• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Official Smash Ultimate Discussion

Almost one month has passed since release. In retrospect....

  • This is by far the best Smash ever. Like, I don't even know how they will top this.

  • Pretty freakin' good; I have a few qualms over things like internet play, balancing issues, etc.

  • It's ok, but [insert Smash game here] is better.

  • I'd rather play Parcheesi.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Hinata

Never forget, a believing heart is your magic.
Joined
Nov 10, 2013
Messages
7,621
Switch FC
SW-5535-3962-2797
If they do make a sequel to Uprising, they'd better improve the control scheme. Having to control the camera with the touchscreen was a huge pain.
The touch screen isn't nearly as much of a prevalent feature on the Switch as it was on the 3DS. Plus, the Switch actually comes with a second joystick by default, so I'm sure the controls would be vastly improved.
 

Senselessbreak

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 24, 2014
Messages
1,151
Ten out of eighteen pokemon types are represented in Smash 4:

Electric
- Pikachu
Fire - Charizard
Flying - Charizard
Fairy - Jigglypuff
Normal - Jigglypuff
Water - Greninja
Dark - Greninja
Psychic - Mewtwo
Fighting - Lucario
Steel - Lucario

Your task is to add the other 8 types with no more than 5 pokemon. Who do you pick?
5 Pokemon is farrrr too easy. I can do this with just one choice.

ARCEUS (with plates)

Come at me brah.
 

APC99

Smash Master
Joined
Jun 12, 2013
Messages
4,244
Location
Appleton, WI
NNID
APC-99
3DS FC
3840-8265-8211
What I was trying to say is I'm proud to like stuff that people hate.
upload_2018-4-10_23-7-35.png


Contrarianism makes not a compelling argument.

I'm not going to start an ethics debate, but advocating for something simply because the general consensus is negative, again, lacks creativity and favors attention over discussion. I could type pages upon pages of essays why so-and-so is deserving of being in Smash and how everyone else is wrong and smells bad, but to what purpose?

Ten out of eighteen pokemon types are represented in Smash 4:

Electric
- Pikachu
Fire - Charizard
Flying - Charizard
Fairy - Jigglypuff
Normal - Jigglypuff
Water - Greninja
Dark - Greninja
Psychic - Mewtwo
Fighting - Lucario
Steel - Lucario

Your task is to add the other 8 types with no more than 5 pokemon. Who do you pick?
Grass / Ghost: Decidueye
Rock: Lycanroc
Bug / Poison: Beedrill
Dragon / Ground: Garchomp
Ice: Beartic, though if not for overlap, I'd go with Weavile.

I almost went for Sandshrew, but... I guess not today, little pal. :(
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
Dr. Mario should stay separate and become de-cloned even further. Add the viruses into his moveset, etc, etc.
You don't know how much I want this.

If having more representation of the Dr. Mario franchise will get people to stop ******** about how he should be an alt just because he's "Mario in a lab coat", then I'm all for it.
 

Danpal65

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,069
Location
Australia
Ideally i’d want Viridi playable too as she has a lot of moveset potential and smash lacks a nature based character.
That would be pretty awesome, heck, any of the other major characters from Uprising would be hype. However, I feel like Sakurai might feel like dialing back his support for KI this game as he gave them two characters last game.

Although another KI character would be awesome, if he could decline Dark Pit more, in a similar vain to how you suggested, I think that would be adequate for this game, although more reps would be great.
 
Last edited:

CBO0tz

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 2, 2014
Messages
1,055
Location
Yoshi's Island
Cool challenge!

Well personally I would go:

Grass - Decidueye
Ghost - Decidueye / Froslass
Dragon - Flygon
Ground - Flygon
Ice - Beartic / Froslass
Rock - Lycanrock (Midday/Dusk?)
Bug - Beedrill
Poison - Beedrill
Beedril should def come back as a Poke ball pokemon.
 

