early interaction, but the way you presented it makes me (slightly) doubt myself. I think your post was what I needed for to refresh my mind. What do you think of recent arguments against BSP? Him replacing out?
@Soup: Wrt IR being the night kill, BSP Scum would certainly be someone who'd want IR gone.
Can you point me to a page number for recent arguments against BSP? Because there haven't been any today so far.
You also mentioned that Town BSP is generally a lot more active and would be in here commenting on things. Can you talk about this meta a bit more? I haven't played with BSP before so I most likely just an inactivity thing rather than pressure (considering he weathered the whole IR storm).
Vand: when you get here talk to me about Nabe. Hopefully you've played more games with him than I have.
Am incredibly curious to see why he's so sure on BSP/Rake scum. The fact that he's chosen that direction doesn't mean much, but what he finds suspicious about him will be very telling. Right now though I don't feel NabeScum would bus his partner in this situation.
@Vanz: u srs bro?
I'll give you paranoia about us offing BW as a normal thing in mafia, but don't go into the whole "Idk if he's done things" waffling too. We already killed a scum and got reads on most of the players in this game, most of which people have been agreeing with eventually. Don't knock our methods as "idk maybe they ask questions" when it gets us results. We already have a solid direction to go in today: Kary/Nabe/Gangstalicious. If it was purely my choice I'd have us kill off Kary, then if he flips indy/town we go Gangsta. If he flips mafia we go Nabe. Don't make me have to fight off you coming in with conspiracy theories and have to dissuade you before I go on Christmas vacation.
Convince me on Kary then. Tell me what actions in particular make him a likely scum bud to Badwolf. I don't see it right now. Would you be willing to roll Nabe first? What do you think about the points I raised on MiR?