make an rpg where common things are the npcs and stuff
and like a starfish fights the way it does in real life and it baits enemies with its regenerating stomach then tears apart its defenses
and like the knife and fork do combos together
and you travel throughout decrepit hobo boxes to extravagant bourgoisie homes, fighting the electric spinning egg beater boss with 3 whisks inside of the oven
you level up by collecting stickers
and combine paper clips and super glue to upgrade your weapons, and toilet paper to napkins to paper mache to cardboard to upgrade your armor
the story must be legit like toy story 3 lol, quite heartfelt at the end
the toothbrush is your loyal friend
anything could be good if you make it clever and innovative enough. clever as in clever gameplay and dialogue (i like paper mario), and not innovative so that you create your own genre, but that you do the basic things in very different ways. I was always big on innovation, new stuff > 25th zelda game no matter how good zelda is