Senselessbreak

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 24, 2014
Messages
1,151
That would be pretty awesome, heck, any of the other major characters from Uprising would be hype. However, I feel like Sakurai might feel like dialing back his support for KI this game as he gave them two characters last game.

Although another KI character would be awesome, if he could decline Dark Pit more, in a similar vain to how you suggested, I think that would be adequate for this game, although more reps would be great.
I just want a proper villain like Hades or Medusa. Viridi would be nice in addition to a villain though. Phosphora and Magnus are perfect as ATs.
 

Verde Coeden Scalesworth

Flap and Swish~
Premium
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
34,385
Location
Cull Hazard
NNID
Irene4
3DS FC
1203-9265-8784
Switch FC
SW-7567-8572-3791
Beedril should def come back as a Poke ball pokemon.
I honestly miss it. It had a fun range, definitely was strong, but not unavoidable(it's no Gust Bellows or Palkia...). It felt just the right balance of strength overall.

I also wonder why new Legendary smol Pokemon will show up. Marshadow maybe?
 

Superyoshiom

Smash Master
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
4,337
Location
The Basement
NNID
Superyoshiom
View attachment 141211

Contrarianism makes not a compelling argument.

I'm not going to start an ethics debate, but advocating for something simply because the general consensus is negative, again, lacks creativity and favors attention over discussion. I could type pages upon pages of essays why so-and-so is deserving of being in Smash and how everyone else is wrong and smells bad, but to what purpose?



Grass / Ghost: Decidueye
Rock: Lycanroc
Bug / Poison: Beedrill
Dragon / Ground: Garchomp
Ice: Beartic, though if not for overlap, I'd go with Weavile.

I almost went for Sandshrew, but... I guess not today, little pal. :(
That's not so much as his argument as it is "I want him in the game because I like him" which is fine.

All I know is that there'll be a lot of discussion when Dr. Mario gets confirmed for the game (knowing Sakurai, there's a 0% chance he'll be an alt anyways).
 
Last edited:

MrReyes96

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 27, 2018
Messages
584
I just want a proper villain like Hades or Medusa. Viridi would be nice in addition to a villain though. Phosphora and Magnus are perfect as ATs.
I’d love either, I think Medusa would be better even though I love Hades, if only to not spoil those who haven’t played uprising
 

MrReyes96

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 27, 2018
Messages
584
I liked both but tbh, Medusa felt kind of bland compared to Hades.
True but I feel like having Hades playable wouldn’t be as cool unless he constantly talked, it’s what makes Hades such a good character.
Medusa has an advantage by being in the first game too. But in perfect world we’d have 6 kid Icarus uprising characters in smash anyway
 

Mega Bidoof

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
8,463
Location
The Drought
NNID
Link46
3DS FC
1160-9840-1542
Ten out of eighteen pokemon types are represented in Smash 4:

Electric
- Pikachu
Fire - Charizard
Flying - Charizard
Fairy - Jigglypuff
Normal - Jigglypuff
Water - Greninja
Dark - Greninja
Psychic - Mewtwo
Fighting - Lucario
Steel - Lucario

Your task is to add the other 8 types with no more than 5 pokemon. Who do you pick?
Dragon/Ground - Flygon
Ghost/Grass - Decidueye
Rock - Lycanroc
Bug/Poison - Beedrill
Ice - Vanilluxe (He’d be funny, and Gen V would be the only one without a rep if I didn’t add him)
 

Danpal65

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,069
Location
Australia
Beedril should def come back as a Poke ball pokemon.
I honestly miss it. It had a fun range, definitely was strong, but not unavoidable(it's no Gust Bellows or Palkia...). It felt just the right balance of strength overall.
It would bee great if Bedroll returned, but if not at least give us Unown back, they kinda function similarly.


Woot 500 posts!
 

Verde Coeden Scalesworth

Flap and Swish~
Premium
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
34,385
Location
Cull Hazard
NNID
Irene4
3DS FC
1203-9265-8784
Switch FC
SW-7567-8572-3791
It would bee great if Bedroll returned, but if not at least give us Unown back, they kinda function similarly.


