Skies of Arcadia Mafia - Game Over! Indy (AM) Wins!

[Aggressive Mediation]

Except, I've never said as much. You are not a scummy player - you are null to me.

How long does it take for you to start getting suspicious of those null reads?

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

For the record, I haven't even started my read yet. Might do that after I finish Pulp Fiction before I have to return it later tonight. Or I'll start my read then treat myself to the movie, then finish when I return it, either or.

 

[Aggressive Mediation]

Nevermind - Gorf's the play.

He's the only one who doesn't have a legitimate counter-argument to accusations and I don't think anybody has a better read on him than null.

Unvote Vote Gorf

I don't see how the reads of others should influence your own vote.

 

[Rockin]

Oh wait I'm voteblocked.

AND I GOT ROLEBLOCKED.

AND THIS ISN'T SHADY HOW?

Hahahaha, that be some ****ty luck, matey!

From a town's prespective though, I can see the reason as light as day! It'd be the same reason as that land lover, Red Ryu being affected (as I remember him voteblocked in a semi recent Mafia game for good 'measure'). Don't let the problems get ya salty, matey.

rockin which reads of ams matched with yours? offhand they disliked soup (someone you have as town) and liked lego (someone you had as scum). im not following you at all

In D1, I had soup null, but was willing to lynch him if given a proper reason for it. Sadly that never came to be (more reasoning, I mean)

Here is why we suspect Soup:

In his very first post of the game, he immediately throws a bead on Gheb, saying that Gheb is dangerous and needs to be watched. His very next post, he immediately throws his support in something Gheb says. Hell, this entire game, he's been right on Gheb's ****, throwing his support at Gheb and even saying that he was glad he and Gheb can be friends. What happened to Gheb being dangerous? Where's the argument, the attempt to flesh out the read, the follow-up on that statement, anything that suggests that he sincerely thought Gheb was dangerous, that Gheb was a threat? He threw that statement out there and immediately contradicted it with what he did. He does it again to a lesser extent with Rake as well.

The Orbo wagon itself is something I just don't like (save for marshy). The reason it started was such bogus. Soup just floated a vote out there on nothing. He says Orbo needs to have more meat to his posts but it's a catch-up post in the first place and Orbo gave his stances on things. It's not like it was void of content. That's been the entire basis of his case and yet, Orbo's given his thoughts, he's given his stances, that's about all you can expect. He then says it's all faked (irony over him getting butthurt at us calling him fake?) and that it's just rushed. It doesn't take into context that Orbo's newer, Orbo's bad, and that's about all you can expect from Orbo. Ergo, it feels like a lynch lacking suspicion and a lynch for the sake of a lynch.

And then he gets defensive over a weightless jab by Rockin. That's just shady. It's ****in' Rockin, you wouldn't get lynched over something like that. His explanation was something along the lines of it didn't mean anything and he didn't explain it, but you wouldn't flip out over something like that as town.

Paragraph 1 it was more of me 'convinced' with the case on soup then anything.

Paragraph 2 is more of the mindset of ours matching. I really didn't like how that Orbo wagon piled up despite content with him being lynched.

And I'm willing to go with that.

I rather we don't go an Orbo lynch, mainly because I feel we wouldn't learn much of anything for the next day to talk about. But if it comes down to it, then fine. JTB is in the same catagory as far as I'm concerned.

Willing to go with a Legolas a bit more. Gorf as well. Ragnarock is....eh. 50/50. I would probably lynch him.

Here I explained who I didn't mind lynched. Note I was cool with soup being lynched, but I wasn't as strong about it as both Legolas and Gorf lynched.

Soup is town at this point.

AM, we're not sure need to poke at him more for info. Read changed based on this reveal a bit and their activity but still we want to get more info. We might be down for letting them live longer and take Gorf/Gheb first.

How is Soup town?

Granted, I said he was 'anxious town,' but I said that just for behavior and not for his alignment, to which I still find null atm.

Rockin, tthoughts on Gorf/Gheb/JTB.

Gorf is a member that likes to contradict and seems a bit reachy on some of his 'cases.' I wouldn't mind him lynched.

Gheb is....eh. I have him as null. Nothing really sticks out for him that tells me he's town, and that's kinda odd considering I'm used to him contributing heavily. *rubs chin*

JTB....he's a blank state. I havn't seen him interacting, so I won't miss him if he was lynched.

Man someone's looking antsy

Besides... Who aside from J has an argument against me? People say I haven't been doing shiz... But then you have people like JTB or Orbo. Sure you can say that you expect more from me but the point still stands that IT'S NOT SCUMMY.

Neither is it helpful.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Ruy, why are you so stuck on the fact that Gheb suggested a policy lynch for you? I'm pretty sure Legolas did the exact same thing at the beginning of the game (if he didn't, he probably was going to suggest it had you fully disregarded what he said) and yet you're stuck on Gheb. What's the difference between these two slots?

Lego wanted a condition to read our slot, John posting D1, that is reasonable and could be used for a read in one way or another.

