*Cam*
Smash Lord
Actually, 9th. Mahg is 8th.yeahhh, I honestly wasn't expecting to get anything. My tournament performance hasnt been all that great. I was completely surprised that the final list gives me 8th.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Actually, 9th. Mahg is 8th.yeahhh, I honestly wasn't expecting to get anything. My tournament performance hasnt been all that great. I was completely surprised that the final list gives me 8th.
oh whoops, either way, I was expecting 10th or nothing.Actually, 9th. Mahg is 8th.
I honestly don't care either way. To be honest, I think the PR itself is virtually meaningless, so we can do whatever we want with it. If we want to have an honorable mention list, there's really no reason not to. If we for some reason don't want one, then we don't have to have one. Thing is, I don't think anyone really cares about this list besides us, so why not do what we want and not worry about how it looks to others?If I'm not mistaken, Aloha, Cam, and Twinster were those who received votes but didn't make the cut.
That being said, I don't see why an "honorable mentions" list should be made. Sort of defeats the purpose of a ten-spot PR if we say, "Oh, and these people are pretty good, too." It adds nothing of value to the list itself.
I'd be more receptive to it if (for some reason) we were voting on superlatives, and only one person filled each specific superlative, because it wouldn't be a ranking, so much as who is the very best; showing the people nominated would make sense there. Thing is, this is just supposed to highlight the top ten players, and nothing more. Adding an honorable mention just seems to make the people who didn't make the cut feel a little better about themselves.
I don't know that it necessarily motivates our state to get better as much as it motivates people to argue that whatever tournament placements they are currently getting are good enough for PR placement. It's kind of pessimistic, but I think it's also kind of true.WELL i like telling people that i'm "officially" a top ten player in the state.
i just bragged about it on facebook lol
nah but for real, lists like these are interesting, I like to look at pr lists from other states, I like to know "who's who", so thats appeal of lists like this. also it motivates our state to get better.
If people are unhappy with their ranking (or lack thereof), then they should step it up. If they feel they they're good enough to be higher, they should start doing better in tournaments and against individual players. There's a slight about of subjectivity going into it, as well. If someone is definitely good enough to be on the PR, then there wouldn't be a question of who should have their spot. I'm not trying to talk them down--It's just, rules are rules, and the four people who voted seem to think that those people that made it are a little better overall. That doesn't mean that the people who were nominated are really on a level lower than #10.I don't know that it necessarily motivates our state to get better as much as it motivates people to argue that whatever tournament placements they are currently getting are good enough for PR placement. It's kind of pessimistic, but I think it's also kind of true.
This attitude has already led to a kind of Participation PR, which defeats the purpose of having bragging rights about being in the top ten. What's the point of a top ten when there are only like 15-20 active players in the state?i think only certain people see it that way...and its usually people vying for like spot 9 or 10 on the list, because those are generally the most contested areas, and its often a toss up. it's not really a surprise that the people who don't make the list would feel left out because generally they are just as qualified for the last spot as the person who got it. I think its a special case in Alabama because we dont have a large number of really great players, like i'm guessing that people who place second to last in Florida tournaments aren't complaining about not making the list. the reason that aloha and slam and mahg all think they should be on the list is because they know their skill is comparable to people that are on the list. its not like they're noobs that are just running their mouths with no basis. its not so much they think their placing is good enough, its that they've played against all of us, they know how good we are, and they know they're just as good.
I think the motivation to do those things is going to be there no matter what if you are already at the tournament.I think that ultimately this makes you sit down at a tournament and say, ive got to do better. It makes you question, well I know that I'm just as good as these guys, well why don't i do as well in tournaments, or I beat this guy in tournaments whenever i face him, yet he still seems to outplace me. i feel like it makes you think about how to do better. eventually.