Woot 500 posts!
Yeah, it was a clear replacement. That said, the key difference is the angle of which they swarm the field. Unown have more of an arc/diagonal style, while Beedrill are completely horizontal(though they do spread out a bit).

I'm trying to think of what new Pokemon could take a similar role to these two from Sun/Moon... I mean, even with the fact Totem Pokemon can call for help, that doesn't give an easy choice. Just a justification for a swarm option.
 

Danpal65

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,069
Location
Australia
Yeah, it was a clear replacement. That said, the key difference is the angle of which they swarm the field. Unown have more of an arc/diagonal style, while Beedrill are completely horizontal(though they do spread out a bit).

I'm trying to think of what new Pokemon could take a similar role to these two from Sun/Moon... I mean, even with the fact Totem Pokemon can call for help, that doesn't give an easy choice. Just a justification for a swarm option.
The closest thing I can think of is Cutiefly, but that is a pretty terrible replacement. There aren't really any bug or flying Pokémon that would fit that role in Sun and Moon sadly.
 

Senselessbreak

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 24, 2014
Messages
1,151
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
 
Last edited:

Danpal65

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,069
Location
Australia
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Waluigi - I think would be a wacky and crazy addition.
Paper Mario - Has a lot more to draw from, and aside from nostalgia is more significant.
K Rool - While I would like both, a heavy weight villain is much needed. Plus D.K. needs some Kremling representation.
Ridley - Look. This is not even a choice.
Impa - Could easily be distinct from Sheik and Tingle just gives me the creeps.
Decidueye - Like this one much more and we need a Grass type.
Bandana Dee - More relevant to the series as a whole and Marx's popularity resurgence is only recent.
Isabelle - Infinitely more popular and has more potential for a moveset.
Springman - The guy is the face of the series we are not going to be seeing anyone else, except maybe Ribbon Girl.
Hades or Medusa - Not really fussed here, although I think Hades' character may not come across well as a playable character.
Wolf - Already been in Smash once and is more relevant.
Black Shadow - Give him Ganondorf's moveset so he can be de-cloned. Goroh works fine as an AT.
Spyro - Grew up with Spyro and find him much more appealing, plus he's a dragon.
Rayman - Although Mario + Rabbids improved my feelings towards them slightly, Rayman comes out way on top here.

Good set of questions here!
 
Last edited:

CyberHyperPhoenix

"Download Complete."
Joined
Sep 11, 2014
Messages
13,424
Location
Down on the corner, out in the street.
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi
Geno*
K Rool
Ridley
Impa
Decidueye
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Springman
Hades
Wolf
Black Shadow
Crash
Rayman
Simon Belmont

Tl;DR: the more villains the better.

*The only reason I picked Geno because of Smash Kingdom, if I'm being completely honest.
 
Last edited:

shinhed-echi

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 8, 2007
Messages
5,636
Location
Ecuador - South America
NNID
punchtropics
3DS FC
5301-0890-0238
I just want a proper villain like Hades or Medusa. Viridi would be nice in addition to a villain though. Phosphora and Magnus are perfect as ATs.
I usually don't want more characters of already represented franchises.
But boy, do I want Medusa!

I'm also not usually fond of villains. But a female villain is long overdue. (And... Are there many noticable Nintendo villain-esses?)
 

Bradli Wartooth

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
1,947
NNID
Aearlir
A cool Pokemon who could (sort of) have the swarm replacement is Alolan Rattata. They are a destructive species that raid places in swarms and attempt to establish their home. You could throw out a Rattata and then it calls its friends who swarm the stage.
 

