Super Mario RPG Mafia: Hilt lynched, Town wins!

[UTDZac]

Explanation of my reads from earlier:

Raz town
The post where I said a bunch of my reads I made while laying in bed reading over this game for 30min. I was tired but was able to come up with reasons for my reads. Since then I've forgotten why I thought Raz was town (see one of my previous posts). I went back and looked and found why I initially saw Raz as town, his #723 where he says "The second I will reveal in due time." I quickly assumed he knew what the correct town color was, blue, which allowed him to say Rajam was town and RR was scum (for making it up). He then reveal his 2nd second in his #743, "Red Ryu claimed the wrong town color, Rajam claimed the correct one. That's why I knew immediately" which matched my thinking.

Hilt town
Hilt talking about Rajam lynch in his #658 and #673 followed by his #694 make it seem like he's not quite sure what to do. I get a town vibe from this.

Raj town
We know this is an OS game, and we know OS likes to experiment with fun, flavorful roles (see any of his past games). I find his role claim to be quite believable. And to top it off, he apparently picked the right color of blue even without a sample PM, which I find unlikely for scum to do.

Tin man town
Waiting on him to answer my question first.

Red ryu scum
Explained why early. Add to that with him wanting to make a case on me now.

 

[Krystedez]

I thought I didn't have my vote on RR. I guess I do. and I guess it stays. He's not a L-1 right now, right?

And why is RR going back and forth. "Lynch me now if you want, my info will prove stuff lolz" into "GET UR FILTHY MITTS (votes) OFF MEH, I MIGHT GET QL'D!"

I'm just confused.

The only thing that makes me think weirdly about UTDZ is the Tin Man Town stance. I think that's just a little bit too weird, and to right away think an inactive new player is town from one contributing post makes me think of scum iterating plainly someone not of their faction.

That is my only feeling about UTDZ at this point.

Red Ryu. You should provide more information about your role if you think you're going to convince anyone, especially since you're practically our lynch target at this point, regardless of what conjectures you come up with on anyone else. You're defending yourself. Not diverting attention from yourself. Figure it out, or you're gunna die in a lie or stupid mistake, one or the other.

 

[Krystedez]

In other words I'm not buyin the Bowyer talk, again. You don't have any evidence other than poking at one little sentance. I mentioned Bowyer as much as Yardovich. Let me ask; is Yard in this game? Is there ANYTHING you can confirm?

 

[Omni]

been reaaaaally busy with the VP and President of the company here at the office today. ill catch up soon.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

There is no reason Tinman should be a town read then, your assuming he town with no justification.

Rajam your based on a role, which could also have been viewed as a useless role if you think about it to what T-Block has said.

Me making a case on you makes me scum, OMGUS at it's finest.

 

[UTDZac]

RR, you misunderstand. I don't need his response to confirm/deny my town read. I merely want a response from him before I share why I think he's town.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

So you have no reason to think he is town, UTD rather your waiting for something for him to say to have people believe he is town.

What about the other points I brought up about you?

~

Kryz everything about my role is what I said.

I am Frogfucius - Wise Townie

I am not strong, I am wise, I use my wisdom

my ability is passive,

Wisdom - I know so much that I know Mario is in this game, Bowyer is not, the five original party member are not all who they seem...

That is literally what it says, forgive me for not getting a PR that is heavily detailed nor had any way to prove itself.

I have no info on Yardovich.

What changed me to make a case was Pierce telling me to prove myself more than being as passive as I was.

 

[T-block]

vote: Rajam

I have a bad feeling about lynching RR toDay. Leaving my vote on Rajam for now.

 

[UTDZac]

RR did you seriously just 7a?

Also regarding Tin Man. I went back and re-read multiple times over what I found. I take back my read on him. I misread something and it screwed up my read. Ugh sry.

 

[Omni]

Kryz everything about my role is what I said.

I am Frogfucius - Wise Townie

I am not strong, I am wise, I use my wisdom

my ability is passive,

Wisdom - I know so much that I know Mario is in this game, Bowyer is not, the five original party member are not all who they seem...

That is literally what it says, forgive me for not getting a PR that is heavily detailed nor had any way to prove itself.

7a. You are not allowed to quote any mod communication of any kind, real or fake, to anyone. You must paraphrase all information you wish to claim.

Me at work:

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

I never quoted it. I listed traits of my Role PM listed.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Rule 7a says quote, I paraphrased it.

 

[Omni]

oh. the part where you said 'literally what it says' made me believe it was literally what it says. which means that's not literally what it says.