The people that are in those positions are going to go to tournaments anyway, whether or not there's a power rankings. They are also going to try their hardest at tournaments either way. I don't think the PR motivates those people. I think it makes people want a place higher than they are getting, but at the same time, I don't suspect it makes them try any harder. It's a tournament; money's already on the line so what more motivation do you need? I've never seen Billy practicing and heard him say, "I'm practicing to get a better spot on the PR." I don't suspect top 4-5 cares much about the PR in reality. I think their motivation is just to beat the people they play all the time (for Billy, that is Luis, Calvin, and sometimes Raf), not necessarily to earn any specific top ten placement.For players with a solid spot on the list, it definitely motivates them to get better. Once you solidify a spot on the list, you find that its not really satisfying. Then all you have is either trying to move up, or trying to do better in tournaments. (which generally coincide)
I don't disagree with you on that, but I think you were missing my point. My point was that the PR motivates people to argue, but I think it seldom has any impact on how well they play in tournament.If people are unhappy with their ranking (or lack thereof), then they should step it up. If they feel they they're good enough to be higher, they should start doing better in tournaments and against individual players. There's a slight about of subjectivity going into it, as well. If someone is definitely good enough to be on the PR, then there wouldn't be a question of who should have their spot. I'm not trying to talk them down--It's just, rules are rules, and the four people who voted seem to think that those people that made it are a little better overall. That doesn't mean that the people who were nominated are really on a level lower than #10.
That's all. Sorry about earlier; I was in a really bad mood. As for the pictures, it's neat; creates camaraderie.
You look at all 50 state PRs? Does Arizona's PR matter to you? It doesn't matter to me. I mean, maybe adjacent states to us care somewhat, like we sometimes care about GA's PR, but I don't think most people do care.yeah i look at all the state PR's.
im sure other people do too.
if youre honarable mention then you still arent top ten and people know that so i personally dont have a problem with it. buti do see reflex's point and it is a valid one. all his points are lol
Something to note is that it doesn't have to be a primary interest. When I play friendlies, I practice to learn matchups and experiment to find new options and tactics, or simply to have fun. That said, I know I like officially being considered the best player in AL, and thus making my claim actually have worth, even if the community isn't very large. The PR serves as a means to make people want to get better overall, rather than a motivator in tournament (someone can -want- first place all you like, but that doesn't make a player any better at winning). It gives them reason to read up, learn matchups, and just become a better player in general.This attitude has already led to a kind of Participation PR, which defeats the purpose of having bragging rights about being in the top ten. What's the point of a top ten when there are only like 15-20 active players in the state?
I think the motivation to do those things is going to be there no matter what if you are already at the tournament.
The people that are in those positions are going to go to tournaments anyway, whether or not there's a power rankings. They are also going to try their hardest at tournaments either way. I don't think the PR motivates those people. I think it makes people want a place higher than they are getting, but at the same time, I don't suspect it makes them try any harder. It's a tournament; money's already on the line so what more motivation do you need? I've never seen Billy practicing and heard him say, "I'm practicing to get a better spot on the PR." I don't suspect top 4-5 cares much about the PR in reality. I think their motivation is just to beat the people they play all the time (for Billy, that is Luis, Calvin, and sometimes Raf), not necessarily to earn any specific top ten placement.
I don't disagree with you on that, but I think you were missing my point. My point was that the PR motivates people to argue, but I think it seldom has any impact on how well they play in tournament.
You look at all 50 state PRs? Does Arizona's PR matter to you? It doesn't matter to me. I mean, maybe adjacent states to us care somewhat, like we sometimes care about GA's PR, but I don't think most people do care.
I like this better.It's happened to me too, admittedly, but I try to avoid doing it. When I said 2 weeks ago that I should have beaten JMIX, I was wrong. JMIX is a fantastic player and was definitely better than me at AUSOM 2. I should have said "I should have beaten JMIX in order to be worth placement on the PR."
yeah it does. i just think its interesating. then i watch the players videos on youtube and like... just search them and stuff. idk believe me or not i think its pretty interesting. its like a way for me to check out smash scenes kinda. it doesnt do any good but i like doing it and i find it interesting to see what other states are doing.You look at all 50 state PRs? Does Arizona's PR matter to you? It doesn't matter to me. I mean, maybe adjacent states to us care somewhat, like we sometimes care about GA's PR, but I don't think most people do care.