Verde Coeden Scalesworth

Flap and Swish~
Premium
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
34,385
Location
Cull Hazard
NNID
Irene4
3DS FC
1203-9265-8784
Switch FC
SW-7567-8572-3791
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Toad
Paper Mario
K. Rool
Ridley
Tingle
Decidueye
Bandana Dee
Tom Nook
Spring Man
Medusa
Wolf
Samurai Goroh
Spyro
Rabbids
Simon Belmont

While I like Waluigi, Toad feels like he seriously is a main member of the team. I think that puts him in a spot that's deserving in my opinion. I like the moveset concepts for Paper Mario more. K. Rool I wanted more partially due to a villain, but also cause I love him in the TV show. Ridley I was more interested in due to space dragon, and major villain, and cause he's someone I just plain like. Tingle I've always been for, though Impa is still a nice choice. Decidueye feels like a fun and interesting archer type but also has lots of flying moves/bird moves that could make for a great and unique air fighter. Incineroar is still sweet, though. Bandana Dee was always more interesting to me as is, but that's more due to seeing him more among media/LP's, etc. Albeit, the anime helps to a degree, since the Waddle Dees have spears there. Tom Nook was always interesting to me(Resetti moreso). However, one notable thing is that I don't like the idea of attacking someone as cute and helpful as Isabelle. I love her as the "helper" role. I feel her being an Assist Trophy matches who she is beyond perfectly. Spring Man is the main character, and the series doesn't interest me too much, so... go with simplicity. I've wanted Medusa in for a while. I also like the character a lot, and not just cause she's a villain. Wolf I mained in Brawl, so... Samurai Goroh feels most interesting to me as we lack a Samurai, and he's not similar to Takamaru anyway. Also one of the original 4 racers of F-Zero. Spyro cause I like dragons more. Rabbids I actually have more experience with due to watching their show a bit, and I love the fact they got a crossover with Mario. They don't bother me at all and ultimately it's just a case of bias here. Coincidentally, they also have less amiibo issues(I'm sure some remember the two mock-ups. :p). Finally, Simon Belmont. I'm a fan of Captain N, but I also liked playing Castlevania more. Bomberman is still cool, though. But I want to whip some vampires. It also helps I saw the Castlevania anime some time ago, and that was awesome.
 

Bradli Wartooth

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
1,947
NNID
Aearlir
A Pokemon that I feel hasn't been discussed enough is Tapu Koko. It has been important for entirety of gen 7, being the main Totem Pokemon the player interacts with. It's also been shown off fairly often, and is even in a decent amount of the anime. It even gives the player their Z Bracelet, which plays a large role in the games and the anime. Obviously it and the other Totem Pokemon could be worked into a single Pokeball, like Latios & Latias. But the extended prominence of Tapu Koko in both the game and the anime makes me wonder about its chances.
 
Last edited:

Golden Icarus

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 4, 2013
Messages
1,132
Location
USA
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Toad - I am very much on board with either or both inclusions but I feel like Toad has earned the spot more and I’m personally more in love with the character.
Paper Mario - Very very interested with how he would play. Super Mario RPG was also before my time.
K. Rool - We deserve him.
Ridley - ^^
Impa - Tough call. Not super duper fond of either but I do think they both could be really cool.
Decidueye- Literally one of the coolest character designs I’ve ever seen. I love him.
Bandana Dee - Really close one. Bandana Dee just feels right as the fourth Kirby character though. Personally I wouldn’t be opposed to having both of them, and Galacta Knight included. For some reason I’ve just been itching for more Kirby in Smash. That’s just me. Not saying that that necessarily should happen, but yeah.
Tom Nook - My personal favorite AC character.
Min Min - Her design is far and beyond the most interesting to me. And I feel like if she were added to Smash, she would have what it takes to eventually become the face of ARMS. The series is very very young. It’s hard to tell if Spring Man is really the Ryu of the franchise or just a Liu Kang, where someone else is clearly the Scorpion. Ya feel?
Viridi.
Wolf - Miss him.
Samurai Goroh - I never ever saw the appeal in Black Shadow, aside from just taking Ganondorf’s moveset (which wanting a character just so that they can take someone else’s ****ty moveset is very strange to me). And I also feel like it would just be cool to see a character climb from cutscene character, to assist trophy, to playable.
Spyro - Love his games. Never really enjoyed Crash. No idea why.
Rayman - Without question.
Simon - Definitely the hardest one for me to choose from. I love both characters and series very very much, and while I have gained an even greater appreciation for Bomberman with Bomberman R being some of the most fun I’ve ever had with 5-8 player gaming, Simon slightly edges him out simply because I really want Castlevania music.

