SmashBoards Roster Evolution (11-1, break)

[pupNapoleon]

Cant get real life votes from different accounts? Well, I'm out. Cant do much if I cannot convince the people I know in real life. Ah well. Good game.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

Ok cool. I thought so. I have the means to counter them, but thanks for letting me know.

by meaning you can counter them I hope it doesn't mean cheating

 

[The Light Music Club]

by meaning you can counter them I hope it doesn't mean cheating

I have a large "Framily" as Sprint would say. That's a lot of votes. My brother and sister were going to help me and may have voted, that would be why there are some multiple ones of the same IP addy and I apologize for that.

I wouldn't cheat or get help from people who aren't interested in this (my brother has an account on the boards though) unless someone was doing it to me. And I'm glad that won't be happening.

 

[pupNapoleon]

by meaning you can counter them I hope it doesn't mean cheating

If it is considered such to ask people I know that are here with me and have been invested in this game, then I apologize and will resign.
I vaguely remember reading (when I read the whole thread some time ago,) 'get friends to vote for others, if you dont want to lose

yes; what light said.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I have a large "Framily" as Sprint would say. That's a lot of votes. My brother and sister were going to help me and may have voted, that would be why there are some multiple ones of the same IP addy and I apologize for that.

I wouldn't cheat or get help from people who aren't interested in this (my brother has an account on the boards though) unless someone was doing it to me. And I'm glad that won't be happening.

If it is considered such to ask people I know that are here with me, then I apologize and will resign.
I vaguely remember reading (when I read the whole thread some time ago,) 'get friends to vote for others, if you dont want to lose

yes; what light said.

I really wouldn't say its against the rules, but it does inherit personal biasum,
I would make this clear, I don't want this to go out of control both of you, I have eyes on the vote count

 

[pupNapoleon]

I'd like to resign, then. If that is the case, I dont want it to get messy, and would rather it be considered fair.
So, open up the poll again and allow people to vote, I was under the impression the goal was to find smashaholics and get them to vote*

This game is fun, dont let anything I nor Light may have said ruin that. I am content watching and commenting. And in another round drawing my own rosters to the top

**and get people on the site

 

[The Light Music Club]

I really wouldn't say its against the rules, but it does inherit personal biasum,
I would make this clear, I don't want this to go out of control both of you, I have eyes on the vote count

Alright, makes enough sense to me. I will make sure there will only be one vote from my IP addy. Sorry about that @ LoneKonWolf and sorry to everyone else for taking this outta hand. I just really like this game and am pretty competitive probably since I've been pushed as an athlete for so long. I'm glad I made my goal of top ten. Best of luck to everyone. But just know I still plan on winning (within the rules of course).

 

[LoneKonWolf]

I'd like to resign, then. If that is the case, I dont want it to get messy, and would rather it be considered fair.
So, open up the poll again and allow people to vote, I was under the impression the goal was to find smashaholics and get them to vote.

This game is fun, dont let anything I nor Light may have said ruin that. I am content watching and commenting. And in another round drawing my own rosters to the top

the poll never closed and won't till sunday (just in case I don't come on, I don't want the thing running)
the goal of this game is to have an interesting roster competition that allows individual users and guests to vote out ones that they don't like/make sense and eventually chose a winner
i'll be keeping as it is now, and eventually end this thing on Saturday, i'll only be accepting one vote per IP to avoid multiple.
if you still want to resign then i'll cut you out at the end of the period

 

[pupNapoleon]

you can do as you wish. I was just speaking with Light in private, may have gotten out of hand here but we have patched things up I think haha.

Keeping the same poll up after she and I have told other fans doesnt seem to ameliorate the problem; so, if I dont get eliminated, then to be fair, I am disqualified.

 

[SmasherMaster]

I'm voting for somebody who cut the following three characters: and .

The following people applied: Chase, Light Music Club, The Sheik, Sunny Dust and Andimidna.

So I then looked at the four series that could cause the most strangeness. The three series that would determine my outlook were Mother, Fire Emblem, Pikmin and Pokemon.

Everybody had Ness and Porky.

With Fire Emblem, everybody kept Marth, but everybody cut Ike, but I can understand that due to the nasture of the round.. (I am suprised nobody cut Marth for Chrom and/or Lucina seeing how many people replaced Olimar with Alph.)

Speaking of Olimar and Alph, both Andimidna and Light Music Club both kept Oliamr, so it was down to Chase, The Sheik and Sunny Dust.

Pokemon wise, these were what they had. This was after taking out Pikachu and Mewtwo, who everybody had.
Chase has Charizard, Meowth and Zoroark.
The Sheik had Meowth, Lucario and Gardevoir.
Sunny Dust has Blaziken, Zoroark and Greninja.

