i have a 100% serious question ziv. why is falco (to you) clearly the best character primarily because of consistent top placings (top 10/whatever), yet jigglypuff is overrated? hbox consistently places well. and sheiks generally don't get top 5, yet hbox nearly always gets top 3, yet you have jigglypuff way lower than both falco and sheik. and even captain.
It is my opinion that he is the best, but for one I never said "clearly" the best, and for two I'm arguing that I believe Falco would be number one if a new tier list was made. That is because there are two Falco mains that are better than ANY Fox main, and two more Falco's that
might be (Mango, PP, Zhu, and Westballz). There are really only three characters we see win national tournaments. Peach, Jiggs, and Falco. And I don't believe the tier list should be changed based off ONE person being godly with a character. That's why Peach and Puff aren't that high. With your logic Sinister, Peach should be higher than Puff because there are 2-3 Peach players that can consistently place top 17 in nationals, and only one Puff.
As far as Sheik not getting top 5, you're crazy. You forget too easily that M2K is a Sheik main, and he very rarely uses Marth anymore. Not to mention Amsah, who could take top 5 in most tournaments. And KirbyKaze and Tope also place well. Look at some nationals.
Genesis 2 - Top 17
Peach - 1st (armada) - 9th (macd)
Falco - 2nd (mango) - 7th (drpp) - 17th (dehf)
Marth - 3rd (taj)
Puff - 4th (hbox)
Sheik - 5th (m2k) - 13th (atma) - 17th (lucien)
Doc - 5th (shroomed)
Falcon - 7th (s2j) - 9th (hax) - 13th (ss) - 17th (fuzzyness)
Fox - 9th (sfat) - 13th (lovage) - 17th (silentwolf) 17th (leffen)
IC - 9th (wobbles) - 13th (fly)
Ganon - 17th (kage)
Luigi - 17th (eddy)
Pikachu - 17th (axe)
4 Fox players, 4 Falcon, 3 Falco, 3 Sheik. 2 IC and 2 Peach. One of everybody else.
Pound 5
Falco - 1st (pp) - 9th (remen) - 13th (zhu) - 17th (blunted) - 17th (mango)
Peach - 2nd (armada) - 17th (macd)
Puff - 3rd (hbox)
Pikachu - 4th (axe)
Sheik - 5th (m2k) - 7th (vanz) - 9th (amsah) - 17th (kirbykaze)
Falcon - 5th (hax) - 17th (s2j)
Fox - 7th (cactuar) - 9th (cactuar) - 13th (unknown) - 13th (kels) - 13th (silentwolf) - 17th (lovage)
Doc - 9th (shroomed)
IC - 17th (chu)
Marth - 17th (strawhat)
6 Fox players, 5 Falco, 4 sheik, 2 Peach, 2 Falcon. One of everybody else.
Apex 2012
Peach - 1st (armada) - 9th (macd) - 13th (vanz)
Puff - 2nd (hbox) - 17th (darc)
Falco - 3rd (mango) - 5th (pp) - 13th (zhu) - 17th (dashiz)
Fox - 4th (javi) - 9th (lovage) - 9th (unknown) - 13th (sfat) - 17th (silentwolf) - 17th (chillin)
Sheik - 5th (kirbykaze) - 13th (tope) - 17th (koreandj) - 17th (m2k)
Falcon - 7th (hax) - 17th (s2j)
Doc - 7th (shroomed)
IC - 9th (wobbles)
Marth - 17th (pewpewu)
6 Fox players, 4 Falco, 4 Sheik, 3 Peach, 2 Puff, 2 Falcon. One of everybody else.
Ok so, in the three National tournaments within the last year, this is the number of high finishes we have:
Fox - 16
Falco - 12
Sheik - 11
Falcon - 8
Peach - 7
IC - 4
Puff - 4
Marth - 3
Doc - 3
Pikachu - 2
Luigi - 1
Ganon - 1
So why is it that people think Marth is better than Falcon? Why do people think Puff is better than Falcon? Falcon is the most punishing character in the game. He has a speed only two other characters can match. He can death combo any character in the game. And most importantly he has multiple pro players representing him at an extremely high level and not only placing well, but also expanding what the character can actually do.
Marth is an inconsistent character who lacks representation from active, high level pros. His metagame has been on a plateau for a long time and the other characters are catching up to him.
And while there were more high Fox finishes, he only once got top 5. Where as we see 4 Falco top 5 finishes.
This is analysis from actual recent tournaments. A quick look through some other large tournaments within the last year show very similar results. Lots of Fox's and Falcos. Sheiks, Falcons, and Peachs remaining well represented. One Marth in each in the top 17. The Big House, Winter Gamefest 2012, Northwest Manifest. All of them prove the point.
EDIT: Oh and Strong Bad, for clarification, the points of debate I'm trying to argue now are 1) that if a new tier list was made, Falco would/should be number one based off the backroom criteria for voting on the tier list (which i quoted earlier for reference) and 2) that falcon would climb above Marth and Puff.
And after this analysis I would even change my vote for tier list to even more so reflect the criteria, switching Peach and Marth.
1) Falco
2) Fox
3) Sheik
4) Falcon
5) Peach
6) Marth
7) JigglyPuff
8) Ice Climbers