Tenth Ever Smash Tourny in CONNECTICUT: a Leisure Event - Wallingford CT - Apr 19, 08

[S.P.I.C. TOM]

Fox/Falco can simply laser camp forever on the stage and half more than half the cast never be able to hit them back in Melee due to the fin. And now the fin is a wall and I've heard people like Chillin specifically counterpick that level and go DDD and infinite wall CG, it should never happen in tourny IMO >_>

yes actually we should

Couldn't the person just pick a character that can't be chaingrabbed when going to corneria. There are a good amount of characters that can't be CG'ed by DDD. Another thing is why don't you just ban all infinites instead of banning levels? That's what is done in other fighters like MVC2(Marvel vs Capcom 2), Soul Caliber 2, and Street Fighter Alpha 3. Let's try banning the techniques instead of banning the level. This is brawl not melee let's change up the rules a little bit.

 

[_V_]

Blah I want to go...

Edit//Tom makes a pretty good point.

 

[Cort]

I think the next time someone says something about Brawl not being Melee I'm going to explode.

The stage is banned.

 

[_V_]

Hey Cort did you know Brawl isn't Melee...

I believe it goes something like this...

STFU NOOB!!!!!

LoLz

 

[Zombie Lucille Ball]

DDD's CG isn't an infinite. It ends when you run out of stage. I suppose you could just ban doing it against a wall because that can be considered stalling/gay. Then again Corneria is just stupid camp gay fest anyway.

 

[S.P.I.C. TOM]

I think the next time someone says something about Brawl not being Melee I'm going to explode.

The stage is banned.

[sarcasm]Why don't we just ban all flat levels too![/sarcasm]

If I decide to be either DK,Bowser,Mario, Samus,or Luigi because they can get CG'ed without a wall what do you do then? These are the characters that I know of that can be CG'ed and there's a video on youtube on it . How about we just ban the character DDD to solve the issue.

Here is the video for DDD's infinite with no walls
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23UyrHXK36A

Here is another video as to why we should ban the technique instead of banning the level.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8EKKEZPAE4

I thought these were good examples.

 

[Cort]

It's not stalling, but it is gay which isn't a reason to ban something. Corneria is being banned because of the fin essentially dividing the level, making it easily campable. The wall there is just a side reason to ban it.

edit// That chain grab takes -some- skill to do, and it can only be done 5 times before grab degradation takes into affect and he has to move forward again. You can stall it by grab attacking but it's very easy to escape grabs in Brawl, so learn to struggle.

 

[S.P.I.C. TOM]

In the first video that I put up as an example they found a way to reset the CG and make it an infinite with mario and luigi. I think you should ban the technique instead of banning the level/levels.

 

[Cort]

You can struggle out of 2 grab attacks at the %s he was trying at. The tactic won't be banned.

 

[S.P.I.C. TOM]

Cort, what im trying to get at is switching up the rules because we are just at the start of this game and if we don't have an open mind about switching up the rules then really couldn't be a different game.

 

[Cort]

You're the one trying to ban a tactic <_>

 

[trademark0013]

wait, if its a new game, why would we wanna switch up the rules so early?

 

[noodles]

wait, if its a new game, why would we wanna switch up the rules so early?

exactly well said.

 

[wWw Dazwa]

Another thing is why don't you just ban all infinites instead of banning levels? That's what is done in other fighters like MVC2(Marvel vs Capcom 2), Soul Caliber 2, and Street Fighter Alpha 3. Let's try banning the techniques instead of banning the level.

HAHAHA OH WOW

tom you don't know what you're talking about

the only infinite banned in MvC2 is a dead body infinite...which isn't even used for the sake of doing damage, it's used to stall out a match and is more like Melee's Rising Pound/Peach Bomber stalling...WHICH WAS BANNED.

Meanwhile you have easy as **** infinites on assist characters, Iron Man being able to start an infinite, and once he has it going, WINS THE ROUND, and the ****ton other infinites in Marvel because Marvel is MAHVEL BABEE

edit: sorry if my reaction to your post was harsh, tom, but the marvel community PRIDES themselves on their infinites.

 

[Banks]

If someone infinites me I'm gonna go wild up in here

call me Pittsburgh Bobby

 

[wWw Dazwa]

If someone infinites me I'm gonna go wild up in here

call me Pittsburgh Bobby

ISS MAHVEL BOBBEE!

 

[Zombie Lucille Ball]

mango sentinel

 

[S.P.I.C. TOM]

wait, if its a new game, why would we wanna switch up the rules so early?

So we can experiment and not turn it into a broken game.