I voted for The Sheik over the other because of the lack of a starter. which I think is more important to the series as a whole. Plus Gardevoir stood out a little.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

(might post music later, for now not)

running late, no flavor
@ pupNapoleon out, not big of a shock, but I would like to ask to not have a repeat of yesterdays,
60 slots, only 2 cuts, make what you can
[collapse=vote count]

• Andiminda 0

• angelglory 0

• chase 1

• TheLightMusicClub 6

• The_Sheik 1

• Smasher101 0

• SunnyDust 0

• DukeNapoleon 8

• kylexv 1

• thezomebiepig 1

[/collapse]
[collapse=surviving contestants]
@ andimidna
@ Angelglory
@ Chase
@ The Light Music Club
@ The_Sheik
@ Smasher 101
@ SunnyDust
@ kylexv
@ TheZombiePig
[/collapse]
[collapse=rosters]
[/collapse]

you have till mondayish to get your rosters in​

 

[Chase]

Alright here we go. This round was a bit eh for me.

• REST IN PEACE: Alph and Zoroark
• HE HAS COMETH AGAIN: R.O.B., Ganondorf, Wolf, Lucario, Meta Knight, and Olimar.

NEWCOMER:

• SONIC SPEEDS IN - Wanted to add a third-party, and Sonic is the most iconic. Was the only character in my original plan I added this round (Ganon and Chibi-Robo also being part of that plan)

HONORABLE MENTIONS: Mega Man, Muddy Mole (remenants of the original plan), Ike, Mr. Game and Watch, Toon Link, and Ice Climbers.

This round I played it kind of safe, but I'm calling the next few rounds "Spring Cleaning"; I'll be gradually clearing out the characters added in last round (with the exception of Ganon, Rhythm Team, and Chibi-Robo), but some I may add later. Right now, Alph and Zoroark were just the dust bunnies I started clearing out. Next targets are Balloon Fighter and Vaati.

 

[TheZombiePig]

A much friendlier round than last, though I really like some of the choices it forced on people.

Most of the characters added were cut from the last round.
-Cut:
Alph
Krystal (she'll probly make it back soon)

-Added:
Olimar: I REALLY did not like cutting him for Alph. He's much more important to the series.
Toad: The only newcomer this round. Stacked up against Bowser Jr, his appearances have just been so much more consistent as of late. It almost seems like Bowser Jr. is being faded out in favor of the Koopalings.
Toon Link: It was a tough call to cut him with Tetra still on the roster. I wanted him back.
Meta Knight: No brainer. Didn't like having Bandana Dee without him.
Falco: He's more important than Krystal.
Mewtwo: Putting both Mario and Zelda up to 6, Pokemon should have been as well. And Mewtwo is the clear choice. And Sylveon's sticking around.
Ice Climbers: I miss R.O.B, but I feel they should be back before him.

At this point in the game, I'm not sure about third parties. I've been wanting them in for several rounds, but there are plenty of Nintendo characters still to add in.

 

[The Light Music Club]

Edit: Some of this has changed. New roster is in a later post.


In an effort to clean up the mess I made, I cut the two characters I felt I got the most hate for: Krystal and Zoroark, replacing them with the two people more important, Mewtwo and Wolf

I kept Ghirahim because he wasn't as much of an eyesore as the other two were. Ashley should be here now that we are at sixty, and Anna seemed okay to still have. I also kept Hoenn Trainer because I like that combo of the three pokemon as well with the new remakes being announced.

To be more organized here is who I added:
- Toad - It seemed odd to be one of the few without six Mario characters by now.
- Mewtwo - Third most important Pokemon character I think
- Meta Knight - He is a very important character to have, and I hated having to cut him
- Wolf - To make Lonekonwolf happy as well as the fact I plan on adding another Starwolf guy soon
- Mr. Game and Watch - Easily the most important retro
- R.O.B - Important retro, and I already have a duo so no need for Ice Climbers over him
- Agent J - I like him more than the countless rosters with RH characters.

Top Nine! I hope I can make it to the next round!

Oh, I might change this later based on other peoples rosters.

 

[kylexv]

First of all, Alph and Gardevoir were cut for Olimar and Jigglypuff, respectively.
Added 3 cuts from last round: Toon Link, Zero Suit Samus, and Mr. Game and Watch.
Also added two newcomers: Dixie Kong and Starfy.
Ganondorf, Ike, Lucario, Wolf, and R.O.B. have to wait just a little bit longer, as they would over represent their respective series. (R.O.B. being retro)

New series: Legend of Starfy
Returning Series: Game and Watch
Total Series: 31 (Mario, Donkey Kong, Yoshi, Wario, Legend of Zelda, Kid Icarus, Fire Emblem, Golden Sun, Kirby, Earthbound/Mother, Animal Crossing, Pokemon, Metroid, Star Fox, Custom Robo, F-Zero, Chibi-Robo, Xenoblade, Punch Out!!, Game and Watch, Ice Climber, Balloon Fight, Duck Hunt, Mach Rider, Nazo no Murasme-jō, Pikmin, Rolling Western, Legend of Starfy, Wii Fit, Rhythm Heaven, Wii.)

