One of the main problems I have found with Brawl is that it is relying simply on more basic techniques. Pretty much if you just space and camp, and turn the game into a scene no more complicated then how a basketball fan can tell how good his favorite basketball team is and why, with statements like "oh, they play an aggressive defense, they play man-to-man defence, etc." Sure, there is skill involved, but it's less. Hell, unless you're ********, it's hard to make mistakes in Brawl...
Making Brawl competitive will be like making tic-tac-toe a little more complicated and subsequently competitive... ...now I was never really good at Melee, and I know I won't be good at Brawl, but I can definatly tell these things about the games...
The other day I had a Toon Link fall down at my Marth from the sky, I u-tilted right when the Toon Link was about to get to me, he air dodged, and was able to land and then d-smash me before I was able to shield after my u-tilt! WTF, this game is allowing noobs to do pretty much whatever they want to do without fear of consequence, baring say a wiffed smash attack. All they have to do is simple camping, spacing, and not do anything dumb and they can compete with the best players out there. Sure I haven't seen Ken play a random player who isn't dumb, but isn't amazing yet, but this all makes sense to me.
I don't know if it makes any sense to you guys, but taking advantage of things that simply couldn't be done in Melee was the only things that made me decent at the game, but now, there is such freedom that basic, real-life-football strategy is as complicated as it gets. I don't think I'll like Brawl at all...