The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Deleted member]

WYR have more Punch-Out music or more Final Fantasy VII music?

Final Fantasy

WYR have the next Smash game have triple the content of Ultimate in exchange for blocky, 64-esque graphics, or have roughly the same amount of content but with hyper-realistic graphics?

64 esque, I feel it'd fit better.

WYR have the next DK game canonise K. Rool's supposed semi-redemption arc from Smash, or have DK reworked in Smash to be more accurate to his source material?

Definitely have DK reworked.
WYR add Sonic R or a Mario Strikers mode to the game

 

[Mamboo07]

Sonic R

WYR have both Solaris and Dark Gaia from Sonic 06/Unleashed as a boss fight or Tetris Block as a fighter?

 

[Perkilator]

Sonic R

WYR have both Solaris and Dark Gaia from Sonic 06/Unleashed as a boss fight or Tetris Block as a fighter?

Tetris Block, but only because people might accuse Sakurai of “Sonic Bias” if those were bosses.

WYR have an HD rerelease of Brawl or Smash 64 be part of an N64 online service?

 

[Deleted member]

WYR have an HD rerelease of Brawl or Smash 64 be part of an N64 online service?

Smash 64, if no improvements to Brawl(or any Smash game)'s fighting I don't want defined graphics.
Plus we'll jump beyond Nintendo's asinine tactic of releasing the same games for the same three grey bricks every console
WYR have a Fighters Pass with only FG characters as echoes or one with all indie echoes

 

[Perkilator]

Smash 64, if no improvements to Brawl(or any Smash game)'s fighting I don't want defined graphics.
Plus we'll jump beyond Nintendo's asinine tactic of releasing the same games for the same three grey bricks every console
WYR have a Fighters Pass with only FG characters as echoes or one with all indie echoes

Indie echoes, so indies get the spotlight.

Speaking of indies, WYR have a premium Mii costume of Hollow Knight or Madeleine from Celeste?

 

[Perkilator]

Okay, restart:

WYR have a Curien Mansion stage (shameless thread plugging) or Magician Type-0 as a boss?

 

[BigRedMonster07]

A curien mansion stage
WYR have a Greek god as a boss or a greek monster as a playable character

 

[Perkilator]

WYR have a Greek god as a boss or a greek monster as a playable character

Greek god as a boss…? (you didn’t answer the question above your reply)

WYR have have a Subspace Army Assist Trophy or Caeda as a playable character?

 

[BigRedMonster07]

(you didn’t answer the question above your reply)

I have fixed that

 

[Perkilator]

Okay, lemme ask again:

WYR have a Subspace Army Assist Trophy or Caeda as a playable character?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

You don't need to bump like that. Someone will answer eventually, I've been on this thread since the beginning and I know for a fact it always comes back no matter how much downtime.

 

[Perkilator]

Okay, new month, new question; WYR have Sakura Shinguji or Axel Stone as a SEGA-created rep (as in, not like or , who were created at Platinum Games and ATLUS, respectively)?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Stop bumping! be patient!

Anyway, Sakura

WYR bring back Dojo reveals, with trailers only being reserved for super popular characters, or have all trailers be shared between a popular character and an unpopular character?

 

[Perkilator]

Stop bumping! be patient!

Anyway, Sakura

WYR bring back Dojo reveals, with trailers only being reserved for super popular characters, or have all trailers be shared between a popular character and an unpopular character?

Dojo-esque reveals.

WYR have Ayumi Tachibana or Mach Rider as a retro rep?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Ayumi

WYR replace Falcon in 64 with Muddy Mole, or replace Marth and Roy in Melee with Sonic and Tails? The replaced characters' series will be treated as a minor franchise in future instalments, only getting Spirits or Trophies.

 

[Perkilator]

Muddy Mole.

WYR replace Dr. Mario with Wario or Pichu with Heracross in Melee?

 

[LoZ00]

Muddy Mole.

WYR replace Dr. Mario with Wario or Pichu with Heracross in Melee?

Mmmmh... That's a tough one. I like Pichu more than Dr. Mario, and I like Wario more than him as well, but Heracross seems cool... I guess I'd replace Pichu with Heracross.

As a very cheap DLC (.99$) celebrating P5R, WYR have Crow as an echo of Joker or Mementos receiving an additional red and gold palette with a few P5R tracks (the new red and golden version would apply for Aria of Souls too)?

 

[Perkilator]

Mmmmh... That's a tough one. I like Pichu more than Dr. Mario, and I like Wario more than him as well, but Heracross seems cool... I guess I'd replace Pichu with Heracross.

As a very cheap DLC (.99$) celebrating P5R, WYR have Crow as an echo of Joker or Mementos receiving an additional red and gold palette with a few P5R tracks (the new red and golden version would apply for Aria of Souls too)?

Royal upgrade just for the songs. Any DLC Echoes should be free; maybe as a gift, like the Tockles Spirit.

Speaking of which, if more free gifts come in the future, WYR have free Echo fighters or free standalone stages with some extra music?*

*Say, for example, we get Poké Floats back as a stage, and we get some tracks from Sword and Shield? Or a stage based on the Last Resort from Luigi’s Mansion 3, with some tracks from LM3?