Gheb wants us dead because I'm in this Hydra.

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

lego wanted a condition to read our slot, john posting d1, that is reasonable and could be used for a read in one way or another.

Gheb wants us dead because i'm in this hydra.

^ .

 

[Marshmellowman]

yo who are my townbros in this game?

i remember liking lak/j/soupadoupa

wanted to be bros with bronar/dancer and they would say mad obama inspirational **** like "FOLLOW ME AND WELL GET A GOOD D1 LYNCH" then disappeared. come back to my life

jtb was useless as he is wont to be. jtb you said soup was your strongest townread. what are your other reads?

gorf/mediation can go. pretty sure i want one of im today. gheb is meh and ill get to his post soon. gotta talk to macman

kevin if i gave you a gun who would you shoot?

HEY has anyone heard the song "the potion" by ludacris? **** is ill

 

[Marshmellowman]

HEY has anyone heard the song "the potion" by ludacris? **** is ill

werd who has heard this song lol

 

[Marshmellowman]

lak/j/soupadoupa

down to hardbody quicklynch townbro wagon anyone this combination of players wants. this game is boring and everyone takes forever to catch up so im down to just steamroll everyone these guys want til i die probably

 

[JTB]

Rockin, you down with keeping me a blank slate this game? I don't see you trying to remedy that

Ill get to you later marshy

Raziek should prod kevinm so he answers my questions

 

[Raziek]

Rolling out prods shortly.

 

[Raziek]

Hilariously enough, nobody is within the time-frame to be prodded yet. Everyone has posted, and the flip was just about 48 hours ago.

Orbo announced V/LA, he's really the only one actually eligible. If he doesn't post within 24 hours I'll prod him.

 

[Marshmellowman]

vote gorf

lets just kill him and call it a day. btw when he flips scum dont you all go clearing gheb like he doesnt bus his buddies. dont want that boondock saints bull**** where me/gheb lynched his buddy then proceeded to nightkill my *** and everyone was like "wow gheb is so town did you see how he lynched that scumbag derpherp". rockin please just kill yourself (in-game)

 

[KevinM]

I would shoot Rockin.. then reload and shoot Orbo

then reload and shoot LAK,

CLICK CLICK BOOM

 

[Marshmellowman]

yo gorf vote yourself again dont unvote this time tho

kevin who do you wanna lynch d3 after gorf goes

gorf dead yet

why is gorf alive

why are we in dayphase

 

[Marshmellowman]

anyone heard the song "the potion" by ludacris? **** is ill

i would really like to know

 

[JTB]

yo marsh, thats one of my favorite songs, no joke

 

[JTB]

Kevmo, why aren't you shooting AM? Something he say make you change your read on him?

 

[JTB]

btw im still posting later tonight, getting my anime fix on atm

first time i listened to that song marshy, it was amazing, but everytime after, it just didn't have the same effect as the first

 

[JTB]

vote: rockin
vote: AM
vote: rockin

no problems seeing either of these slots go. rockin is just commentating on stuff and giving his support for lynches without looking for scum at all. As for AM, I didn't like his push on Soup at all D1 and it felt like he was solely trying to discredit him rather than push him as scum. None of his posts toDay have improved my read on him either, so he's my second choice after Rockin.

I would still be down to go with Orbo, but I'll wait to see what he brings to the table once hes off V/LA.

KevinM, what is your read on Marshy? I really want to know this and in some amount of detail as well. Also, my previous questions still stand.

Soup and MMM are my town bros and I don't mind lending them my vote, but I think Rockin should die toDay.

 

[#HBC | ѕoup]

This game is going to bore me to death, Orbo is on V/LA for the worst ****ing reasons and AM isn't doing **** to progress anything I have on him.

I might sheep Marshmellowman on Gorf.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Yes, a role that hinders the town's main vehicle of removing scum is a completely beneficial to town.

Voteblocker only makes sense as a town-role though. MAYBE as indy but that wouldn't work with any indy wincon I could possibly think of right now. It's no coincidence that so far the only known instance of a mafia voteblocker only happened because a town voteblocker was recruited onto their side.

And regarding your Gorf comment, I don't need the reads of others to realize that he's the play toDay. It just surprises me that I can't remember a single player that has voiced some pro-town sentiments behind his actions and yet the Gorf wagon still consists of only marshy and myself. Where are all the other players that used to preach how scummy he was yesterDay now?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Rockin what gives you the impression I'm not contributing? Disregarding the fact that you're using faulty meta here I don't see how your reasoning applies at all =/

JTB, your #660 is bad. Read the game, plz.

 

[JTB]

I have read the game and I'm dead serious about Rockin. His last post is a prime example of it:

>I'll lynch Soup if given proper reason
>Called Soup anxious town for reaction, null read
>Gheb posting alot, null
>Gorf is contridicating himself, don't mind him lynched
>JTB is blank slate, wouldn't mind him lynched

 

[JTB]

Rockin, who do YOU want to push as scum? Not who everyone else is pushing, what exactly are your scum reads?

