Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Alright, primarily concerning my seeding comment(snap's comment about ewb and josh having the same seed)...
No one has the same seed. Unless(example) you are comparing seeds 8 and 9 of a 16 man bracket(or similarly proportioned to the amount of participants.... or comparing seeds 4 and 5 from an 8 man bracket, same difference) then why in the **** would 2 people have the same seed. You have got to be ****ing kidding me........ I mean wtf. It's inconceivable to me. I make brackets all the ****ing time under more watchful eye than the nc melee pr thread lmfao. Even my drunk *** can't even get this ****(I am very drunk... x-mas eve activities). So let me be clear here....... NO ONE HAS THE SAME SEED. NO ONE. What is this seeding 1-4 value **** or whatever bull**** I've seen at tournaments? I've seen that stupid horse **** at bill fests and that's the only way something like the ewb v. josh thing could happen. The seeding is BULL****. I repeat, no one should be considered the "same" in a seeding value. It's a ****ing bracket. You seed the bracket(everyone has a different seed) then it plays out. The same concept applies to pools...... which may I remind you, this same concept was NOT applied to the most recent NCSU tourney pools(you were also given the 2nd best #1 seed, which was deserved by boss for out performing you in pools, and that's not even considering what whack *** pools they were).
And yeah, that 1-4 seeding billfest value **** should stop. I may be wrong about the 1-4 part(it might be 1-3 or 1-5, lmfaooaoaoaooaa), but I've seen it with my own eyes(people having the same "seed"/numeric value going into the tournament) attending these tournaments. I've seen myself and mohr been given a greater seeding value than dark hart and players alike(whether we're good at melee or not, still had no previous tourney experience). Karn, to say that your methods aren't subjective in comparison, let me just say that you just need to lay off the crack pipe buddy. As a panelist, you also need to step up and not let TREMENDOUS seeding discrepancies happen like they did in your favor at NCSU 4. WTF...All I gotta say.
Seeding should change after every tournament. They should NOT be based off the PR's, although the PR is essentially a good seeding system.. but it should fluctuate after every tournament, instead it just stays the same after 4 tournaments go by all the while pp and karn try to make sense of it all when the seeding for all tournaments wasn't even absolute.
And karn man... I can't believe you said your system could come close to accurately predicting tournament results. I mean....... idk what to say. In perfect competition, seeds in smash bros. are based off who does the best v. who OVER-ALL... How on earth could your system, or any system, predict a bracket in regard to melee character match-ups? Gotta be kidding me man... I mean take me for example; I'd get a horrible seed but if you put me up against a ganon main I am going to eat his *** for breakfast(smirking at chris right now).
Ranking = who does the best in tournament
NC PR = a rating/poll(good for seeding purposes, but seeding purposes demand more frequency than every 3-4 months to actually be accurate)
alright... I need to get another beer. I don't even remember what I just typed... but I will read later and add, just you wait NC.
$mike's the homie
--
k, Now I'm adding.
Seeding should be based on who v. who(what the PR is). Players should have a seeding value. A system should compare wins and losses in terms of one seeding value(x) v. another one (y)... the range(difference) between these seeding values would dictate the fluctuation of the future seeding changes. That way when the panel actually analyzes this "who v. who" crap they'll actually have something to go by. A lot of it is easy calls, but the panel is indeed being subjective by not doing what I'm saying, by the book and for everyone to see, whether they claim to have similar motives or not.
The process is self-sufficient, as I've said. As for the "strength" of the tournament(chris's comment), that could be easily factored in by the sum of the individual seeding values I discussed.... this would simultaneously account for the "strength" of the tournament(how much it's weighted in comparison to others) as well as attendance.
duuuuuuude what theDang I miss Tero's random namesearches.................
He's what made that funny.
edit:Tero if you happen to read this then it's all <3 (no homo).
duuuuuuude what the
i also miss namesearching and finding 200 black mantis post with a link of me vs pepito
Oh yeah, I saw / remember that set...was a good win for you I thought(at the time anyway lol)Dorsey, I beat mohr in tourney
So of he was seeded above me then lol
I miss mohr
![]()
Lol??ok so basically just use modified elo for everything and the pr is just the top 10 of that?
whatever.
HELL YEA BAND TOURMohr is a lot like drums
Never played em...
But I heard of em
![]()
don't make me stomp a mudhole in your monkey ***
How do I up vote this?Reading these just makes me realize that 85% of people shouldn't be talking about PRs...
Let's hear what you have to say. Bring it.Reading these just makes me realize that 85% of people shouldn't be talking about PRs...
when kevin goes up to greensboro.Mike when are you going to be better than S2J?
LOL Esam you think bing bang theory is a good show.
You don't get to have an opinion on anything at all lmao
![]()
uhh, you can bet your *** i'll bape him sideways if i ever play him one on one. but i probably won't get the chance because i don't have any plans to attend a national any time soon.Mike when are you going to be better than S2J?
YESPennys hot tho
![]()
LOLuhh, you can bet your *** i'll bape him sideways if i ever play him one on one. but i probably won't get the chance because i don't have any plans to attend a national any time soon.
lmao yeah maybe if I'm intoxicated.Hope you guys are ready to lose to my DK tomorrow night.
![]()