 

[LoZ00]

Speaking of which, if more free gifts come in the future, WYR have free Echo fighters or free standalone stages with some extra music?*

*Say, for example, we get Poké Floats back as a stage, and we get some tracks from Sword and Shield? Or a stage based on the Last Resort from Luigi’s Mansion 3, with some tracks from LM3?

I'd take the Echo fighters.

WYR have a rebooted Smash with a small selection newcomers and improved veterans or another Ultimate, where everyone is here?

 

[Perkilator]

I'd take the Echo fighters.

WYR have a rebooted Smash with a small selection newcomers and improved veterans or another Ultimate, where everyone is here?

In the case of “another Ultimate”, maybe a re-release on a more powerful version of the Switch, or the next console I’m general or maybe even PC

WYR replace Roy with Caeda in Melee or replace Ice Climbers with Ayumi Tachibana in Melee?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Caeda

WYR have Crash's reveal tagline be "Crash Bandicoot gives it a spin!" or "Crash Bandicoot has entered the station!"

 

[Perkilator]

Caeda

WYR have Crash's reveal tagline be "Crash Bandicoot gives it a spin!" or "Crash Bandicoot has entered the station!"

“Gives it a Spin!”

If we ever got a second SNK character, WYR have a Samurai Shodown rep or a Metal Slug rep?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Metal Slug

WYR have Muddy Mole make his Smash debut (No replacements) in 64, Melee, Brawl, 3DS/Wii U, 3DS/Wii U DLC, Ultimate, Ultimate DLC, a future game, or a future game's DLC?

 

[Deleted member]

I don't want Muddy Mole in Smash. (Ultimate DLC)
WYR have this Optimus as a Mii Gunner or Buffy as a swordfighter

 

[Perkilator]

I don't want Muddy Mole in Smash. (Ultimate DLC)
WYR have this Optimus as a Mii Gunner or Buffy as a swordfighter
View attachment 270966

Optimus, purely because I know absolutely pepper jack cheese about Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

WYR have FP7 be a big-name 3rd party character, or an obscure Nintendo character?

 

[BigRedMonster07]

An obscure Nintendo character
Would you rather have Goku added to smash before you die or have Waluigi added to smash after you die.

sorry, is this too dark?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Waluigi after I die

WYR have Pac-Man added in Brawl, or Sonic added in Melee?

 

[BigRedMonster07]

sonic added in melee (fun fact, sega called sakurai and begged him to put sonic in but the game was to far into development at that point).
WYR have solo squirtle or solo ivysaur replacing solo charizard in smash 4.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Squirtle

WYR have Daisy decloned but Rosalina changed to a clone, or Lucina decloned but Ike changed to a clone?

 

[Perkilator]

Squirtle

WYR have Daisy decloned but Rosalina changed to a clone, or Lucina decloned but Ike changed to a clone?

Lucina somewhat de-cloned, by using Marth’s custom moves from Smash 4.

WYR settle for another sword wielder FE character or run a minute on a treadmill to get an FE character with a different weapon.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Preferably neither, but if I HAVE to choose I'd do with the treadmill.

Let's say all the FE characters were cut, WYR they be replaced with Zelda characters or Sonic characters?

 

[Deleted member]

WYR have FP7 be a big-name 3rd party character, or an obscure Nintendo character?

Big name 3rd party

Let's say all the FE characters were cut, WYR they be replaced with Zelda characters or Sonic characters?

Sonic, without hesitation.
WYR have an option to make the characters and stages look N64 or Sackboy

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

N64

WYR have a Mario Kart + CTR crossover where you can choose between CTR mechanics or MK mechanics, or a simple Sonic DLC pack for Mario Kart 8 Deluxe?

 

[Perkilator]

Sonic DLC pack.

WYR have Jill Valentine ended FP Vol. 1 or started FP Vol. 2?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

End FP Vol 1. I'd rather have Jill Dozer through.

WYR replace Joker or the ARMS rep with Crash Bandicoot?

 

[LoZ00]

End FP Vol 1. I'd rather have Jill Dozer through.

WYR replace Joker or the ARMS rep with Crash Bandicoot?

I was just singing to myself "Wake up, get up, get out there" while scrolling so... R.I.P. ARMS. Although I'd rather cut Hero or Terry.

WYR have a remix featuring lyrics for Bowser's Galaxy Generator or for Calamity Ganon?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Galaxy Generator

WYR have Boss Battle from Learn with Pokemon: Typing Adventure, or Break Point 2 from Mario Tennis 64 as a music track?

 

[Perkilator]

Galaxy Generator

WYR have Boss Battle from Learn with Pokemon: Typing Adventure, or Break Point 2 from Mario Tennis 64 as a music track?

Boss Battle.

Speaking of music, WYR Game & Watch Gallery music or more Punch-Out music?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

G&W Gallery.

WYR have a prototype for Mother 64 or Twelve Tales: Conker 64 leaked?

 

[Deleted member]

WYR have Jill Valentine ended FP Vol. 1 or started FP Vol. 2?

FP1, to move Byleth out lol.

WYR have a prototype for Mother 64 or Twelve Tales: Conker 64 leaked?

Mother 64, I can't stand Conker.
WYR get rid of all shapeshifting stages or all side-scrolling stages