 

[The Light Music Club]

Ok, I cut Hoenn Trainer because I think people like her less than Zoroark. Also added Ganondorf to Ganon:

Series: Mario, Yoshi, Donkey Kong, Punch Out!, Pokemon, Zelda, Wii Fit, Animal Crossing, Kirby, Star Fox, Metriod, Pikmin, Wario, F-Zero, Fire Emblem, Earthbound/Mother, Kid Icarus, Custom Robo, Dillon's Rolling Western, Golden Sun, Chibi-Robo, Advanced Wars, Xenoblade Chronicles, Mach Rider, Panel de Pon, Shin Onigashima, The Riddle of Murasame Castle, Duck Hunt, Game and Watch, Gyromite, Elite Beat Agents (31 Series)

Characters still wanted to be added but couldn't yet: Micaiah, Leon, Toon Link, Ayumi Tachibana, Ike, Masked Man, Lucas, Ice Climbers, Lucario

 

[andimidna]

This might change. But for now:

I needed to overhaul my Pokemon roster. So I cut Zoroark and Hoenn Trainer (Blaziken, Grovyle, Mudkip), I also put Greninja in the trainer Pokemon as part of Charizard, Sceptile, and Greninja
Ganondorf was added as part of Ganon. As a transformation by final smash like ZSS, or whatever you want it to be. Choosing how transformation characters work isn't really part of the game.
For Pokemon, I needed more iconic picks, so I chose Meowth and Lucario.
Now, while I don't think these characters really have the merits for a good smash character on their own, their series needed more representation. So, Bandana Dee and Samurai Goroh.
And of course I brought back Wolf!
I also added back Mr. Game and Watch and ROB, they took priority over Ice Climbers because they're historical, and I already have a retro duo.

(I meant to post this message last night but fell asleep, I might have left something out)

 

[Angelglory]

Cut: Alph, Zoroark
Returning: Sheik, ZSS, Olimar, Ice Climbers, Charizard, Wolf
Newcomers: Lyn, Duck Hunt Dog, Bandana Dee
New Series: Duck Hunt
Total Series: 34​

 

[Gunla]

@ LoneKonWolf
Was looking and I wanted to give you a headsup about avoiding double/triple voting.
Some advice:
A: They can only use a computer one time to vote.
B: IPs are always checked.

 

[SunnyDust]

CUT : Blaziken and Alph
RETURNING : Ganondorf (with Ganon), Lucario, Mr. G&W, R.O.B. and Ice Climbers.
NEWCOMERS : Bandana Dee and Muddy Mole.
TOTAL SERIES : 36

HONORABLE MENTIONS : Charizard, Ike, Duck Hunt Dog, Mallo, Sonic and Mega Man.

 

[The Light Music Club]

I'm pretty sure I know who I'm voting for. I don't think any other roster can change that. I hope we get more cuts next round. I want to clean up this "oil spill" of a roster.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

View attachment 13934

CUT : Zoroark, Blaziken, Alph and Excite Biker.
RETURNING : Ganondorf (with Ganon), Charizard, Lucario, Mr. G&W, R.O.B. and Ice Climbers.
NEWCOMERS : Bandana Dee, Mallo and Muddy Mole.
Total series : 36

only two cuts can be made, that's four,

 

[andimidna]

View attachment 13934

CUT : Zoroark, Blaziken, Alph and Excite Biker.

only 2 cuts

:o

Edit: 'd

 

[SunnyDust]

only two cuts can be made, that's four,

Fixed.

 

[Angelglory]

Just edited my roster in my previous post, swapped Goroh for Wolf.

 

[Smasher 101]

Alright, my roster actually uploaded this time.

And neat, I think I've now made it farther than I did last game.

Krystal and Skull Kid are being swapped out for Wolf and Toon Link. Ganondorf is also being added to Ganon, though I'm not particularly fond of this idea, so I may end up changing it back to just dorf eventually.

Lucario, Ice Climbers, R.O.B., and Sonic all return this round. Sorry Lucas, Ike, and Jigglypuff, you'll have to wait a little longer, as the last spot is going to a new addition: Bowser Jr., as I need Mario and Pokemon to have the same number of characters.

 

[The_Sheik]

Cut: Alph and Robin

Added back: Olimar, Ike, Toon Link, Zero Suit Samus (Now a part of Samus), Falco, Mr. Game & Watch and R.O.B.

New characters: Rosalina, Pokémon Trainer (Charizard, Grovyle and Oshawott)

Sheik is now a part of Zelda.

 

[SunnyDust]

Sooooo... When's the update?

