I mean, considering that even back then Golden Sun and TLA were going to be a single N64 game, but had to be split up and moved to the GBA, it shows how ambitious the IP is in terms of actually making it.
Yeah, these aren't easy games to make. I'd imagine with a smaller team, it would take a normal development cycle (1.5-2 years) just to port the first two, so that might be a pretty large block in getting the games made. However, I still think Camelot will make the right move and recombine them into one Switch game.
Hey flawed do you mind giving me your theory on why you think we will get Isaac in as dlc and golden just might get a remake this year? I should put that to good use when I go use another design for my banner next time I hit up a major.
Yeah, no problem. Anything for the guy who's basically the face of our campaign! You're doing the Wise One's work, man.
Basically, the whole idea is predicated one the assumption that Camelot is developing a new Golden Sun - most likely a remake of the first two, since that would reintroduce people to the franchise, and would reduce the workload on the new team, since no new story would have to be made. I think this is likely due to two main factors: Camelot/the Takahashi Bros. have said they'd make a new GS when the fans demanded it. Well, due to the negative(-ish) reaction to Dark Dawn, they were kinda scared off from doing GS. However, when the Smash Ballot came around, Isaac did surprisingly (to Nintendo, at least) well, as in, well enough to make the game. When Sakurai has to visit/call up Camelot to get permission to use Isaac, Camelot learns of Isaac's popularity, and realizes the demand is there (this is around 2016). Well, Camelot is currently working on Mario Tennis Aces, but they send a smaller team (including the Takahashi Bros.) to another company, probably Monolith or Namco to have them help remaking the first two Golden Sun games, with Camelot sending more of their employees once MTA is done. This game is developing well, and so is Smash, but in mid-2018, something unforeseen happens: Sakurai realizes he can't finish Isaac in time for the game's release, and Nintendo will not let him delay the game and miss the holiday 2018 season. So to please GS fans, Sakurai quickly adds Isaac's Assist Trophy, and cuts any new GS content in Smash, outside of Spirits: any new songs and the stage that would've come is scrapped.
Now, we come to August of 2018. The Rathalos tweet is sent, and GS fans everywhere start jumping for joy. There's no way that tweet wasn't a GS reference, but it was made and sent before Isaac was cut from the game. Nintendo applies for a new Golden Sun trademark, with expanded coverage for the GS remake coming soon. It's my personal theory that Isaac was meant to be shown in the September Direct, but couldn't, since he was cut from the game. (It had nothing to due with the Hokkaido earthquake, but the timing of that is such a coincidence it's strange.) Despite his Assist Trophy, Isaac
has to be on Sakurai's mind, since he's a fan demand character, and Sakurai tried to make him work earlier. (Quick side note: If this is true, I'm kinda pissed Isaac was cut over Incineroar or Isabelle, but whatever.) With all the outrage over Isaac's Assist, Nintendo deciding the DLC characters, and the new Golden Sun in development, Nintendo makes the call to Sakurai to make Isaac happen. Of course, I don't think if Isaac was planned and cut, he was cut just to be paid DLC, since Sakurai doesn't work that way. However, I think Nintendo sees what is literally the golden (heh) opportunity: add a
hugely requested character to Smash ($), to coincide with a new game from that character's series ($$), to get new fans interested in the series ($$$). With a small team working on the Golden Sun remake, the game isn't ready until 2019 (hell, they may have started it after MTA, the timeline adds up), perfectly coinciding with the Smash DLC window. (Quick thing about the potential GS remake: if I remember correctly, the trademark is in English, despite the trademark being for Japan, which leads me to theorize that the franchise will be rebranded as "Golden Sun" across the world, instead of 「黄金の太陽」(Ōgon No Taiyou) in Japan.)
The theory rests entirely on two things: Camelot is making a GS remake (or a new game) and Nintendo wants to capitalize on that with some promotion. I honestly think we have a pretty solid chance of this happening (I put it at 50/50 myself), but we have to hope Isaac fans showed the **** up on the Ballot in order to convince Camelot to work on the next game.
(If I missed anything, let me know, and I'll edit this post accordingly)
Quick edit: On a somewhat related note, how possible do you guys think it is that the remake started on 3DS but were ported to Switch? It would explain the somewhat long dev cycle (2-3 years, if I'm right), and might also explain why some insiders have been claiming GS on 3DS - they have old info.