First of all, there are no patterns? No patterns whatsoever? Sakurai just throws darts at a board to craft the roster?
I don't understand why you are so insistent that we're being naive. Are you under the impression that I, or any of the other Sceptile supporters, are arguing that there isn't a possibility Sceptile doesn't make it? As if it's a garuntee? If anything, you seem to be arguing that there no possibility what-so-ever that a starter that fits well into the roster from the newest main-series pokemon entry could make it, or at least that it's not even solidly within the possibilty. That seems a little naive to me.
.
Trying to say Sakurai keeps up to the hopes of people is naive, it's universally acepted that people can't really predict him regardless of what fans consider "obvious", "very likely" or "fitting" sometimes people get lucky actually at predicting him, so this starter trinity as much likely or fitting, despite his chances, is in no way to almost guarantee Sceptile inclusion Sakurai has troled rosters and expectations since Melee, people were sure Lucario would be replaced by Zoroark that he would not return, and Lucario is back, people had cut Jigglypuff from the next game since ancient times, yet there is Jigglypuff (brawl) , is Ridley liked and demanded? let's put R.O.B. in the roster instead, is King K Rool highly demanded? let's put Olimar in the game.
No offense to R.O.B or Olimar supporters just making a point. (at least of the last game)
Talk about selective reading there, I never said "YOU THE WHOLE SCEPTILE SUPPORTERS" I said people so only if you feel identified with people then yeah so I am not saying EVERY SUPPORTER IS NAIVE please read carefully.
Lastly I don't mind having Sceptile, if you read my WHOLE post you might have read that I said to keep expectations realistic, nothing is worse than see your character don't making in the game despite the fact that there were lots of hinds or that "it makes sense", so don't be so defensive, Sceptile might be likely, might make sense, yet this is Sakurai we are talking about.
The last part of my post was a joke on the whole pattern thing Charizard and Greninja are both dual typed and even make some use of their secondary typing in smash but Sceptile isn't, if you like to see patterns because it makes sense you can't ignore this and only see the patterns that fit your hopes to increase Sceptile chances.
I only invite people to look on the higher picture, it's easy to be carried in the hype train with the whole supporters, it's better to be a bit exceptical even when evidence tells you otherwise.
So peace friend, stop using your "this guy don't want Sceptile" glasses to selective read and counter argument with someone who doesn't even mind the character , I NEVER said I don't want him, I just suggested people to keep hopes low and not let themselves be blind with everyone's hype that's all
Wise words. I think perhaps a lot of people fall into the trap of deciding on a character first, then only looking at or interpreting information in a way that 'supports' their inclusion.
Personally I think the most likely list of Pokemon reps is the characters we've already seen + Jigglypuff. Cutting a three-game SSB veteran would be outrageous, and two newcomers for what is already one of the best represented series in Smash would seem out of proportion to me. If that Pokken Fighters thing turns out to be true, though, I'd definitely be up for seeing Sceptile in that.
Really happy someone actually understood the meaning of my post congratulations to you!