Before I respond, I want to note that I'm not trying to hold up the update by having this discussion (by all means, update Kola). I know in the past Kola has refrained from updating b/c of stuff like this.Something to note is that it doesn't have to be a primary interest. When I play friendlies, I practice to learn matchups and experiment to find new options and tactics, or simply to have fun. That said, I know I like officially being considered the best player in AL, and thus making my claim actually have worth, even if the community isn't very large. The PR serves as a means to make people want to get better overall, rather than a motivator in tournament (someone can -want- first place all you like, but that doesn't make a player any better at winning). It gives them reason to read up, learn matchups, and just become a better player in general.
The PR also serves as a list of "who to beat" for out-of-state, as well as signifies that we have an active scene at all. New players see it and will say, "I want to be recognized," and will start practicing and going to tournaments. Out-of-state players will try to test their mettle, as well as can expect decent turn-outs at our tournaments if they see that there are people that actually play. We don't really pay attention to Mississippi Brawl, because they don't appear to have much of a scene, and a lack of power-ranked players is going to make other people not even bother making the drive to a MS tournament, due to perceived lack of interest.
I'm not sure if the Alabama Thread has an updated player directory, but that may be good to have on the side in the OP for this thread, to show that the scene is active.
I don't think we do have a lot of players. If you think a crew is a clique, so be it, but it's better than people just not playing period. I still see being in a crew as one step away from going to tournaments. If one person in the crew goes to a tournament, chances are they can get several people to join them.we have a lot of players, just not many of them are good.
this is one of hte differences between the brawl and melee communities, for some reason the brawl community is full of "cliques" and people don't travel as much and people don't to tournaments as much, and people don't care as much about getting good at the game. i couldn't pinpoint the exact reason but i'm sure some of it has to do with the game itself in that it appeals to more "casual" players, because its easier to get in to. but this is something we as a community have to actively tackle, by helping people get into the game, and having more local tournaments. the problem with this community, especially new players is that we hate losing so much more than the melee comunnity. We've had like 30 member tournaments in tuscaloosa, where half the new people would leave after seeing how good some of us were, so we're down to like 12 ppl for singles. we have to figure out how to combat that.
I've noticed a lot of people completely underestimate each other. There's kind of this attitude that if they haven't played them and they are not on the PR, they must not be good. It's simply not true. I mean, the basis that you are judging the other player as "bad" might be the same basis that someone else might judge you as bad. Maybe they also haven't been playing to their full potential. That's why, like you said, talk is cheap unless you can back it up in tournament when the pressure's on.also, obviously everyone is biased to themselves. that doesn't make them wrong. sometimes I'll lose to a person who I know is a bad player. I'm not wrong that he's a bad or mediocre player, and i'm not wrong that playing at my full potential I would have won. other people can't see this because they're not me, they don't know what i'm capable of. but what people don't realize is that all that matters is coming back and winning it next time, and talk is cheap. but eventually the more you play great players you come to learn that.
Ironically, that just helps prove my point that the PR does not help motivate people to win. Someone with a PR placement is more intimidating to go up against in tourney. Also, people are willing to accept that 9th placement if they know 9th will get them on a PR list. If they have nothing to gain from getting 9th, then they wouldn't settle and might try harder to win.to counter your point about "well if you're at a tournament, you're going to try to do good anyway"
i disagree that everyone does this.
there was a time, and i'm sure a lot of people have done this, where I would look at who was at a tournament and determine my placement from that before the tournament even started. I'd see billy, geo, calvin, reflex, and elev8. and say, "welp i guess i'm getting 9th at this tournament". I would look at my bracket, and see that i'm running into reflex in second round, and go ahead and figure out who I would be facing in losers.
and i know lots of people do this.
but i've realized this is not the mindset to have. I'm ready to get better and pull of that upset. I'M COMING FOR YOU GUYS
Sorry. It was a pretty long rant.I felt as if I just read an essay.
