3:





(


)









I once again feel this tier is alright as it is. However, it's posts above me that make me make votes like this...
+1

: I will just re-itterate, that I don't think Marth is any higher. However, when people down vote him when they have no real reason to calls for such countervoting.
While results do mean a lot, they don't mean everything. For a start, Marth does have good enough results to at least hang with these characters, with better results that some of the characters in this tier in the first place.
The reason why Marth is this high and Duck Hunt isn't, is because Marth isn't held back by a slew of flaws. While both Marth and Duck Hunt have results, lets compare them as characters a moment.
If we went by your theory, Yoshi and Peach should be at least in tier 5, because their results are actually quite poor and lacking. However, they aren't, because they have multiple positive traits that keep them up there (this is why I put Yoshi up a bit higher than normal; he lacks notable results, but they can only keep a good character down so far I believe). This is what Duck Hunt lacks, and overall has more negatives than he does positives.
Can I also point out that False gets results with Marth, not just Pugwest and Mr. E? I can't remember the player's name, but there is a Japanese player doing stuff with Marth recently (came 5th I believe at Karisuma), and that says a lot about the character when Japan are notorious for having poor views on him. Marth has more players than just these two.
Rant over.