That was fun
 
Last edited:

Danpal65

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 10, 2014
Messages
1,069
Location
Australia
A Pokemon that I feel hasn't been discussed enough is Tapu Koko. It has been important for entirety of gen 7, being the main Totem Pokemon the player interacts with. It's also been shown off fairly often, and is even in a decent amount of the anime. It even gives the player their Z Bracelet, which plays a large role in the games and the anime. Obviously it and the other Totem Pokemon could be worked into a single Pokeball, like Latios & Latias. But the extended prominence of Tapu Koko in both the game and the anime makes me wonder about its chances.
I definitely agree that within the context of Sun and Moon Tapu Koko is significant, but, to me, Tapu Koko just does not feel like a Smash character.

That being said, I think that all four Tapu's would make excellent Pokéball Pokémon. They could all use their terrain powers around them. Koko electrifies everyone around him dealing damage, Bulu heals everyone around him, Lele slows everyone around it and Fini could do... something, out of ideas here.
 

shinhed-echi

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 8, 2007
Messages
5,636
Location
Ecuador - South America
NNID
punchtropics
3DS FC
5301-0890-0238
Toad
Geno
K Rool
Ridley
Impa
Decidueye
... Marx I guess.
Isabelle
Ribbon Girl
Medusa
Wolf
Black Shadow only if he takes over Ganon's moveset.
Crash
Rayman
Simon Belmont
 

Fenriraga

You have the strength to overcome your destiny!
Writing Team
Joined
Aug 4, 2014
Messages
4,873
Location
Wave Road
NNID
DarkAura
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi
Geno (You're asking me to choose between the two loves of my life you monster)
K Rool
Ridley
Tingle
Decidueye
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Min Min
Hades
Krystal
Samurai Goroh
Spyro
Rayman
*Points to signature*
 
Last edited:

TheSpitefulWolf

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
254
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Wolf or Krystal
yo realtalk why not both? hell i'll dump falco if it means both wolf and my blue space fox waifu get in. also only answering this one 'cause idgaf about the rest, literally just names. ****ing mad i don't see higgs up there in metroid consideration tho, as bad as other m was, it at least outdid ****ing hunters.
 

Hinata

Never forget, a believing heart is your magic.
Joined
Nov 10, 2013
Messages
7,621
Switch FC
SW-5535-3962-2797
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi
Paper Mario
Dixie Kong
Ridley (only because I haven't played enough Metroid to know who Sylux is)
Impa
Decidueye
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Min-Min
Viridi
Wolf
Samurai Goroh
Spyro
Rayman
Simon Belmont
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
I like the idea of Dr. Mario becoming a full on Deadly Doctor.

Just look at the Doctor Ability from Kirby Planet Robobot as an example. This is one of those cases where the motif is enough for the character.

He could use Needle Injections like as Jab or a Pummel, use defibrillators as electric attacks (Dr Mario already uses electricity in his foward Smash, so there's some precedent here) a parademic knife to slash enemies in close range (or are knifes too dangerous in the same way realistic fire-arms are?) and use a sethoscope as a grab or even tether.

