SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[The Light Music Club]

Ughh! Got a vote already... probably because of too many females, too many japan only characters, or King Hippo.

Anyway I went with Angelglory because he has Blaziken and Charizard which over represents the fire-type. He also had classic Link who I don't really see a point in having, especially over Mask Link, and he also had Pac-Man and Mii two guys I never want to see in smash.

If you vote for me please say why!

 

[TheZombiePig]

I'm between Sunny and Angel Glory.
Sunny because of both bikers and for devil without Tamagon.
Angel Glory for Classic Link over Toon Link, and an odd choice of representation for Pokemon.
I'll have to think about this for a bit.

 

[Smasher 101]

It's between Angelglory for still having only five Pokemon slots, with two of them being fire types (three if you count Monferno), and The Light Music Club because I feel like three transforming Zelda characters is a bit much, and if Fire Emblem has four characters then I think Star Fox should too. I decided that last thing is understandable, plus Light's not the only one who did that, so I voted for Angelglory.

 

[The Light Music Club]

It's between Angelglory for still having only five Pokemon slots, with two of them being fire types (three if you count Monferno), and The Light Music Club because I feel like three transforming Zelda characters is a bit much, and if Fire Emblem has four characters then I think Star Fox should too. I decided that last thing is understandable, plus Light's not the only one who did that, so I voted for Angelglory.

Cool. I had Krystal/Leon planned for next round anyway! And yeah I'm thinking about removing Ganon, I just had him originally so I could put back in Ganondorf.

 

[Angelglory]

Shoot, I accidentaly voted for ZombiePig. I meant to vote Sunny, for the reasons others have already stated.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Shoot, I accidentaly voted for ZombiePig. I meant to vote Sunny, for the reasons others have already stated.

i'll make sure to make note of it when it ends

 

[kylexv]

Sunnydust- Ashely or Syrup would of worked better as a second Wario rep, Missing Falco, Missing Charizard, 2 e-shop reps, Devil over Tamagon, having both bikers.

Light- More FE than Star Fox, King Hippo, Medusa or Hades would of worked better as a third KI rep, 2 e-shop reps.

Andiminda- 2 e-shop reps

Smasher 101- Solid roster right here, but is playing a little too safe.

Angelglory- Classic Link, Pokemon still at 5, 2 e-shop reps.

TheZombiePig- Sylveon, adding two third parties without Sonic, More FE than Star Fox

Ended up voting Sunnydust because of having the most negatives above.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Voted for SunnyDust. It's just too bizarre to represent a series without its main character (The Devil vs Tamagon).

 

[andimidna]

Sunnydust- Ashely or Syrup would of worked better as a second Wario rep, Missing Falco, Missing Charizard, 2 e-shop reps, Devil over Tamagon, having both bikers.

Light- More FE than Star Fox, King Hippo, Medusa or Hades would of worked better as a third KI rep, 2 e-shop reps.

Andiminda- 2 e-shop reps

Smasher 101- Solid roster right here, but is playing a little too safe.

Angelglory- Classic Link, Pokemon still at 5, 2 e-shop reps.

TheZombiePig- Sylveon, adding two third parties without Sonic, More FE than Star Fox

Ended up voting Sunnydust because of having the most negatives above.

This is an interesting perspective. Is 2 eshop reps really a problem? I hadn't even considered that. That was actually part of the reason I added Mallo, but I guess I see what you mean. Huh...
Do other people here think 2 eshop reps is a bad idea?

 

[Tepig2000]

Two E-shop reps aren't needed, but I don't see it as a problem.

 

[The Light Music Club]

Looks like my roster might need a makeover to please you guys. Wondering what the next round will have in store with us.

 

[kylexv]

Next week, I will unable to be able to get on a PC. Not sure what I'm gonna do with this, though

 

[LoneKonWolf]

meh, he he he, sorry for the late update mates, when ya get busy, you get busy

(going back to twilight sympathy, if you don't like it leave)

. . . .
the votes this time were pitiful

the fallen this time was an user named @SunnyDust,
looks like you've pulled the hammer out too soon,
and added someone that shouldn't been in,
it missed and your gone

were done to 6,
the game is ending soon,
the last couple of drips are falling into the coffee pot,
and the final scene is being set,
but there's an problem though. . .

tell me users . . .

have you ever heard of the term "inflation"?

in an economy. . .
when more and more money gets placed into it,
goods and services increased in value,
making the value and spending of money smaller and smaller,
and eventually after enough cause its value becomes next to worthless.

that is whats happening now,
the users that are in game are now going through the slots like their hard candy,
just waiting for more just to devour them,
till eventually all the slots the person has is useless,

so. . . how about we fix that little problem eh?
in order to bring back the value of the slots,
we must make them more important again.

now have you ever heard the phrase
"an man who has next to nothing has more to cherish than an man who has everything"?

it meaning is that the less you have of something,
the more of importance it has.

do you see the picture?