Okay Cam, I'll update. Though it is probably a bit late to point out this question I've had.
Did people really place Mahg not knowing his bracket progress? Theory based update ftw
New plans added to the second post. I'll be taking a bit of time to chop Cam's post into sections.
People used the number results a fair deal, and at the tournaments he's been to, he's placed rather well, based on that.Did people really place Mahg not knowing his bracket progress? Theory based update ftw
- Invite people over, whether you know them a lot, or hardly at all. You never know how it will turn out unless you try.Recruiting has to take place locally, not on the state level, which is why crews are extremely important in my opinion. You can't shout at a dozen villages from the top of a mountain and expect anyone to hear you. You have to be in those villages to get anyone's attention. If we had a good set of 6 or 7 crews in AL, all of them having 10-15 people, we would only be one step away from getting fantastic tournament attendance. It doesn't take living in a large city to get a good crew, you can do it in a small town, which is why the idea of 6 to 7 crews isn't outrageous at all.
But how can we get new people locally? I can only tell you what worked for us, as it is certainly not the only way. We recruited in Madison by constantly inviting new people that we barely new to come and play. A lot of people actually know the basics of how to play brawl (i.e.- the controls) and have played it before with their friends. We made a point of not comparing the players to each other ("Jimmy, you are so much better than Johnny"). It turns people off to do so, and it makes them not want to come back. We just constantly gave them encouragement AND we would step out if we won a bunch in a row. We let the inexperienced players play each other a lot, so they wouldn't just get frustrated against us and never brawl with our group again. We made sure to tell them what they were doing well along with what they could do better, while trying not to sound arrogant or take the game too seriously.
Even I get tired of playing only Brawl for a long period of time. Don't be afraid to try other games. I'd recommend Mario Kart, The Legend Of Zelda 4 Swords, Bomberman, or any other really enjoyable party game. Remember for now we're just trying to get more people in Brawl itself. So don't play too much of it so where they become sick of it, but enough so where it isn't forgotten.Another thing we have going for us is that we don't always play brawl. We have other things going on while some people are playing. People bring their laptops and play Starcraft and Minecraft. Someone introduced Magic the Gathering to the group at one point and some people will play that. So, when someone gets worked up about losing at brawl, they can go do something else and chill out instead of brooding about their losing streak. I think in general when it's brawl brawl brawl brawl brawl all the time, people can get tired of it. We try to mix it up by having diversions from brawl to keep things interesting. We're more than just brawl friends, and that makes us want to hang out more, which leads to more brawl.
Yeah, but he only beat unranked people and got byes.People used the number results a fair deal, and at the tournaments he's been to, he's placed rather well, based on that.
lol well putYah I beat scrubs but I didn't lose to scrubs either
Just pick Wario and airdodge until the Smash Ball appears. Get it, because you're Wario, and win. Do it enough times, and they won't want to play with items on.I wish there were more people in Mobile that would play brawl and give it a chance with items off. Our crew is 6 people counting Alias in Auburn and two people who are more into other games and only play on occasion. I've met about 6 people who will play, but only with items.
You may have to indulge them a bit with items. Agree to play with items on sometimes and off at other times. Once they see how well you and Rag play, they are going to start wondering how to get better. As they start trying to get better, they will like items less and less. They will start to realize why competitive players don't like to play with items on. You really do have to treat items as a legitimate way to play the game though. There's no "right" way to play brawl. If you sound snobby and always complain about items, then they just aren't going to enjoy playing with you, even if items are turned on.I wish there were more people in Mobile that would play brawl and give it a chance with items off. Our crew is 6 people counting Alias in Auburn and two people who are more into other games and only play on occasion. I've met about 6 people who will play, but only with items.