HAHAHA OH WOW

tom stop talking you don't know what you're talking about

the only infinites banned in MvC2 is a dead body infinite...which isn't even used for the sake of doing damage, it's used to stall out a match and is more like Melee's Rising Pound/Peach Bomber stalling...WHICH WAS BANNED.

Meanwhile you have easy as **** infinites on assist characters, Iron Man being able to start an infinite, and once he has it going, WINS THE ROUND, and the ****ton other infinites in Marvel because Marvel is MAHVEL BABEE

So what your saying is it's ok to have an infinite in a game as long as it's difficult. That doesn't make sense to me. I am sure you wouldn't want this game to be marvel or have any infinites. Marvel is a strerched out example but look at street fighter alpha 3 Ryu has an infinite that let's say someone who wanted to pick up the game seriously but was new to it would probably be turned off by it. I am saying let's be open to new ideas instead of sticking with the same rule set as the last game. I mean they took out alot of things because it wasn't suppost to be in the game and turned off most players that wanted to play it at a serious level but said we were glitching and didn't respect the scene.

Here is the vid for ryu

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vcr0Cl7L0LM

 

[wWw Dazwa]

So we can experiment and not turn it into a broken game.



So what your saying is it's ok to have an infinite in a game as long as it's difficult. That doesn't make sense to me. I am sure you wouldn't want this game to be marvel or have any infinites. Marvel is a strerched out example but look at street fighter alpha 3 Ryu has an infinite that let's say someone who wanted to pick up the game seriously but was new to it would probably be turned off by it. I am saying let's be open to new ideas instead of sticking with the same rule set as the last game. I mean they took out alot of things because it wasn't suppost to be in the game and turned off most players that wanted to play it at a serious level but said we were glitching and didn't respect the scene.

Here is the vid for ryu

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vcr0Cl7L0LM

no, what I'm saying is, you can talk as much as you want against infinites, but don't pull examples out of your ***

 

[noodles]

whoa thats coldblooded

also MVC2, SC2, and SFA3 = toms ass?

 

[wWw Dazwa]

Tom's *** is MAHVEL BABEE

 

[Banks]

so much beef, its like a whopper

 

[noodles]

Tom's *** is MAHVEL BABEE

awwwwwww yeaa

EDIT: where the **** did cogsmooch's qoute come from?

EDIT2: delete

 

[KevinM]

Dazwa don't get upset man.. its all MAHVAL

 

[IronChief]

This thread too much for me from all the *****ing and awesomeness!

Can't wait for this tourny it is going to be amazing.

Setups ill probablly bring none but, i think banks is going too.

 

[Banks]

yea i could, but this place has tvs and doesnt need anything but my wii, BUT i will bring one for melee anyway if i have to woot woot

 

[So Fatal]

holey **** who cars about MVC2, and Sorry Tom, Im going to have agree with cort and just ban the stages, it would be too hard to monitor everyone playing and **** if you were to ban the tactic. cort is the MAN!

 

[SleepyK]

so much beef, its like a whopper

Bobby's *** is a MAHVELous whopper?



The reason why Tom's example (albeit an incorrect example) of Marvel is a valid one is because it's a long-standing and well-respected community. It's one of the largest and most successful fighting game communities in existence, and it has been for some time now.

I'm rambling, it's 4 am.

 

[wWw Dazwa]

Fixed .

Bobby's *** is a MAHVELous whopper BAYBEE

 

[trademark0013]

So we can experiment and not turn it into a broken game.

but we dont kno whats broken yet. lets jus let things play out and what gets stupid, ban

edit/ also yea, no infinites are really banned in MVC2

 

[SleepyK]

Bobby's *** is a MAHVELous whopper BAYBEE

Where his curly ***-mustache at?

 

[Zombie Lucille Ball]

somebody find that vid for noodles...I can't find it

 

[-Darc-]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZZUMjoxfZA

 

[Cort]

SCOOPS

SCOOPS HAAGEN DAZ

Wow there needs to be someone like that at every smash tourny and I'd always lose my sets from laughing too hard.

 

[Zombie Lucille Ball]

I can try.

 

[P.c. Chris]

LOL omfg its the wes of the marvel community too good.

 

[trademark0013]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZZUMjoxfZA

SCOOPS

SCOOPS HAAGEN DAZ

Wow there needs to be someone like that at every smash tourny and I'd always lose my sets from laughing too hard.

u havent played kaiba corp recently, have you?

 

[Cort]

uhhh, nope

 

[trademark0013]

u need to. its usually hilarious

 

[noodles]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZZUMjoxfZA

that explains plenty