-_-

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

No no, not literal quote.

I'm stating it what it literally says in my own words.

 

[UTDZac]

Just for your satisfaction RR:

He actively visited the site and other mafia games but decided to not post here.
Im visiting family. It's really easy to skim over fun threads like League/DFW/LoZ mafia and make a quick post compared to thoroughly reading this thread, catching up, and making content posts. I didn't have time/motivation to do so while at my familys.

Zero follow ups on his reads.
I was planning on posting follow ups. I made the original post on my phone while laying in bed for a while.

Makes up bull****.
Can't really respond to this one...

only 15 posts in this game.
Hard to fix this one by going back in the past and being more active.

Limited content in those posts.
Probably because it was early in Day 1. Sorry I can't just pull content out of thin air.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

He actively visited the site and other mafia games but decided to not post here.
Im visiting family. It's really easy to skim over fun threads like League/DFW/LoZ mafia and make a quick post compared to thoroughly reading this thread, catching up, and making content posts. I didn't have time/motivation to do so while at my familys.

Yet you had no problem making these posts in the LoD mafia, why avoid this one unless you didn't care to scum hunt?

Zero follow ups on his reads.
I was planning on posting follow ups. I made the original post on my phone while laying in bed for a while.

Planning is different from did.

Makes up bull****.
Can't really respond to this one...

Because it is true.

only 15 posts in this game.
Hard to fix this one by going back in the past and being more active.

Well you could have easily made small comments during those times you were posting in other threads, including another mafia.

Limited content in those posts.
Probably because it was early in Day 1. Sorry I can't just pull content out of thin air.

You could have made content during those times you were on.

 

[Omni]

oh ok.

btw i cant do a lengthy retort to what i think so far about the game cuz of my bosses lurking around but uh

rr can live, altho him dying and flipping town would be awesome. mario can claim town and be auto-cleared in lylo situations. also, if "the other 4" does refer to Mallow, Geno, Peach, and Bowser and one of those 4 flip scum then the rest are cleared town. but i do think rr should live.

rajam can still die.
haven't read into UTD enough but he can probably die, too.

so imo either Rajam or UTD should be lynched.

and ill address everyone else after toDay's end

 

[CT Chia]

Frogfucius (Wise townie)

I know info about the set-up, that is my only ability.

lmao how did I not notice this

I didn't notice it until Rajam posted his claim which I just read that showed a different color. I didn't pick up on this when I first read RR's claim since it was my first time reading the game in a few days and it's been a bit since I saw my role pm, but yea. Dat color, it's not right lol.

 

[CT Chia]

honestly im shocked that no one else picked up on that

 

[CT Chia]

so omni, why can RR live?

 

[CT Chia]

Simple. Look at their claims.

This guy knows whats up

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

I'm well aware Chibo, I thought my role PM was in green until I double checked after I saw Rajam's claim.

 

[CT Chia]

Why would you even feel the need to put color?

and even since I was fine with you being lynched before I noticed the color fiasco, I don't care either way lol

and your last statement only adds to the wifom

 

[Omni]

i actually didn't notice the color either. there's no sample pm and i've only looked at my role once since.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Well most of the first games I played people put there claims in color so I felt like it was something you needed to do when claiming.

 

[Omni]

lol, if u really are town, RR, i gotta say you've easily managed to become one of the most successful self-lynchers who isn't a jester

 

[UTDZac]

honestly im shocked that no one else picked up on that

Skimming much? Wow...

@RR, LoZ mafia has like... 2 posts per day. It's really easy to post response there compared to here.

@Omni, you haven't read much into me but you think I should die? Cool =(

 

[CT Chia]

UTD I already said I'm posting as I'm reading, I'm still like 5-6 pages back

 

[Omni]

im just mad about u being so inactive, utd. ive actually got quite a good amount of reading to do until im caught up correctly tho but no johns.

 

[UTDZac]

UTD I already said I'm posting as I'm reading, I'm still like 5-6 pages back

Weren't you the one that said you were "appalled" by the amount of posts since your returned? Why are you then "posting as you go," it just adds to the fluff and annoyance. I'm fine with reading posts that are longer than 20 words.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

lol, if u really are town, RR, i gotta say you've easily managed to become one of the most successful self-lynchers who isn't a jester

Your comment after Shaq mafia sums it up.

@RR, LoZ mafia has like... 2 posts per day. It's really easy to post response there compared to here.

Can't be that hard to reread the latest page.