Im just giving ideas.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

SuperMii3D

Mii-Based Fighter
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
4,221
Location
Waiting for the Switch 2
NNID
PizzaDeliveryKid
3DS FC
5284-1700-6123
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Ridley
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Daisy Toad
Paper Mario
Dixie
Tingle
Decidueye
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Springman
Hades
Krystal
Black Shadow
Crash
Rayman
Bomberman
 
Last edited:

Yellowlord

ゆゆネーター
Joined
May 11, 2015
Messages
3,635
Location
Who knows? :3
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi (I think he's waited long enough to get into Smash; give him some Mario Sports styled moves and have him represent the spinoffs).
Geno (Sakurai has considered adding him before and I think he has lots of potential as a fighter).
K Rool (I believe him to be the most likely newcomer for the next game; it's time DK got its main villain to join the fray).
Ridley (Metroid really needs a new rep like DK does; I also still think they could make Ridley work).
Impa (If they went with her HW design and abilities especially from what I've seen in gameplay videos, I could see her being quite unique).
Decidueye (Out of all the possible choices for playable Pokemon, I would consider Decidueye to be the most likely; a grass type representative would be nice to complete the main three types and also give us our first playable Ghost type Pokemon).
Bandana Dee (The last of the main 4 team of Kirby, I think he deserves to get in, especially with the fact his spear would give him a unique moveset to work with).
Isabelle (although I haven't played the Animal Crossing games before, I think she should be the second rep if one were chosen).
Ribbon Girl (Spring Man would be fine if it came down to it).
Medusa (We don't have any female villains yet: she could be the first one in the game and have a unique moveset revolving around her snakes).
Wolf (he's been in the game before and should be brought back).
Black Shadow (like many have said, giving him Ganondorf's cloned moveset would work perfectly, allowing Ganondorf to get a unique moveset and F-Zero to be granted a new rep and villain).
Neutral (both would be fine, although I know Crash ever so slightly more then Spyro even if I haven't played their games before).
Rayman (He would work incredibly well in the Smash universe; the idea of him fighting against Mario, Sonic, Pac-Man, Mega Man, and Cloud in one game just seems incredible).
Neutral (like with Crash and Spyro, I know Bomberman a bit more then I do Simon Belmont despite having not played their games).
 
Last edited:

Bradli Wartooth

Smash Lord
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
1,947
NNID
Aearlir
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi
Geno
Dixie
Ridley
Impa
Inciniroar
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Spring Man
Hades
Wolf
Black Shadow
Spyro
Rayman
Bomberman
 

JamesDNaux

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
7,760
Location
Studio Naux
NNID
JamesDNaux
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
WAH
Neither
King R. Kool
Ridley
Impa
Birb
Neither
Neither
Twintelle
Viridi
Krystal
Neither
Spyro
Rayman wtf kind of choice is this one
Simon
 

Onua

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 8, 2017
Messages
415
Location
Liberty, Missouri
Just because why not and Im super late. I imagined a trailer for Fossil Fighter cause lol why not

The hot sun basks over a dry bad land. Heat waves flicker off the sandy, rocky ground. A crow sits on a dinosaur skull and flies off. Suddenly we hear the picking of a pickaxe as it swings into the ground. The camera pans over and we see a young lad digging in the heat. It zooms in onto the pickaxe as he swings it down. Feeling somewhat deterred by the lack of fossils he wipes sweat off of his brow. He keeps digging and strikes something, his eyes light up. He digs up the fossil and looks at it, his happy expression changing to one of awe. It zooms up and we see the smash logo reflect in his eyes off of the fossil. It then zooms out revealing the desert is gone, its a pitch black area with the only light being supplied by a distant smash ball shaped sun. He drops the rock and looks in awe. He then nods and checks his vivosaur tokens before rushing towards the smash sun.
 

PLATINUM7

Star Platinum
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
12,206
NNID
PLATINUM7
3DS FC
1246-8735-0293
Switch FC
2465-5306-3806
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Waluigi
Geno
K. Rool
Ridley
Decidueye
Gooey :p
Tom Nook
Min Min
Medusa
Wolf
Samurai Goroh
Both
Rayman
Bomberman (but Snake back as well)
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Waluigi. While i feel that that Toad is playable material for Smash and is long overdue, i have a lot of attachment to Waluigi.

