Speaking of this, I feel like most people are overlooking the chances of unrepped IPs. I mean if you look at Smash 4s newcomers, if you count the Miis as one character and you exclude the clones, you have 2 third parties (
) , 5 characters from pre-existing series (
ultbowserjr
and 6 characters from previously unrepped Nintendo series (
). And while they could have easily added other popular and relevant characters like Ridley, Bandana Dee, King K. Rool, Dixie Kong, Ashley, Impa, Ghirahim, Mewtwo, etc., etc. They instead chose to have the majority of the Nintendo newcomers be completely new faces from both new and old franchises.
Then, I consider how in the E3 presentation, he made a specific point regarding how this is the biggest crossover in gaming history. Really emphasizing the fact that there a
lot of games represented here.
So, if Sakurai is looking at the ballot and he sees characters like Isaac, Waddle Dee, Ashley, and Geno all ranked similarly, I feel like there is a
very good chance that he would opt for the completely new face.
And as far as other franchises that he might look into for a new character, I do think Advance Wars, Rhythm Heaven, Sin & Punishment, Custom Robo, Dillon’s Rolling Western, and ARMS all stand out. But I am confident that, aside from Inkling, Isaac would’ve easily performed best in the ballot. Especially considering Rhythm Heaven’s lack of a main character, and ARMS being well past the prime time.