 

[The_Sheik]

@ SmasherMaster you voted me for not having any starters, so now I added 3.

 

[LoneKonWolf]

(classic snes goodness, learn to like it)

still no flavor, you get that tomorrow
1 day to vote, please explain why you voted, blab, blab, same old, same old
[collapse=surviving contestants]
@ andimidna
@ Angelglory
@ Chase
@ The Light Music Club
@ The_Sheik
@ Smasher 101
@ SunnyDust
@ kylexv
@ TheZombiePig
[/collapse]
[collapse=rosters]
Chase -

TheZombiePig -

Kylexv -

The Light Music Club -

Andiminda -

Angelglory -

Sunnydust -

Smasher 101 -

The_sheik -

[/collapse]

Click here to vote

the elimination period will end around Tuesday. . . . maybe
good luck mates, i'll be watching. . . .​

 

[The Light Music Club]

Chase has no Game and Watch. He should have been the number one retro priority. ZombiePig, you should have had R.O.B. over ICs though.

So yeah, Chase is it.

Oh and @ LoneKonWolf the video only works on Youtube. Other site playback is disabled.

Banking on a ten addition 5 cuts next round. I really hope that's what it is.

 

[Chase]

Chase has no Game and Watch. He should have been the number one retro priority. ZombiePig, you should have had R.O.B. over ICs though.

So yeah, Chase is it.

Oh and @ LoneKonWolf the video only works on Youtube. Other site playback is disabled.

With all due respect, ROB essentially saved the early gaming industry. So in my opinion, ROB is number 1 priority.

Anyway, my vote ended up being for Angelglory because Star Fox does not deserve four characters while F-Zero is still sitting at one.

 

[The Light Music Club]

With all due respect, ROB essentially saved the early gaming industry. So in my opinion, ROB is number 1 priority.

Anyway, my vote ended up being for Angelglory because Star Fox does not deserve four characters while F-Zero is still sitting at one.

I guess. I honestly think both should be there, but no Game just felt strange to me.

 

[Chase]

I guess. I honestly think both should be there, but no Game just felt strange to me.

It's understandable. Game & Watch is considered the original Retro, so it makes sense to feel a bit of a tick if he isn't present.

 

[The Light Music Club]

It's understandable. Game & Watch is considered the original Retro, so it makes sense to feel a bit of a tick if he isn't present.

Oh also, the fact that you had Ganon and Ganondorf as their own characters, but not Game and Watch, while everyone who didn't have Game and Watch or R.O.B. had Ice Climbers.

 

[SmasherMaster]

@ SmasherMaster you voted me for not having any starters, so now I added 3.

To be fair, I voted for you because you cut G+W, Ice Climbers and ROB. Pokemon was the way I choose because some people cut all three of them.

 

[kylexv]

I'm first pointing out the flaws I saw in the rosters:

Chase: Ganon and Ganondorf as seperate characters, Vaati, but no Toon Link, missing Game and Watch, Dark Matter over Bandanna Dee

TheZombiePig: Sylveon. Otherwise, pretty good.

The Light Music Club: Viridi. Otherwise, pretty good.

Andiminda: Vaati, but no Toon Link, 4 Star Fox reps, 3 KI reps.

Angelglory: 6 Zelda reps including transformations, but no Toon Link, no non-sword-weilding FE rep, strange PT pokemon choices

SunnyDust: 6 Zelda reps including transformations, but no Toon Link, missing Falco, only 2 Kanto Pokemon (Most notably missing Charizard).

Smasher 101: Flawless

The_sheik: Lacking a FE rep that is not a blue-haired swordsman, strange PT pokemon choices.

I narrowed it down to Chase, SunnyDust, Angelglory, and The_sheik, but ultimately chose Chase because of missing some prized veterans and making strange choices Zelda series wise.

 

[andimidna]

I think I'm choosing Chase because of Dark Matter and Ganon separate but Sheik with Zelda. But, like usual, I'm going to think about it.

 

[Smasher 101]

Voted for Chase for a few reasons:

-Ganon and Dorf are separate characters even though ZSS and Sheik are transformations.
-Only brought back one veteran retro, and could use more retros in general.
-Dark Matter over Bandana Dee.

 

[andimidna]

Vaati, but no Toon Link

Well, to be fair, Vaati is a Zelda villain, and not a Toon Zelda villain. There's no such thing as a Toon series, like there is for say... Paper Mario. Which I think is solidified by the fact he's represented with a triforce icon identical to the rest of the Zelda cast.
WW has 2 DS sequels, and there's a separate 4 swords trilogy on GBA and GC, but it's not an official side-series, it's simply a few Zelda games with a unique art-style It's still called Legend of Zelda, and in-game the hero is called Link, not Toon Link.


But the rest you said is true, I know I over-represented those franchises. (which I'm going to keep simply because I like Krystal and Medusa )