Time for my .02.
Look at SPOC back when Scar ran it. Monthly. Philadelphia. Those without cars were near to one of the biggest railroad hubs on the east coast. PA, 3 hours from NY. Close enough, but far enough. Happened once a month, if that. Drew in a different crowd, you got more South Jersey support, along with the NY regulars.
Now, lets look at both No Johns and Saffron. Both appealing to basically the same group. Jersey City technically should appeal to NYC more than Nanuet, and Nanuet (as we've seen) draws in that mid-upstate crowd. Both events are within roughly an hour of another, an area shared by DIP as well now.
*puts on glasses and makes educated face*
So, I think the main gripe as OTG said is you have an overpopulation of tournaments within the same demographic area. This can be alleviated, however, the means of doing so are quite difficult. You have the same top players who will be attending both, the issue with ALL tournaments now is getting the influx of new blood into the scene. This...doesn't help. Going 0-2 is not fun for anyone. The "pot fillers" generally are the ones who are mostly likely to drive, while those most likely to take the pot are usually driven. I think what Waffles is doing on the WC with an "Amateur Bracket" is definitely a strong idea. I'd even say that we could step it up a bit, have a coach behind each player in the amateur tournament. Ex. A up and coming Falcon player would have Hax, while HBK is whispering advice and encouragement to a Marth player, etc. It's just an idea, but come on, everyone appreciates the advice, and it may be what gets those fringe players to join more regularly.
I know that my tournament was mentioned, and I'll definitely give my reasons for wanting to run it:
1. Long Island has a scene that is largely untapped. There was a tournament at the same venue a few months back, 30 players, none of the regulars (shoutout to Ryan K and Niko for making it through).
2. To get around on Long Island...you have to drive. You get more of those players in the scene, you get more drivers that can take NYC to events. As one of the "designated drivers" I'll have about 8-9 people asking me per tournament, and I can't take them all. This has increased with G$ being on the shelf as of late.
3. Location wise, it isn't the most ideal place. The only way to get out here is car or LIRR. I'm definitely reaching out to the Long Island demographic, to get interested in a "dead" game in a "dead area" going again, however, NYC can make it, Jersey can drive, etc. It's just a manner of effort they want to make.
I think I'll speak for a lot of the "fringe" players when my own personal gripe as a player, for me, its definitely the travel. I hate the amount of tolls, the gas money I have to pay to get anywhere. I'm not a money player, I don't go to a tournament expecting to get my money reimbursed through tournament placing. I feel bad for players that go 0-2 and can't get a TV for friendlies, or for players who, like I once was, didn't want to enter because they're testing the waters and don't get a chance to play people they've only seen on youtube.
Probably won't edit this, but may add another post later.