Geno or Paper Mario
Geno. Back in 2014 or so i would have said Paper Mario, but i have lost all interest in the franchise after Color Splash, and that pretty much made me lost all interest in the idea of playable Paper Mario. and to be honest, i would be an active Geno supporter if he was more recurring (at least on Waluigi or Daisy levels of recurring) in the Mario series.

Dixie or K Rool
K.Rool, only becuase i want him more.

Ridley or Sylux
Ridley, no doubt. I see Sylux as nothing but a request to fill a baseless "must have more reps" criteria, even when the requested character in question has barely any merit or are barely any prominence in its home series.

Impa or Tingle
Pig Ganon because im not a fan of either :troll:.

Decidueye or Inciniroar
Decidueye. While Inceneroar was my starter of choice in Sun, i feel Decidueye could make a more interesing fighter.

Bandana Dee or Marx
Bandanna Dee. I feel's he the next in line out of all the possible potential Kirby newcomers, which isn't saying much because before Star Allies, BD was pretty much seen as the only viable choice by the majority.

Isabelle or Tom Nook
Isabelle. Her popularity is undeniable, and i see her as a potential fighter if only because of that.

Springman or someone else from Arms
Springman. Putting someone else before him would be like choosing someone from Street Fighter that's not Ryu.

Hades or Medusa
Hades, because he's hilarious.

Wolf or Krystal
Wolf all day!

Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Samurai Goroh.

Crash or Spyro
Cash Banooca, obviously.

Rayman or Rabbids
Rayman. I don't want the Rabbids in Smash, although depending on their implementation they could be hilarious or really obnoxious.

Bomberman or Simon Belmont
I like Bomberman, he's one of the few non-veteran third parties i want in Smash but............

Simon Belmont is my most wanted character in Smash, even above Waluigi and K.Rool, so i'd say Simon.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

YoshiandToad

Smash Hero
Joined
Dec 24, 2001
Messages
7,123
Location
Still up Peach's dress.
So heres some questions. Would you rather have:

Toad or Waluigi
Geno or Paper Mario
Dixie or K Rool
Ridley or Sylux
Impa or Tingle
Decidueye or Inciniroar
Bandana Dee or Marx
Isabelle or Tom Nook
Springman or someone else from Arms
Hades or Medusa
Wolf or Krystal
Black Shadow or Samurai Goroh
Crash or Spyro
Rayman or Rabbids
Bomberman or Simon Belmont
Toad for obvious reasons, but I still like Waluigi
Paper Mario
Dixie
Ridley
Impa
, but Tingle is my third choice of Zelda character
Inciniroar
Bandana Dee
Isabelle
Anyone else from ARMS
, Springman is such a basic design with a horrible colour scheme he kind of puts me off ;;
Medusa, but I prefer the original KI to Uprising
Wolf, but I wouldn't be opposed to Krystal
Samurai Goroh
Spyro, but Crash is still good.
Rayman
Bomberman
 

Kamikazek

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
1,246
I'm also not usually fond of villains. But a female villain is long overdue. (And... Are there many noticable Nintendo villain-esses?)
I don't think any of these are actually likely for Smash (Medusa would indeed be the most likely), but just to answer your question-

Mother Brain is probably the biggest name (held back by the nature of her design, obviously)

Pokémon has
Lusamine

Fire Emblem 10 has
Ashera

Captain Syrup (I guess you could debate whether she's a "villain" or just an "antagonist").

Birdo but I don't primarily think of her as a villain at this point.

Maaaaaybe Twinrova?





Theres a lot more but I'm not that I'd consider "noticeable". Drawica, Jambastion Mages, Wendy Koopa, whole bunch of Fire Emblem characters, Veran, ect...

Not really sure what counts as spoilers 'round here so I'm being super liberal with spoiler tags. :sweatdrop:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom