ATTENTION
I have just completed my first ever official Smash Ultimate tier list. This is based on both results and theory. Here's what I got:
Tiers are indeed in order.
Some character specifics....
![Peach :ultpeach: :ultpeach:]()
- Best character in the game. She's consistently good at everything, and while she is floaty and semi-light it's not glaring to the point where her viability is greatly hindered. Good KO moves, amazing combo potential, decent range, and many players love playing her... Peach is the total package.
![Joker :ultjoker: :ultjoker:]()
- Joker's 2nd best in game. In my tournament results system he has the best results, but we also must account for theory: and he relies heavily on Arsene to get kills. Outside of Arsene, he's got decent air game but poor tilts overall. Thankfully for him he's got good movement, combos, and reliability. He's for sure a top tier... but he's not the best in the game imo.
![Snake :ultsnake: :ultsnake:]()
- Would be rated at #1 but he's fallen off since Peach and Joker rose to fame and Ally left the circuit. He's still got great theory and solid results, but counterplay has been discovered for him and he's not as strong as he used to be.
![Pikachu :ultpikachu: :ultpikachu:]()
-Potentially the best theory in the game, but ESAM is carrying him right now. Can certainly win majors, but not consistently at the moment.
![Banjo & Kazooie :ultbanjokazooie: :ultbanjokazooie:]()
- Still young in the meta but shows a lot of promise. Has been semi-popular so far and has an all-around reliable moveset.
![Rosalina & Luma :ultrosalina: :ultrosalina:]()
and
![Sheik :ultsheik: :ultsheik:]()
- They've had a similar trajectory since Patch 4.00. Originally low tiers, they've been rising in popularity considerably since the patch. Dabuz has begun using Rosa more consistently, and VoiD now has Sheik as his main again. Both have risen in popularity overall as well, and have had solid results since the buffs. However, with Rosa's floatiness and Sheik's lack of KO power still, they aren't in the top 20 at the moment. They've still gotten far better as of late, though.
![Marth :ultmarth: :ultmarth:]()
- Marth is strange to me because his sour spots got a lot more obvious in Ultimate, while his sweet spots got nerfed. Yet, he's still got the sweet spot tipper that can come in handy. He's still got a few solid tools, but he feels like a watered down version of his Smash 4 self.
![Bayonetta :ultbayonetta: :ultbayonetta:]()
- The longer time goes on, the less good she seems. She's still got great combos, but this is nothing like her Smash 4 self... it's very rare to see a zero-to-death combo with her, even though she keeps most of her combo strings. Her KO power is absolutely brutal, and her specials are all finnicky now. Couple that with average frame data and mediocre speed, and you're set up for low tier.
![Piranha Plant :ultpiranha: :ultpiranha:]()
- Only reason why the Plant isn't in F tier is because of the run that the character went on all the way to Grand Finals this past summer. The character has a few good moves... but is still quite shoddy.
![Kirby :ultkirby: :ultkirby:]()
- At least Little Mac has KO punch. Buff this poor thing please.