How did you get a null read from calling Soup an anxious townie? What sort of reactions were you expecting?

Why did you vote Nabe when you had rather lynched someone else? There was plenty of time before the deadline to sway the wagon, but you chose to just hop on.

 

[Marshmellowman]

what was bad about 660 gheb? hating on rockin/am alone makes that a good post

jtb is a TERRIBLE play. kevin please answer his question regarding my alignment

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Hahahaha, that be some ****ty luck, matey!

From a town's prespective though, I can see the reason as light as day! It'd be the same reason as that land lover, Red Ryu being affected (as I remember him voteblocked in a semi recent Mafia game for good 'measure'). Don't let the problems get ya salty, matey.



In D1, I had soup null, but was willing to lynch him if given a proper reason for it. Sadly that never came to be (more reasoning, I mean)



Paragraph 1 it was more of me 'convinced' with the case on soup then anything.

Paragraph 2 is more of the mindset of ours matching. I really didn't like how that Orbo wagon piled up despite content with him being lynched.





Here I explained who I didn't mind lynched. Note I was cool with soup being lynched, but I wasn't as strong about it as both Legolas and Gorf lynched.



How is Soup town?

Granted, I said he was 'anxious town,' but I said that just for behavior and not for his alignment, to which I still find null atm.



Gorf is a member that likes to contradict and seems a bit reachy on some of his 'cases.' I wouldn't mind him lynched.

Gheb is....eh. I have him as null. Nothing really sticks out for him that tells me he's town, and that's kinda odd considering I'm used to him contributing heavily. *rubs chin*

JTB....he's a blank state. I havn't seen him interacting, so I won't miss him if he was lynched.



Neither is it helpful.

You're a VEGETABLE

Spoiler

and not the good kind more like the smelly, scummy kind.

Seriously, what the fuhh have you been doing all game? Where the fuhh are you going at this point? I'm a member that likes to contradict? I'd love to see what info I've given that contradicts. Reaching on my cases? Like the Orbo one? Doubtful. You're not even playing this game.

Vote: Rockin

So... What's your direction?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

vote gorf

lets just kill him and call it a day.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

yo gorf vote yourself again dont unvote this time tho

kevin who do you wanna lynch d3 after gorf goes

gorf dead yet

why is gorf alive

why are we in dayphase

Vote: Gorf I'm digging dat direction.








































































































































No I'm not Unvote Vote: Rockin

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

vote: rockin
vote: AM
vote: rockin

no problems seeing either of these slots go. rockin is just commentating on stuff and giving his support for lynches without looking for scum at all. As for AM, I didn't like his push on Soup at all D1 and it felt like he was solely trying to discredit him rather than push him as scum. None of his posts toDay have improved my read on him either, so he's my second choice after Rockin.

I would still be down to go with Orbo, but I'll wait to see what he brings to the table once hes off V/LA.

KevinM, what is your read on Marshy? I really want to know this and in some amount of detail as well. Also, my previous questions still stand.

Soup and MMM are my town bros and I don't mind lending them my vote, but I think Rockin should die toDay.

 

[Marshmellowman]

i see that scumve decided to bus this dayphase

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Considering how much flak AM has gotten toDay I feel like JTB's case on him is lackluster. Hating on Rockin is justified but also pretty damn generic.

 

[Marshmellowman]

i see that scumve decided to bus this dayphase

we agree on too much ****

shoulda just joined separately an acted as each others double vote

 

[Lovably Adorable Kanine]

Vote: Gorf

Choo-Choo.

All aboard.

 

[KevinM]

Fine down with Gorf going.

Vote Gorf

Basically my stance on MarshMac hydra is town until I feel otherwise. For now some of their reads are lining up with mine but I'm getting more and more worried about their play as some of the blatantly scummy things I feel like Marshy would attack are being allowed to slip under the radar (not going to point these out specifically in case I need them for later). So town leaning null with a need to reevaluate after this gorf lynch would be my guess.

 

[JTB]

request votecount

 

[Marshmellowman]

he is -3 jtb

kevin doesnt see that im town. i wonder if this game confuses him

 

[JTB]

It's not so much the amount of votes he has, but who is voting him. KevinM being on the wagon makes me dislike it greatly since he's pretty much in the same boat as Rockin for me, albeit giving a little more content. No doubt that Rockin will join the wagon at some point today and Orbo will just sheep everyone because "he wants to get more information out of the slot" and he will be given a pass since everyone holds him to low standards.

 

[JTB]

I could've sworn I asked more questions to KevinM earlier toDay, but I can't find my post.

Why were you voting AM earlier in the Day? You said he had some explaining to do, what exactly did he need to explain? If it was regards to the RB, what kind of answer did you expect to get that isn't null?

Why don't you mention AM in your 654? You have your vote on him, is there something he said in the past few pages that made you change your mind on him? Why is Gorf more deserving of your vote right now?

 

[JTB]

ebwop: you had*