It's long but it was worth saying.
We wouldn't have to settle for second place every time if Golden Sun fans would stop going dormant every single time something seems to be in our way. Good Lord if the Banjo, K Rool, or Ridley fans did that they wouldn't be here.
I take umbrage with that. The fact that the character in question hasn't had a leading role in a game for eighteen years, the series itself hasn't had a title in nine, and hasn't had a great one in seventeen, yet clocks in second behind a character who appears damn near every year in multiple million-unit selling titles as apart of the biggest gaming series
full stop is not a testament to Nintendo, who like to act like Golden Sun barely ever existed, it's not a testament to Smash Bros., that straight up ditched the character last time, it's a testament to the fact that the fans, since pre-Brawl, have refused to cease pushing.
It's very easy to equate Banjo, K. Rool, Ridley and Isaac as if they all begin from the same starting point, and the latter's fans just lack the resolve to match the others. But that is a super flawed premise. Need I remind you that K. Rool and Ridley are the antagonists of DK and Metroid, series get a helluva lot more attention from fans, but also from Nintendo, than Golden Sun does. Golden Sun, meanwhile, has outpaced most its actual contemporaries, like Starfy, or Advance Wars, or Sin & Punishment, or even Rhythm Heaven. Those series, as fellow c-tier titles, gain an innate disadvantage promotion-wise, and audience-wise, from the likes of Metroid and DK.
Moreover, Ridley and Banjo are characters that would've been included a long time ago, probably in Brawl, had extenuating circumstances (whether concerns of feasibility or legality) not mitigated their chances. Take a different Brawl inclusion, like Wario, Diddy, Olimar, etc, keep their fanbase in play for ten additional years, and see how popular they get as the competition around them weakens. It's the fact that those character just function at a higher degree of prominence that allows a fanbase such as Banjo's to
actually go dormant for nearly fifteen years then resurge almost overnight.
But I've been around the whole time, I've overseen every Isaac thread here since pre-Smash-4, and while obviously activity ebbs and flows, to single Isaac out as an exception and malign the fanbase for the typical reduction that comes with a confirmed role is pretty off-base. I guarantee right now if you go to the first page of "newcomer speculation" you will see that activity is dominated by characters either still in play, or only "soft deconfirmed" by spirit roles or whatnot. Of those that have been hard deconfirmed, you'll probably only see Isaac, Waluigi, Ashley, and maybe one or two others. So to suggest we're some aberration by lowered activity, or actually expect that such an event wouldn't hinder engagement is just misunderstanding how deconfirmations impact a character, across all of Smash.
Honestly though, Isaac fans have always,
always showed up when it mattered. The secret is, right now it doesn't really matter. You may say that it perpetually matters, and whether that is true or not, the times it was actually crucial, such as the ballot, such as in reaction to his AT reveal, Isaac fans were certainly present, certainly vocal, and in the instance of the former, clearly affected development. I have every faith that, going forward, the influx will continue when necessary.
We are working from the disadvantage of being a dead series. Metroid and DK were not. Mario certainly isn't. We are working from the disadvantage of never having been an A-tier series. Banjo did not. Mario is so A-tier that even his supporting cast is ubiquitous. You want a comparison between series that actually share some degree of parity? Look at all the other dead ones with fanbases that, unlike us, have fallen by the wayside.
I think the fact that Isaac, after all this time, is still even in the top three is a massive coup which rests almost entirely on the backs of the fanbase. We perform phenomenally for having only ever been fed on scraps. This thread has had more posts made after Isaac's deconfirmation than most did in their entirety. A fanbase will slow when things seem resolved, welcome to Smash, but if there's anything that doesn't describe the Isaac fanbase, it's complacency.