• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

SoCal Melee PR 12/29/2013 Update

MacD

Banned via Administration
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
6,891
Location
probably on a platform
idk if i agree with the order of 5 6 7

idk if lovage should be 9

and if you don't put a peach next to connor's name then he better be below lovage

EDIT: did romeo go to any other tournies besides last weekend?
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
whats the reasoning behind each person being where they are

like dehf #4


etc
 

HugS™

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 23, 2009
Messages
1,486
Location
DBR
LOOOOOL get ***** Mango.

Helllllllllll no!
Romeo went to another active gamers tournament, where he placed like 7th, losing to kira and Larry.

Either way, it wouldn't matter if he attended just that single tournament last weekend. If there is nothing indicating what counts as active under the PR's mission statement, then we can only assume that attending zero tournaments counts as inactive.

And even then, that wouldn't be grounds for elimination from the rankings, unless something or someone says/implies that is what would happen.
 

HugS™

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 23, 2009
Messages
1,486
Location
DBR
I used my Ganon to advance in tournament @ Super Champ combo.

Add my SIIIICK Ganon to my name, please.
 

Adam M!

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 20, 2009
Messages
1,462
told ya these are joke rankings

this is what it should be:

1. mango
2. zhu
3. hugo
4. lucky
5. larry
6. lovage
7. kira
8. romeo
9. fly
10. connor

and if you're gonna add larry/hugo/romeo to the list, then it should be to 15 like norcal and go to:

11. macd
12. joeplicate
13. s2j

actually, just stop at lucky 13
 

choknater

Smash Obsessed
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
27,296
Location
Modesto, CA
NNID
choknater
why should oscar be above kira?
dave seems way more consistent in his placings where as oscar has lost to macd, connor and darrell recently.
yes but connor and darrell should be ranked 3rd and 5th in norcal, respectively

oscar just lives in a trash can anyway man



that aint big bird
 

MacD

Banned via Administration
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
6,891
Location
probably on a platform
told ya these are joke rankings

this is what it should be:

1. mango
2. zhu
3. hugo
4. lucky
5. larry
6. lovage
7. kira
8. romeo
9. fly
10. connor

and if you're gonna add larry/hugo/romeo to the list, then it should be to 15 like norcal and go to:

11. macd
12. joeplicate
13. s2j

actually, just stop at lucky 13

dude, fly beat kira last time, and he's beat hugo everytime except the last (if i remember correctly)

hugo did beat lucky this one time, but kira has consistantly beat hugo in tourny (granted he normally get's ***** in losers but still) so i hope you're not basing hugo being that high because he beat lucky this once

and wtf did romeo do this period? beat no one and lose to whoever was mentioned, yes i know he's good, but he hasn't done anything to prove himself better than fly (especially) or connor

the best accomplishments connor had was beating lovage and sfat last weekend (as far as i know) and he had a "bad" loss because he went falco and got *****, then was stupid and suicided twice, but that should place him above romeo

joe moved to back nor cal, get him off the PR adam, but if you want it extended to 15 or 13 or whatev, you're probably going to be placed on it... whether you like it or not

feel free to correct anything i said wrong since i'm going off what i know from the last few weeks and whatever i can remember since last update

PS joe should be considered nor cal and me/zhu should be so cal unless we move back for more then just a summer

imo it should be

1 mango
2 zhu
3 lucky
4 larry
5 hugo
6/7 kira/fly
8 lovage
9 connor
10 romeo

it's just kinda hard to place lovage because i feel like that is hella low, but he hasn't gone to many tournies recently/got to play kira or fly so it's hard to say where he truely stands
 

Atlus8

Smash Master
Joined
Jul 14, 2006
Messages
3,462
Location
Los Angeles (818 Panorama City!)
One thing I would change is place Lovage ahead of Connor because he told me that he beat connor twice at the same tourny! The results were never uploaded so I asked connor if there was any chance that he had them! He did! He lost the USB that contained the results but found it later on!

MacD's PR list is more legit than P's!

why are atlus and lovage still on the pr
I'm not on the PR b!+c#
 

Kira-

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
2,859
Location
Socal
and nah dave, you definitely feel yourself online
yeah i know

this pr is bad

IGNORING IT
if you're not going to give any reasons, we're not going to listen to you.

Romeo went to another active gamers tournament, where he placed like 7th, losing to kira and Larry.
we didnt count this tournament because of laggy TVs. most of the results weren't out of the ordinary anyway, so even if it was counted it wouldn't make any difference.

Either way, it wouldn't matter if he attended just that single tournament last weekend. If there is nothing indicating what counts as active under the PR's mission statement, then we can only assume that attending zero tournaments counts as inactive.

And even then, that wouldn't be grounds for elimination from the rankings, unless something or someone says/implies that is what would happen.
Why the hell is Lovage so low?

Why is Kira above Hugo?
lovage is low for losing to qlex, fly, connor, and macd

where was the result for when connor lost to lovage twice? i actually looked and couldnt find anything like that, although now i remember cam saying something about it

dude, fly beat kira last time, and he's beat hugo everytime except the last (if i remember correctly)
I'm 4-1 against Fly in recent times. Hugo and I are 2-2, I've beaten Lucky 4 times so far, neither of us have beaten Larry. I've also beaten Norcal (done well against OoS) while Hugo just played Socal

hugo did beat lucky this one time, but kira has consistantly beat hugo in tourny (granted he normally get's ***** in losers but still) so i hope you're not basing hugo being that high because he beat lucky this once
i think you mean i consistently beat lucky? also larry is that high because he only loses to mango/zhu/lucky. he beats hugo, obviously he should be 4th. larry also beat me in Upland (B.I.C. Melee 6)

and wtf did romeo do this period? beat no one and lose to whoever was mentioned, yes i know he's good, but he hasn't done anything to prove himself better than fly (especially) or connor

the best accomplishments connor had was beating lovage and sfat last weekend (as far as i know) and he had a "bad" loss because he went falco and got *****, then was stupid and suicided twice, but that should place him above romeo
connor's major accomplishments only occurred last weekend, but he only had one bad loss as opposed to oscar's four (they are bad for oscar because he is ranked higher, thus losing to people under him brings him down)


The only thing I would consider changing is Romeo's placing on the PR. Even though he would still beat everyone not ranked, he hasn't proved that in terms of results or attendance so I'm up for reconsideration on that point.


@ everyone. Way to argue when you don't even know the statistics.
except lovage for that one connor tournament. if you give us the results for that then i'll reconsider (not speaking for other panelists though)


edit - also it was me mango and atlus
edit 2 - hugo should not have ganon
edit 3 - HugS needs his S capitalized
 
Top Bottom