. . .

I want you all to cut your rosters down to half,
I want only 35 slots, no extra cuts, no replacing
and if their is any more, you'll be receiving an penalty from my good friend joe​

[collapse=vote count]

• Andiminda 0 (0%)

• Angelglory 2 (25%)

• The Light Music Club 1 (12.50%)

• Smasher 101 0 (0%)

• Sunnydust 4 (50%)

• kylexv 0 (0%)

• TheZombiePIg 1 (12.50%)

[/collapse]

[collapse=surviving contestants]
@ andimidna
@ Angelglory
@ The Light Music Club
@ Smasher 101
@ kylexv
@ TheZombiePig
[/collapse]
[collapse=rosters]
[/collapse]​

the break period will end (hopefully) on Thursday, around 8 PM eastern
i'll be waiting​

 

[Angelglory]

Is that no veteran rule still in effect?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Is that no veteran rule still in effect?

Yes,
And even then you can't add or replace anything. So it technically doesn't matter in this round

 

[The Light Music Club]

Ok, here is my new roster. Does it look familiar? It should. This is my roster back when we had 35 slots earlier in the game. Except, I put Greninja over Lucario, Wolf over Falco, R.O.B. over Lip and Isaac over Wii Fit Trainer:

Donbe and Hikari stayed because I needed a duo character, and I couldn't have the Ice Climbers since they weren't currently on my roster.

 

[Angelglory]

Too lazy to list all the cuts. Mario gets 4 characters, Zelda/Pokemon get 3, others get 2, the rest get 1

Total Series: 23​

 

[Tepig2000]

This is a really cool round. Too bad I didn't survive long enough. (I didn't even get through one round actually ).

 

[Smasher 101]

@ LoneKonWolf I dropped Chrom and replaced him with Robin a couple of rounds ago, but accidentally undid the swap last round without realizing it. Can I still have Robin this round because of this, or no?

 

[SmasherMaster]

Wait, do the veterans cut this round remain cut?

 

[kylexv]

Again, I may change this later.
Series: 20
Honerable Mentions: Sheik, Zero Suit Samus, Shulk, Dillon, Chibi-Robo, Ray, Saki, Chrom, Duck Hunt Dog.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Aww so much for Sylveon and Doshin.

Still though, I'm liking the sound of this round.

 

[andimidna]

@ LoneKonWolf I dropped Chrom and replaced him with Robin a couple of rounds ago, but accidentally undid the swap last round without realizing it. Can I still have Robin this round because of this, or no?

It all comes down to what lonekonwolf says, but my personal opinion is that you wouldn't have had a vote last round either way: Chrom or Robin. So I think it seems fair, but wait till he responds.

---------------------------------

I think I'll be posting my roster today.

 

[The Light Music Club]

Aww so much for Sylveon and Doshin.

Still though, I'm liking the sound of this round.

You should keep one character you like. Donbe and Hikari have been with me since round three. I aint given up on them now. (But I need a duo so it makes sense there too.)

 

[andimidna]

It was hard to cut Takamaru, Falco, Lip, Chibi Robo, Saki, Mach Rider, Dillon, Andy, K Rool, Anna, and Dixie Kong... but I had to...
These 11 almost made it on my roster, but I cut them for my last 5 slots that I had to pick, which went to Isaac, Robin, Wolf, Mr. Game and Watch, and R.O.B.
Wolf was picked over Falco partly because he's slightly more unique, partly because as an antagonist he has a bigger role in the series, and mostly because lonekonwolf is our host
The rest of the cuts I made were less necessary than the ones I kept. So I won't be explaining each one.
Only other notable think I did with my roster this round was take Ganon out of Ganondorf, he's his own Dorf now, alone. I just like the icon of him alone better. The only one I have of the team has OoT + classic designs. I'd prefer TP and ALBW, personally, and apparantly one just like that was added to version 8.0... but I don't have 8.0, so this is what I have.
When dealing with a challenge, I don't care for adding risks. I hope nobody votes for "playing it safe" on a challenge round, I think challenge rounds are what's supposed to keep it from not being safe, and you're supposed to make the best of what you have. Which it looks like everybody has done so far, so I'm not too worried about that.

WAIT... My roster isn't loading...
I will edit it in later, I might have to restart my computer.

Got it!
Other characters not mentioned above that have been removed include: Toad, Rosalina, Captain Syrup, Vaati, Skull Kid, Starfy, Wii Fit Trainer, Meowth, Zoroark, Dark Samus, Tiki, Bandana Dee, Porky, Samurai Goroh, Hikari and Donbe, Ayumi, Wonder Red, Mallo, Ray, Captain Rainbow, Duck Hunt Dog, Medusa, Krystal, and Balloon Fighter.
And... I think that's all of them.
I think that keeping Isaac, Mewtwo, Lucario, Pokemon Trainer, Ridley, Robin, Meta Knight, Shulk, Wolf, Palutena, Villager, Little Mac, Game and Watch, and ROB is all justified. And I think that if anyone cuts any of the characters I have on my roster that were not mentioned in that list, they'll be getting votes. (Like Peach, Diddy, Dedede, Olimar, etc.)

