The end of melee tournys?

[Shy Guy!]

When project m is done and released will it replace melee tournys?

I was wondering for a while now and I don't see why it wouldn't if it turns out good. It will be everything we thought brawl was going to be lol

Also I'm am still so exited for it to be finished, is there any recent news on it?

 

[Fried Ice Cream]

No, nope and nein.

 

[Pi]

anything less than a perfect replica of melee w/ more characters isn't going to replace melee

 

[Shy Guy!]

But isn't that the point? A perfect replica just more characters and better brawl textures? Isn't that why it's taking so ************** long to even begin beta testing?

 

[Pi]

But isn't that the point? A perfect replica just more characters and better brawl textures? Isn't that why it's taking so ************** long to even begin beta testing?

idk what fantasy world your living in but project M still has a long way to go before it's a perfect replica

not saying the endevour isn't worth it
even now i'm able to pick up characters and adapt quite quickly to how they play

but i think you're forgetting that project m isn't even suppost to be a perfect replica of melee
it's supposed to be it's own unique game with melee physics

it's not going to -replace- melee, because it's not melee, and it's not trying to be melee, it's taking things from both games and merging them into it's own game to be played

 

[Shy Guy!]

See I don't have alot of info on project m yet because I can't find much info besides YouTube videos, i'm bad at archiving smashboards

But you don't think, if done right, it will become a big tourny scene, replacing melee monthlies and some big tournys?

I feel like if brawl was heavy in tech skill and more competitive almost all melée players would of moved to it. So that's why I was thinking that about project m

am I just totally wrong? Lol

 

[gm jack]

At this point, it would have to be unrealistically close to melee, and the new characters would not have to disrupt the current metagame. Considering how intrinsically good people like MK are, I can't see that happening.

 

[Shy Guy!]

Maybe im just looking at this to open minded, like a new start of something seems very interesting. But I could see from what your saying how it couldn't replace melee. Actualy nothing can or every will :D Haha

 

[Grim Tuesday]

Too much effort, anyway. You need to learn a new game, get a Wii (if you use a GCN), hack it somehow and download P:M.

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

but it won't have the jigglypuff and marth I love to fight so much

 

[Grim Tuesday]

...
Why wouldn't it?

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

I don't think they'll every bring out that effect of melee marths, pichu, and puffs the only thing that needs chnaged about melee puff is rest doing only 5%.

Also I don't really feel like playing what ifs with you

 

[Shy Guy!]

That's very true I totaly forgot about the wii hacking and all that

 

[Grim Tuesday]

I don't think they'll every bring out that effect of melee marths, pichu, and puffs the only thing that needs chnaged about melee puff is rest doing only 5%.

Also I don't really feel like playing what ifs with you

You do realise that once they figure out landing detection and L-Cancelling during hit-lag, Marth will be EXACTLY the same as in Melee.

 

[Siglemic]

people who actually love melee probably won't main project m instead

i'm not saying project m won't be a good game though, i'm looking forward to it

 

[LLDL]

Closed thread!

 

[Shy Guy!]

why chain ace!?!?!?!

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

I don't know if it's techical enough for me to play. Yes i've seen shiz wiz matches : P

melee players have to make everything hard

that's what she said to ruin it for anyone wanting to try it

that's what she said.

 

[LLDL]

Because there have been several other threads discussing the same thing.

 

[Grim Tuesday]

I don't know if it's techical enough for me to play. Yes i've seen shiz wiz matches : P

melee players have to make everything hard

that's what she said to ruin it for anyone wanting to try it

that's what she said.

How can it not be technical enough for you?

IT IS MELEE >.>

 

[Revven]

Too much effort, anyway. You need to learn a new game, get a Wii (if you use a GCN), hack it somehow and download P:M.

You only need an SD Card and can use PM without hacking your Wii, it's called Stack Smash. But hacking your Wii is beneficial anyway, so I don't see why you wouldn't do it other than being afraid to.

 

[Charlesz]

project m is a sad and futile attempt to duplicate melee. If you want to play a good game, just play melee.

 

[UltimateHaxor123]

nothing will ever replace melee

plus projectM will be nothing more than brawl+, a side event at tourneys...except it will be 100x better than brawl+ but still 100x worse than melee :D (brawl+ is 100x better than brawl. you do the math)

 

[Revven]

project m is a sad and futile attempt to duplicate melee. If you want to play a good game, just play melee.

It's not a "sad attempt". Secondly, it's a sequel and it's not even done. And if you haven't even played it yet then you shouldn't be so prejudice towards it.

 

[Geist]

Bleh people and their theories.
Here's a theory: play the game you like. This may be a hard concept for some to grasp but it'll sink in over time.

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

Chalesz has spoken we must respect his wisedom. But I would think a melee verison of snake/diddy would be broken unless you rush them like falco or something

 

[Zodiac]

I loled when I read "Replace melee" ...That should be enough of an answer

 

[Quic]

Had project M been brawl's official release instead of what Brawl is now, every single person would've switched over, but Brawl made a big separation in the community, I don't think the Melee players will want to move from there game due to what brawl did to melee.
Not to **** with Brawl, it sounded like I was pointing fingers to Brawl, I'm not, but it sure as hell made me sceptical to other games, even though Project: M is fun, I played it for like 30 minutes.

 

[Teczer0]

A lot of people will probably play Project M for fun.

I think its incredibly doubtful that it will overtake melee completely, but this is all baseless conjecture <lol pheonix wright puns =D> so yea really theres not much to be said.

Melee survived its biggest test (brawl) so I think we're good for a while