Third.A teir ***** huh? Then how come I haven't dropped my main? I've been playing him since 64, place well with him and tourneys and don't replace him with my seconds. Your theory fails, the game isn't about relying on the teir of the character to win. EDIT: Even if it is Brawl. lol
Also, might I point out that as long as the character is not useless there is some advantage to using him/her. Many players may not know how to fight Mario. Even if he is theoretically worse, he can still win because no one knows how to fight Mario. You get the element of surprise.