 

[TheZombiePig]

These rosters look shockingly tiny after how they were last round.
Notable cuts from my roster:
Toon Link, Tetra, and Vaati: Half of the Zelda characters needed to say bye bye so I went with the Toon Characters. Simple, but sad decision.
Palutena: A series with such a small amount of games, it felt necessary to cut Palutena in order to keep more franchises around.
Falco: Wolf is a better option in my opinion. He is an antagonist of the series, rather than one of three team-mates.
Robin: I was back-and-forth between Robin and Anna, but I settled on Anna for her longevity in the series.
Meowth and Sylveon: Guess it had to happen.
Doshin: Sigh....
Megaman and Banjo: It didn't feel right having these third parties without Sonic.

I did get to keep Excitebiker, though. Whenever I got to add him, everyone else was picking Mach Rider, but I chose Excitebiker, because his series felt more classic, and has had more titles in the series. I really liked having him on the roster.

 

[The Light Music Club]

View attachment 14438
These rosters look shockingly tiny after how they were last round.
Notable cuts from my roster:
Toon Link, Tetra, and Vaati: Half of the Zelda characters needed to say bye bye so I went with the Toon Characters. Simple, but sad decision.
Palutena: A series with such a small amount of games, it felt necessary to cut Palutena in order to keep more franchises around.
Falco: Wolf is a better option in my opinion. He is an antagonist of the series, rather than one of three team-mates.
Robin: I was back-and-forth between Robin and Anna, but I settled on Anna for her longevity in the series.
Meowth and Sylveon: Guess it had to happen.
Doshin: Sigh....
Megaman and Banjo: It didn't feel right having these third parties without Sonic.

I did get to keep Excitebiker, though. Whenever I got to add him, everyone else was picking Mach Rider, but I chose Excitebiker, because his series felt more classic, and has had more titles in the series. I really liked having him on the roster.

In my mind if you have Palutena or Ridley your good, so right now I think you are fine.

 

[kylexv]

Edited my roster

Replaced Toon Link with Palutena.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

@ LoneKonWolf I dropped Chrom and replaced him with Robin a couple of rounds ago, but accidentally undid the swap last round without realizing it. Can I still have Robin this round because of this, or no?

. . . . . . . To err is human, to forgive, divine. Humans aren't machines. . . they have souls, feelings. They live, they die, they love, they hate. . . And yes, they even make mistakes. . . .

 

[Smasher 101]

This is almost the same roster I had when we last had this many slots, but with Mr. Game & Watch over Mach Rider and Robin over Ike.

 

[The Light Music Club]

As much as I love Donbe and Hikari, I feel like I'll get voted off for not having Ridley, so I'm putting him in and cutting my duo as much as it pains me. They are for sure coming back ASAP.

New roster:

 

[TheZombiePig]

Hello?
Anybody alive?

 

[LoneKonWolf]

the break period will end (hopefully) on Thursday, around 8 PM eastern
i'll be waiting​

or Friday afternoon, close enough

no flavor, I've only got an couple of minutes
24 hours maybe/probably longer to vote, explain why you vote, this is not the end of punishment, something coffee related, ands that's the gist
[collapse=surviving contestants]

@ andimidna
@ Angelglory
@ The Light Music Club
@ Smasher 101
@ kylexv
@ TheZombiePig
[/collapse]
[collapse=rosters]
Angelglory -

The Light Music Club -

Smasher 101 -

kylexv -

TheZombiePig -

Andiminda -

[/collapse]​

click here to vote

the elimination period will end Saturday, guaranteed by the way
good luck​

 

[The Light Music Club]

Angelglory. Pokemon needs 4 I think.

 

[Angelglory]

Voted for Kyle for only having Gen 1 reps.

 

[Chase]

Voted for Angelglory for a multitude of reasons.

• FALCO BEFORE WOLF & META KNIGHT - Uggh, I really don't like Falco, especially before Wolf, and without MK? No way José.
• LACK OF CHARIZARD - Ok, Monferno without Charizard just makes me cringe.

 

[TheZombiePig]

Voted for AngelGlory. The choices for the Pokemon characters don't seem right. I think at 35 characters, Pokemon should definitely have 35. And while your Pokemon Trainer does add generation diversity, it feels more forced than anything.

 

[Angelglory]

Yeah, I can see where this is going. GG, guys.

 

[Smasher 101]

Voted for Angelglory for the lack of Meta Knight and only three Pokemon slots.

 

[kylexv]

Voted for AngelGlory because he voted for me of only 2 Kirby and only 3 Pokemon.