The Edelgard route was either favored by the developers or is “canon”.
While Byleth does indeed bear the “Crest of Flames” (basically the Fire Emblem), the only other characters to bear it are Jeralt and...Edelgard. This is not copied over to the other two routes with Dimitri and Claude to my knowledge. While she basically artificially gains the crest itself, it just screams ideas similar to other games where the Fire Emblem itself takes different forms and usually ends up with the Hero/Heroine.
I really should just stop doing these comments and take it to a chat with some folks, like
Opossum
,
staindgrey
and
Gentlepanda
but man. The more I find, the more I feel completely validated in my decision.
Anyway, thoughts from those of you who are reading? Between Daddio warning about trusting Rhea, the repeated events of the game that make the Church look corrupt, the bits of story that show Dimitri was wrong to accuse Edelgard for being responsible for the Tragedy of Duscur, and really just the fact that Edelgard wasn’t wrong in starting a war: there is no compromise with the Church of Seiros. It’s like trying to convince people to give away their power for free: it never works.
Edelgard shows much regret in her actions, while realizing there truly is no other way to achieve what she feels is true liberation. That in itself isn’t achieved in the other routes.
Just seems to me that any route other than BE doesn’t go with Jeralt’s warnings, and just kinda turns a blind eye to the obvious corruption in Fodlan.
Black Eagles or bust for me.