[SPOILER ALERT] - The Sevens Squares. - A Square-Enix general support threads.

Who do you think is the most likely possible Square-Enix Newcomer? (Two Choices possibles)


  • Total voters
    537
  • Poll closed .

BZL8

Smash Ace
Joined
Feb 9, 2019
Messages
537
Location
Somewhere
Switch FC
208233413838
Wait, you mean it should be up live now?
Bc I still see the old one.
No, I meant that the old poll on this thread should be changed. I am neither the OP of this thread nor do I have the power to change it. (Teeb has already tagged Nekoo (the OP) to change it.

I think most people will be good with this list:

  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. Sephiroth
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. 2B
  7. Terra
  8. Mana series character
  9. Another FF character ( Black Mage, Tifa, etc)
  10. Deux Ex character (JC Denton/Adam Jensen)
  11. Agnes Oblige
  12. Neku
    Other
That's a nice list for an updated poll.
 

HyruleHero

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 9, 2018
Messages
376
Location
Hyrule
I think most people will be good with this list:

  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. Sephiroth
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. 2B
  7. Terra
  8. Mana series character
  9. Another FF character ( Black Mage, Tifa, etc)
  10. Deux Ex character (JC Denton/Adam Jensen)
  11. Agnes Oblige
  12. Neku
    Other
Theres a bit of clean up that can be done with that list
  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. New FF Character (Sephiroth, Terra, Black Mage, etc.)
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. Mana Series Character
  7. Other (2B, Deux Ex, Agnes Oblige, Neku, etc.)
I think this makes a list more comprehensible, although it puts 2B and Neku in 'Other' it gets more to the point and leaves discussion open after voting.
 

Teeb147

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
8,226
Theres a bit of clean up that can be done with that list
  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. New FF Character (Sephiroth, Terra, Black Mage, etc.)
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. Mana Series Character
  7. Other (2B, Deux Ex, Agnes Oblige, Neku, etc.)
I think this makes a list more comprehensible, although it puts 2B and Neku in 'Other' it gets more to the point and leaves discussion open after voting.
Well, I'd like to see the exact amount of people that vote for 2b, agnes, neku, and all that, seems interesting to me, so it might seem like simplifying with only 7 but actually it's less detailed if we put it like that, and there really isn't much reason to limit to 7 characters anymore. This can be just a general SE thread now. At least that's my thoughts on it.

i.e. with so many pages, the conversation on specific ones would get lost to some people.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
886
Sora is a big time contender, so I definitely think it's better to let people vote for him, especially since the way it's heading it could be about who we'd like to have in. I also think that lots of people will say disney would be ok with it. who knows.
The poll isn't up yet, but I messaged Nekoo Nekoo about it.

I think most people will be good with this list:

  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. Sephiroth
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. 2B
  7. Terra
  8. Mana series character
  9. Another FF character ( Black Mage, Tifa, etc)
  10. Deux Ex character (JC Denton/Adam Jensen)
  11. Agnes Oblige
  12. Neku
    Other
I don't think he is a contender because he is not competing with neither of those chars. He is a Disney character, and the legal procedure to get him works differently from the rest of the pack. Him getting in won't affect the chances of any of the true SE chars. Putting Sora will be a bit of a bonus, but it won't be really telling anything regarding SE chars themselves.

Theres a bit of clean up that can be done with that list
  1. Geno
  2. Sora
  3. New FF Character (Sephiroth, Terra, Black Mage, etc.)
  4. Crono
  5. Lara Croft
  6. Mana Series Character
  7. Other (2B, Deux Ex, Agnes Oblige, Neku, etc.)
I think this makes a list more comprehensible, although it puts 2B and Neku in 'Other' it gets more to the point and leaves discussion open after voting.
Her list makes more sense, given how they are organized by franchises, unless the char is too popular to be grouped in his/her own franchise group (as in, Sephiroth and Terra)
 

Teeb147

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
8,226
Tifa is relatively popular, but i havent seen her talked about much for smash, and even our support page hasn't even made it past the first page yet.

In any case, she's less popular for smash than Sephiroth and Terra, and then there's the other characters people like from ff, I think having more than 3 options for a franchise is a bit much, so because there's even more people would like, i think it just makes sense to make the 3rd option be general for the rest.

If the mana series were talked about for smash more, I think Randi, Liz, Duran, and Angela are the most popular characters. (The last 3 are from Trials of Mana). But i dont it's worth having them listed individually in the poll.


