Yeah, it was kind of hidden in the sticky section of the general boards, where I did not expect it to be.
Anyway, my random thoughts....
Falco got robbed by G&W. IDK, I'd consider Falco to be better than D3, too.
I feel like Marth got jipped, but when I think about it, I don't know where else to put him.
R.O.B. is where he should be. Maybe not the exact place, but he is a top tier character.
Brawl is much more balance than I thought.
I agree and disagree with Stingers. People often consider characters great when great players use them. Azen is so ridiculous at reading people and predicting that he makes Lucario look top tier. However, I also think that Lucario is around the area that he should be. He really shouldn't be "way" lower. At 130%+ he is broken. You certainly have to be skilled to use him, but it's not in the technical sense, it's in the strategy and intelligence sense.
TL is dangerous in the right hands, but he's hard to kill with. He kind of takes a lot of control. Santi makes him look pretty nasty though. The truth is though, he and Quivo are the only good Toon Links I've seen. Meta does give him problems, but other than that he does well against a lot of overused characters. Of particular importance, G&W.
Diddy>DK, I agree. Diddy has a lot more going for him. Bananas are ****. I think he's going to be the Melee Fox of Brawl at some point. DK is much simpler, so he goes down to a similar debate that Lucario has. It all comes down to the balance between the ability of the character vs. the ability of the player, and a tier list is supposed to be about the former, but can sometimes get mixed up the latter. Donkey Kong is pretty **** though. F-smash is broken.
Fox is better than Wolf. That is kind of BS. Wolf just has bairs, lasers, and a long ranged f-smash. Fox has the best recover of the three, a broken hyphen smash, dair goes into so much ****, and shine of course.
Why is Lucas always so low? On paper he sounds a lot better. Why is Olimar not low-high tier?
Good for Pikachu.
Luigi is better than Bowser....
I don't think Link is in the bottom three. I don't even think he should be in the Low tier.
Yeah.