No johns you made plenty of opportunity to do this over 5 days even when you were visiting family, if you could post in other threads you could have posted here.

 

[CT Chia]

Weren't you the one that said you were "appalled" by the amount of posts since your returned? Why are you then "posting as you go," it just adds to the fluff and annoyance. I'm fine with reading posts that are longer than 20 words.

 

[CT Chia]

Sorry, but I still like to make the occasional joke. But yea, just because my posts are split up doesn't change anything.

I normally do the large multi quote post up, but this situation is different. The game is very active right now so people can reply to each of the individual posts I make while I'm still catching up so I can use these new opinions and posts in my reading. I'm reading both new posts and old ones at the same time, makes for an interesting dynamic. You know, like Chrono Trigger mafia lol, reading through time

 

[CT Chia]

So, I'm at L-2 right now.

Ok, might as well do reads again.

Wait... your instinct when nearing lynch is to do reads on people and not defend yourself?


wat

looks like you're trying to get some people on your side with your "reads" so you hope they get off your wagon

not the proper way to do it bro

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Man Omni is right, I'm the scummiest town player alive.

I'm worse than Airgemini.

 

[Krystedez]

Sorry to interrupt you guys.

@RR:

So. Are you basing your suspicion on me on the fact that I called out one of many villains once and equally, during my flavor posting from answering Chibo's talk? This, "oh, look, one of the villains that Krys speculated about is not in this game according to my role, SUSPICIOUS!" is just more diversion of attention from your wagon, and probably for good reason; you're either panicking scum trying to save yourself last minute, or panicking townie trying to relay information that unfortunately doesn't apply at all. You shouldn't focus so much on flavor or you might get burned, buddy. Literally.

I can assure you that my talk of Bowyer was just simply saying that such a crazy character befitting your nutso play earlier toDay. And to fill the rest of my flavor talk that post I spoke of his power most likely being roleblocking, since he does it in game practically.

@Chibo, agreed.

 

[Krystedez]

^and I just read my post and realized I should do this:

inb4howironic@Krys'sflavortalk

 

[CT Chia]

Idiot.

I was looking for the correct blue.

I'm well aware Chibo, I thought my role PM was in green until I double checked after I saw Rajam's claim.

Oh hey look, perfect example of why it's good to read new replies and old posts at the same time UTD

This already contradicts itself, but lets throw some more posts into the mix here!

Because green is usual town, until I looked at my role PM and noticed Overswarm has no sample role PM.

I loooked at Rajams and thought it had a different blue to it.

Nvm, you posted the right color of blue, thought you posted the wrong color of blue and was trying to see if you did slip and say the wrong color if you were scum.

Pulling a Chibo here lol.

Ok so lets piece everything together here...

You claim

You forgot your role pm exactly, and posted the "usual town" color

So RR, what is the usual town color? What are you used to?

Normally I would say Lime Green, but lets face it, I've been playing Mafia here on SWF for what, 2 years now? More often than not it's green. But I also take note when it is different, such as RE4 which prompted said questions you referred to when you said you were "pulling a Chibo"

What were your last two games RR? iirc they were Pokemon Mafia and RE4. While they may not be your two latest games, they are two very recent games fresh in your memory. What was the town color in each? This is public knowledge in both games seen from a sample pm in the OP, and NEITHER of them were lime green. RE4 is a darker green and Pokemon Mafia was a darker blue.

So this already, is just confusing and makes no sense, but I'm willing to look past this.

Here is what is important...

You posted your claim

Rajam posted his claim

You saw Rajam's claim

You DOUBLE CHECKED your role PM

------Why did you not notice they were the same blue? You just saw Rajam's, noticed something fishy about it, then checked yours. It's a fairly unique blue.

You claim that Rajam doesn't know the town color

You realize that he did post the correct town color

You claim that you were doing it to test him, thinking he had the wrong blue

What made you realize after you asked him that he did have the right blue.

This whole thing doesn't make sense, and the fact that you double checked your role PM when you saw his and didn't notice that they were the same blue makes no sense. Not to mention if this color used is so off the norm, why would Rajam have posted that different blue (as in, you thought it was different), and not the normal lime green since you thought he was lying.

 

[T-block]

****ing colours.

Fine with RR dying now then, after reading Chibo's post. Honestly I'm so confused about what to think of RR. Even if he's town, we gain info from his flip, so fine.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

You know I screwed up enough as is, T-Block hammer me.

Every I said was true, but like Omni said I get an award for scumiest town player.