I don't think he is a contender because he is not competing with neither of those chars. He is a Disney character, and the legal procedure to get him works differently from the rest of the pack. Him getting in won't affect the chances of any of the true SE chars. Putting Sora will be a bit of a bonus, but it won't be really telling anything regarding SE chars themselves.


Her list makes more sense, given how they are organized by franchises, unless the char is too popular to be grouped in his/her own franchise group (as in, Sephiroth and Terra)
It's at least a little bit debatable since disney didn't just contract SE, as far as I know, and there's maybe a grey area for intellectual rights since SE designed the character.

I found this tweet that says it's both: https://twitter.com/rogersbase/status/975413324442554370?lang=en

And then some other people say it wouldn't necessarily be hard to work with disney. So I don't know, I think it's worth keeping sora there, but people could chime in if they have more info :O
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
886
Tifa is relatively popular, but i havent seen her talked about much for smash, and even our support page hasn't even made it past the first page yet.

In any case, she's less popular for smash than Sephiroth and Terra, and then there's the other characters people like from ff, I think having more than 3 options for a franchise is a bit much, so because there's even more people would like, i think it just makes sense to make the 3rd option be general for the rest.

If the mana series were talked about for smash more, I think Randi, Liz, Duran, and Angela are the most popular characters. (The last 3 are from Trials of Mana). But i dont it's worth having them listed individually in the poll.




It's at least a little bit debatable since disney didn't just contract SE, as far as I know, and there's maybe a grey area for intellectual rights since SE designed the character.

I found this tweet that says it's both: https://twitter.com/rogersbase/status/975413324442554370?lang=en

And then some other people say it wouldn't necessarily be hard to work with disney. So I don't know, I think it's worth keeping sora there, but people could chime in if they have more info :O
I wish Tifa had more support. :(
She is definitely a Smash-worthy character.

Yeah, you nailed the Mana chars. I love Randi. :3

The Sora situation is this:
The series was planned and conceived by FF creator Hironobu Sakaguchi and SE producer Shinji Hashimoto.
Their pitch was to make a series that could match the appeal of Super Mario 64, so they thought Disney character would be the perfect idea to match with their IP to reach that goal. With Disney's approval and contracts signed, KH was born, with SE developing the games and story, while the OCs are owned by Disney, with art owned by Nomura.
Disney previously expressed that they would be fine with Sora in Smash, and all that they would need is Nomura's approval. And they made it clear, this is done out of respect for Nomura, given that they could easily do whatever they want with Sora and other OCs, but they don't bc they want good relations with SE, specially Nomura. It is the very reason you see the concerts going around that are basically sprankled with Disney's name and copyrights, rather than SE's.
And I seriously doubt Nomura would decline the offer.

I think A.G.L. A.G.L. would be the best man to get even more info on it
 

A.G.L.

Smash Ace
Joined
Nov 2, 2018
Messages
776
Location
Time Traveling
Switch FC
SW-7451-1877-0896
Tifa is relatively popular, but i havent seen her talked about much for smash, and even our support page hasn't even made it past the first page yet.

In any case, she's less popular for smash than Sephiroth and Terra, and then there's the other characters people like from ff, I think having more than 3 options for a franchise is a bit much, so because there's even more people would like, i think it just makes sense to make the 3rd option be general for the rest.

If the mana series were talked about for smash more, I think Randi, Liz, Duran, and Angela are the most popular characters. (The last 3 are from Trials of Mana). But i dont it's worth having them listed individually in the poll.




It's at least a little bit debatable since disney didn't just contract SE, as far as I know, and there's maybe a grey area for intellectual rights since SE designed the character.

I found this tweet that says it's both: https://twitter.com/rogersbase/status/975413324442554370?lang=en

And then some other people say it wouldn't necessarily be hard to work with disney. So I don't know, I think it's worth keeping sora there, but people could chime in if they have more info :O
Thanks for the mention MajoraMan28 MajoraMan28 :).

So it’s actually Disney that owns Sora and Kingdom Hearts properties. Disney is a bit of an interesting mix given they are not a gaming company. And they no longer own a gaming studio of their own that they can pass off decisions to (Disney Interactive & Square Enix made KH1 & 2 together). Disney Interactive has been disbanded, and Disney now trusts gaming studios more to call the shots since they don’t do gaming themselves. Disney can be difficult to work with, if they don’t see it worth their time or if they don’t get something back in return. Keep in mind right now Disney’s entertainment department is quite busy dealing with the Fox merger. So they might not want to deal with Sora being in Smash. Then again we have to keep in mind that Disney has been putting much more freedom with their gaming partners to make decisions since they don’t have a gaming studio of their own, and the last Disney pushed tanked (Disney Infinity) which led to Disney Interactive being downsized and being left in charge of Jam City (a mobile gaming company).

