Whenever I hear the 'got my fave but not the right design' I think the Zelda cast are being discussed since they're the ones with vastly different looks.
Twilight Princess was my absolute favorite design for everyone. BotW Link is okay (aside from the fact that he uses the wrong hand... Why can't you let us keep our one left-handed hero?), but I much preferred the TP designs for Zelda and the Dorf. I like the colder queen version of Zelda, and even her BotW incarnation was a bit too flighty (but that awesome royal gown - why didn't she get more chances to wear it?). And the Dorf needs a beard. But then again, the best he has is Hyrule Warriors and that luxurious mane.
I would 100% be okay with DLC costume packs for this reason.
—-
And this thread moves entirely too fast now. I wanted to jump back and answer this one I missed overnight:
Despite my sig listing like 20 characters, I really only feel like 3 more are needed to make the roster feel "complete"
- Bandana Dee: Would complete the kirby representatives with one of the most iconic characters in the franchise
- Paper Mario: A popular Nintendo franchise with it's own identity that really deserves to be represented with a character
- Xenoblade rep: Elma or Rex/Pyra are fine, but Xenoblade is obviously an important IP to nintendo at this point, and def needs a 2nd character
What 3 characters would make the roster feel like this to others?
He’s not my #1, but Tails missing is a huge hole in the roster for me. Sonic’s a very important series in Nintendo history as a rival franchise - no other mascot had the visibility of the Sonic/Mario rivalry, so more reps from Sonic are not overkill. Tails has always been Sonic’s number 2, so putting in their answer to Luigi is a needed move now. Plus the fact that EGM made that hoax back in 2002, so there’s a lot of history behind it, which would be really cool to see realized.
My #1 isn’t so much needed to make the roster feel complete, but instead to push it to new yet fitting places. Skyrim’s a huge game un terms of sales, made a perfect in Famitsu, and would represent the open-world Western RPGs that Bethesda is known for. There are numerous JRPGs represented so far, but the only Western one is...BotW Link? Sort of? Not to mention that the US gaming market is huge, and no discussion of gaming history can be had without considering American games as well.
My third roster addition would just be a representative from Zelda since the series is not at all well represented in terms of characters. Zelda right now is the anti Fire Emblem: too many clones, but nowhere near enough characters based on the series importance. I’d prefer Urbosa or Midna, but Skull Kid would be cool as well. Just gove us something unique.
So I’d add:
- Tails
- Dovahkiin
- Someone from Zelda (Urbosa/Midna/Skull Kid)