The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[biigshaq]

DJ Octavio similar to Bowser Jr.

WYR have no spikes or no grabs?

 

[Freduardo]

DJ Octavio similar to Bowser Jr.

WYR have no spikes or no grabs?

No spikes.

Grabs break blocks. It’s too key a Rock Paper Scissors component.

WYR have a Codename STEAM character or an Ever Oasis character?

(holy crap, it took me 14 pages to use the obvious acronym)

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

No spikes.

Grabs break blocks. It’s too key a Rock Paper Scissors component.

WYR have a Codename STEAM character or an Ever Oasis character?

(holy crap, it took me 14 pages to use the obvious acronym)

Idk much about Codename: STEAM, so I guess an Ever Oasis character.

WYR have a Gamecube controller playable in Smash or a NES Zapper playable in Smash?

 

[Blargg888]

Gamecube Controller


Would you rather have a Final Destination covered in Ice, or a Battlefield where all 3 platforms occasionally change into lava hazards?

 

[CannonStreak]

The Battlefield with lava hazards.

Would you rather have Ice Climbers or a new retro character?

 

[Blargg888]

The Battlefield with lava hazards.

Would you rather have Ice Climbers or a new retro character?

Ice Climbers.

Would you rather have the roster reduced by 1/2, but you get to make the cuts, or have the roster reduced by 1/3, but somebody else makes the cuts?

 

[Zerp]

Ouch, that's tough but I'll have to go with 1/2 with me making the cuts.

Would you rather get Bubsy (Bubsy) or Goku (Dragon Ball) as a newcomer?

 

[Blargg888]

Ouch, that's tough but I'll have to go with 1/2 with me making the cuts.

Would you rather get Bubsy (Bubsy) or Goku (Dragon Ball) as a newcomer?

Goku.

Would you rather have another clone of Link, or another clone of Mario?

 

[Zerp]

I'm going with another Link clone.

Would you rather buff Cloud and Diddy Kong or buff Sheik and Bayonetta?

 

[CannonStreak]

Buff Cloud and Diddy.

Would you rather Target Smash or a new form of Break the Targets?

 

[Blargg888]

Buff Cloud and Diddy.

Would you rather Target Smash or a new form of Break the Targets?

Target Smash.

Would you rather have Pichu return with a new moveset, or have Raichu added as a newcomer?

 

[CannonStreak]

Raichu added as a newcomer.

Would you rather have Samurai Goroh or Black Shadow (both from F-Zero) as a playable character?

 

[Blargg888]

Raichu added as a newcomer.

Would you rather have Samurai Goroh or Black Shadow (both from F-Zero) as a playable character?

Black Shadow.

Would you rather add Phoenix Wright or Professor Layton as a newcomer?

 

[CannonStreak]

Black Shadow.

Would you rather add Phoenix Wright or Professor Layton as a newcomer?

Phoenix Wright.

Would you rather have creative stage hazards or creative character abilities?

 

[Blargg888]

Phoenix Wright.

Would you rather have creative stage hazards or creative character abilities?

Honestly, Creative stage hazards.

Smash 4 actually already did a lot with creative character abilities, but I always felt like a lot of the stages in it were lacking a bit on the creative side. So I want more creative stages.

Would you rather have Megaman X or Zero as a newcomer?

 

[CannonStreak]

Honestly, Creative stage hazards.

Smash 4 actually already did a lot with creative character abilities, but I always felt like a lot of the stages in it were lacking a bit on the creative side. So I want more creative stages.

Would you rather have Megaman X or Zero as a newcomer?

Zero as a newcomer.

Would you rather have Young Link or Toon Link?

 

[Blargg888]

Zero as a newcomer.

Would you rather have Young Link or Toon Link?

Toon Link

Would you rather have Wolf return, or Krystal as a newcomer?

 

[CannonStreak]

I'd rather have Wolf return.

Would you rather have the Donkey Kong Hammer item only or the Golden Hammer item only?

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

Sorry, didn't see the new comments. Move along.

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather have the Donkey Kong Hammer item only or the Golden Hammer item only?

DK Hammer.

WYR add/keep Red Shells but remove Blue shells or vice versa?

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

I wish there was a way to delete your own comment.

 

[CannonStreak]

DK Hammer.

WYR add/keep Red Shells but remove Blue shells or vice versa?

Vice versa.

Would you rather a new Earthbound stage or a new F-Zero stage?

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

Ignore this. Some people can type faster than me, it seems.

 

[Crazy456Rhino]

Vice versa.

Would you rather a new Earthbound stage or a new F-Zero stage?

New Earthbound stage, since Earthbound has a lot more potential.

Would you rather have New Donk City or the Great Plateau added as a new stage?

 

[Blargg888]

New Earthbound stage, since Earthbound has a lot more potential.

Would you rather have New Donk City or the Great Plateau added as a new stage?

New Donk City. I believe BotW has better options for stages.



Would you rather have more music remixes, or more original music overall?

 

[FamicomDisk]

New Donk City. I believe BotW has better options for stages.



Would you rather have more music remixes, or more original music overall?

Remixes! I can listen to the original music anytime, but Smash gives us new versions of our favorite songs. It's the best of both worlds! Though I do like the inclusion of the original songs too, so I'd still like them.

Would you rather have a Mario Paint level where you can draw in a background in the Custom menu, or a Mario Paint stage where you can compose a song for it in the Custom menu with the Mario Paint music tool?

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Remixes! I can listen to the original music anytime, but Smash gives us new versions of our favorite songs. It's the best of both worlds! Though I do like the inclusion of the original songs too, so I'd still like them.

Would you rather have a Mario Paint level where you can draw in a background in the Custom menu, or a Mario Paint stage where you can compose a song for it in the Custom menu with the Mario Paint music tool?

Your 1st option , wyr have bayonetta cut or give everybody her combo potential ?

 

[nirvanafan]

Give everyone her combo potential

Would you rather have every Melee stage return or every Brawl stage

 

[Blargg888]

Give everyone her combo potential

Would you rather have every Melee stage return or every Brawl stage

Every Brawl Stage.

Would you rather have Mushroom Kingdom 64 return, or get Metal Caverns as a new stage?

 

[biigshaq]

Mushroom Kingdom 64.

WYR have even more Mario characters or even more FE characters?

 

[FamicomDisk]

I think I'd prefer more Fire Emblem simply because there's more unused potential there than with Mario. Mario's got a pretty diverse cast of fighters right now, but Fire Emblem only has sword users, despite there being many other weapon types in FE, along with different fighter types like those who ride horses and etc.

Would you rather all the DLC characters from Smash 4 return, but there are no new DLC characters, or none of them do, but every single DLC character in 5 is brand new, with no veterans?

 

[Blargg888]

I think I'd prefer more Fire Emblem simply because there's more unused potential there than with Mario. Mario's got a pretty diverse cast of fighters right now, but Fire Emblem only has sword users, despite there being many other weapon types in FE, along with different fighter types like those who ride horses and etc.

Would you rather all the DLC characters from Smash 4 return, but there are no new DLC characters, or none of them do, but every single DLC character in 5 is brand new, with no veterans?

All the DLC Characters from Smash 4 return.

Would you rather have Snake and Pichu return, or Young Link and Ice Climbers?

 

[-crump-]

All the DLC Characters from Smash 4 return.

Would you rather have Snake and Pichu return, or Young Link and Ice Climbers?

Ice Climbers and Young Link, solely for Ice Climbers. I miss my little ****** buddies so much

Would you rather have every item from Smash 4 return, or have every item from Smash 4 removed (with the exception of Smash Ball, Assist Trophy, and Poke Ball) and replaced with entirely new items?

 

[biigshaq]

New just for the hell of it, but I never ever use them anyways

Every character is like Ryu with inputs and variations or no more Ryu

 

[Spoon Man the Eleventh]

No more Ryu.

Would you rather have Kirby change his final smash again, or have him keep the Ultra Sword?

 

[Blargg888]

No more Ryu.

Would you rather have Kirby change his final smash again, or have him keep the Ultra Sword?

Change it again.

Would you rather have a popular anime character in Smash, or a popular movie character in Smash?

 

[Thatboyjojo]

Change it again.

Would you rather have a popular anime character in Smash, or a popular movie character in Smash?

Anime character
Wyr have tails or rayman ?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Rayman, I guess? Neither are very appealing choices to me, but Sonic already has a character. Rayman has fans, so I'd prefer him.

Would you rather they cut your main, but add your favorite character from your main's origin series, or they keep your main, but don't add any new characters from their series?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Would you rather they cut your main, but add your favorite character from your main's origin series, or they keep your main, but don't add any new characters from their series?

Keep my main. MegaMan's the only character you really need to rep his series.

WRY have Hat kid from A Hat in Time or Yooka-Laylee as a playable character?

 

[Blargg888]

Keep my main. MegaMan's the only character you really need to rep his series.

WRY have Hat kid from A Hat in Time or Yooka-Laylee as a playable character?

Hat Kid.

Would you rather have your most wanted newcomer come in as an assist trophy, or as a boss character?