Needless to say Disney puts a lot of trust in their gaming partners since their own entrepreneurship in the gaming industry did not work out well for them. They pretty much let their partners have free range as long as they stick to Disney rules.

So in the case with Sora the Vice President of Disney Japan said in an interview with HMK a YouTuber who covers mostly Kingdom Hearts and Zelda games. That Disney is open to the idea of having Sora in Smash. Also Nomura and Square have a lot of freedom when it comes to Sora. Because Disney recognizes how much Sora and Kingdom Hearts mean to Nomura and Square Enix.

Now let’s keep in mind Disney has done crossovers with their characters in games before. Wreck it Ralph was in Sonic & All Stars Racing. Thanos was in Fortnite, and we can’t forget Disney allowed Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 to be a Nintendo exclusive game. So they can be reasoned with. It just depends if Disney, Nintendo, Nomura, Sakurai, and Square Enix can all come to an agreement (I say Nomura because Disney likes to bring him in, when it comes to decisions regarding Kingdom Hearts).


The problem with Sora is it’s hard to dissociate him from Disney properties. Even his keyblade charm has a Mickey Emblem. Now this could be removed or the Kingdom key changed for another keyblade. However given that Sakurai likes to keep characters as close to how they are in their own games. This may present a problem. Also adding Disney characters in Smash even if just as a taunt or part of a moveset will open a whole can of worms. Because people will take it as a sign that Goku or Shrek can now be in Smash. So it’s definitely a very tricky situation when it comes to Sora. Either they’ll have to completely dissociate him from Disney including possibly changing his keyblade or Sakurai and Nintendo will have to add Disney references.

In a interview with Sakurai recently he addressed this situation. I will link the tweet and translation below. It’s important to note Sakurai says “basically Smash will only have content from video games in it”. However he doesn’t outright say it will not have any content that is not video game related. So it is possible Sora could come with some slight references to Disney.

Lastly with KH3’s secret ending, it does seem like Disney is giving a lot creative control to Square Enix. Even possibly allowing Sora to be in a game with little to no Disney references.

 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
886
I know this is random, but just for fun, this poll has been circulating Discord servers.
You vote not on the char you want the most necessarily, but you keep voting between two random choices from the available candidates.
I personally like this method, because it goes more for approval rating than the raw list of most wanted by each person. It's interesting to take a look at least in what most people are ok with or want.
It's at around 85k votes at the moment of me writting this post, which each vote being counted by round that comes up.

http://allourideas.org/smashudlc/results?all=true
 
Joined
Jul 28, 2013
Messages
7,279
Location
Infinite Glacier
I know this is random, but just for fun, this poll has been circulating Discord servers.
You vote not on the char you want the most necessarily, but you keep voting between two random choices from the available candidates.
I personally like this method, because it goes more for approval rating than the raw list of most wanted by each person. It's interesting to take a look at least in what most people are ok with or want.
It's at around 85k votes at the moment of me writting this post, which each vote being counted by round that comes up.

http://allourideas.org/smashudlc/results?all=true
While it has 85k votes, it seems the unique user sessions are just about 700-1,000.

Still interesting, though.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
886
While it has 85k votes, it seems the unique user sessions are just about 700-1,000.

Still interesting, though.
I'm not sure someone is willing to click 100 times, but it should be around 1-2.5k voters as of now.

And a reminder: approval rating is not an indicative of popularity in the most wanted lists.
It just means that those that appear in the most wanted lists are the ones whose fans are most of the people that are part of the ones that comprise said approval rating.
 

Al-kīmiyā'

Smash the State
Premium
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
1,973
In order to "skip" you need to choose one of a number of options, and specific answers give different "points" to the two candidates in question.
I'm not sure if it really does give different points depending on what you pick, but if it does, that's even worse. Just pick "I don't like either." Vote down all the characters except the ones you want.
 
Joined
Nov 28, 2018
Messages
886
I'm not sure if it really does give different points depending on what you pick, but if it does, that's even worse. Just pick "I don't like either." Vote down all the characters except the ones you want.
Voting down all characters doesn't improve rating for your favorite character. This analyses the approval rating of each individual character, and if you don't manage to find enough MUs with your char in it, you won't affect much in the percentage of your char. Remember that this is a poll based on numerous MUs, and each character gets some votes per person. You're changing at best 0.5% of the rating, if you stay there spamming for hours on end.
 
Top