-So you are all mini Sakurais? I'm guessing you didn't have Villager or Wii Fit Trainer either. So you guys would have had only 2 out of 5. That's sad. I got 4/5 on a roster almost 3x smaller.
The Villager was in the original chart. If he was not, Sakurai's face would be hovering over his icon.
The entire point of this topic is to have a list of characters that have a good chance in Smash, everyone voted on who got in and who didn't get in. We even had other times when we asked if the anybody thought some characters should be added / removed. This is not one or two people's personal opinions, this is a compilation of what the forum thinks (or at least everyone who participated).
-You have such a narrow view on character inclusions. I am... disappointed.
So you're saying
everyone has a narrow-minded view on character inclusions?
Also, characters that are deconfirmed by the means of being Stage Hazards, Assist Trophies, and whatnot stay so we can see how everything worked out in the end by seeing who we got right and wrong AND who actually did make into the game in some way.
-If you think every character on the giant roster is more likely than Midna, you're narrow-mindedness is showing again. She is either the 2nd or 3rd most requested Zelda newcomer (always after Ghirahim, sometimes after Toon Zelda/Tetra), and is arguably the most unique.
This is
your personal opinion. One person will not change whether a character is added or not, if you want Midna in the chart say
WHY she has a better chance than other Zelda candidates. Not in comparison to other characters in other franchises. The general consensus was that she what we figured was necessary.
-Toon Sheik must mean Tetra, how could it not? You realize you are saying one popular one-time character is impossible, yet one zero-time character that is only a cloned version of a different one-time character is completely viable and among the most likely based off an assumption pertaining to a deleted file in Brawl. The fact that she would 100% definitely be a clone, should be enough to convince you guys, not happening. Who is pulling for Toon Sheik. The possible Zelda characters include: Link, Zelda, Sheik, Ganondorf, Toon Link, Impa, Ghirahim, Midna, Ganon, Yuga, Ravio, Hilda, Groose, Happy Mask Salesman, Zant, Fi, Toon Ganondorf, Toon Zelda, Tetra, Vaati, Tingle... and I can't currently think of any more. I used to consider Skull Kid, Twinrova, and Phantom Zelda, but they're deconfirmed.
If she was going to be Tetra, it would have said "tetra". Plain and simple.
The character was considered for a previous Smash game, so that is why Toon Sheik is on the chart..
-The assumption Rosalina would be a clone was also extremely narrow-minded. It appears that narrow-minded thoughts are common here.
That does not pertain to this topic. You can send your insults elsewhere.
-Don't blame me either. That was my first post on this thread, so I had no contribution to that silly decision.
I said:
I don't make the decisions, you guys did.
I didn't
blame you, I just told you to not blame me.
-You guys don't need me here to tell you the concept of Toon Sheik as her own slot is absolutely ridiculous.
If we had one icon for every character possibility there is (so for example Toon Zelda [Alone], Toon Zelda w/Tetra, Toon Zelda w/Toon Sheik, Tetra alone, etc.) we had so many icons it's not worth it.
Do you see how Zelda and Sheik have separate icons? And the Pokémon Trainer and his Pokémon have separate ones too? Samus and Zero Suit Samus have separate icons too right? Nobody is saying Toon Sheik will get in on her own, she just has her own icon because she could be a part of Toon Zelda.
-That seems to be very trivial on a character possibilities list.
...? Do you mean the alternate versions of characters?
Trivial? A female Villager would be a
playable character wouldn't it? If we were to add more characters, the amount of character slots would grow. Nobody is replacing anyone, if a character isn't on there that character was not considered fit. That's all.
-I'm simply suggesting you put those slots to better use, and I'm also suggesting Tiki, if nobody else has. And I'm suggesting adding Midna back, guys, I know she's not that popular on this one site (getting 3rd for Zelda newcomers on ShortieCanBrawl's poll), but she gets 2nd everywhere else (or so I've seen, this includes Miiverse, Youtube, GameFaqs, and Facebook)
Slots are put to good use, as I said before if a character was voted to be added on, they would be added on. It's really that simple.
-Tiki has been playable more than Marth, Ike, Anna, Chrom, Lucina, etc. And how could a manakete not be unique?
Unique =/= Suggested.
Nobody brought up Tiki, which is why she was never considered for the chart.
Look, if this is just supposed to be collective opinions, I'm going to add mine to the mix. I'll make my own list per series.
That's fine, all power to you. But characters will only be added to the main charts if more people agree with you than disagree with you.