I think that tier list Xie start on DL is kinda ridiculous. I think they're waaaaaay too strict with their rules. I could understand trying to keep people on-topic and minimize flaming but all of that ... formatting stuff is overkill. That makes me want to read/participate in it less, if anything. I think people are just going to lose interest in that thread early because it's just too much effort to keep up with his demands, on a topic most people don't really care that much about.
I do agree tier lists are necessary, and people complain about them way too much. Though I dislike how that tier list was made from only Xie's opinions. I get he's one of the best players outside of Japan, but even high level players can be biased.
I also disagree with his ranking system. I think it's extremely vague doesn't cover all of the aspects we typically think of when ranking characters. Some things he puts too much emphasis on and others he doesn't really talk about at all. He's basically trying to redefine how we think about character strengths and rankings, and that does not sit well with me at all.
Makoto announcer is horrid. Both A and B too...
Probably my least favorite except for maybe Carl.