Roster Discussion Thread (Closed)

[FalKoopa]

Why except for Dixie Kong?

Dixie Kong isn't human. (Don't tell me you were seriously asking that.)

 

[N3ON]

Everything else you said I understand where you are coming from and could see, although it would depend.

The Reyn only attacks people though relates to a lot of ATs (ones from Brawl and what can potentially happen in SSB4). There will obviously be ATs like that. He would basically be another Lyn, except not as fast but packing power attacks.

Not saying it would be him, but I think it could be.

Lyn doesn't just show up and start attacking, she does have a unique attack method. You're looking more for characters like Goroh, Saki, and Little Mac.

If you do imagine him attacking like Lyn though... that wouldn't make a whole lot of sense. Reyn doesn't really have Lyn's fighting style, he's not known for speed, critical hits, or really anything to do with how Lyn fights. Why would Sakurai pick Reyn, of all characters at his disposal, to work like Lyn, or just to be an AT in general? He doesn't really have popularity, he doesn't really fit Lyn's effect, even if it's slower (plus it would still copy her gimmick), and overall, he doesn't really have much unique-ness he could offer in an AT.

This sounds like another case of DSN bias to me.

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

so what hapends if your a girl and like male characters?

on tropic questions: for zelda reps, who has a biger chance, tingle or graham?

Ghirahim, like FalchionX7 said

 

[Shorts]

Why except for Dixie Kong?

Because Palutena and Dixie are ChronoBound's ladies. So, of COURSE their fans are legit. That whole shpeel was a rip on him, if you couldn't tell.

 

[Moon Monkey]

It is only racist if a black person feels embarrassed that a non-black person notices something peculiar and points it out.

Well if that's the case than nothing is racists if I am that black person.

 

[N3ON]

so what hapends if your a girl and like male characters?

Doesn't count. Chivalry, remember?

on tropic questions: for zelda reps, who has a biger chance, tingle or graham?

Totally Graham. Then Tingle. Then Ghirahim.

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Lyn doesn't just show up and start attacking, she does have a unique attack method. You're looking more for characters like Goroh, Saki, and Little Mac.

If you do imagine him attacking like Lyn though... that wouldn't make a whole lot of sense. Reyn doesn't really have Lyn's fighting style, he's not known for speed, critical hits, or really anything to do with how Lyn fights. Why would Sakurai pick Reyn, of all characters at his disposal, to work like Lyn, or just to be an AT in general? He doesn't really have popularity, he doesn't really fit Lyn's effect, even if it's slower (plus it would still copy her gimmick), and overall, he doesn't really have much unique-ness he could offer in an AT.

This sounds like another case of DSN bias to me.

I meant more of just an attacking AT, and Lyn was the only one that cam to mind. Reyn might not be the one picked, but he could be. Just like Riki, Sharla, Dunban, etc.

But yes, we do get together so well, don't we?

 

[FalKoopa]

Ghirahim, like FalchionX7 said

It's obviously Impa > Tingle > Vaati > Ghirahim.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Because Palutena and Dixie are ChronoBound's ladies. So, of COURSE their fans are legit. That whole shpeel was a rip on him, if you couldn't tell.

Oh, I thought you were just saying there wasn't anyone that wasn't attracted to Dixie Kong and what's in her non pants

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

It's obviously Impa > Tingle > Vaati > Ghirahim.

More like Ghirahim > Impa > Tingle > Vaati

 

[BKupa666]

Hey guys, I have a quick question for you all that I'll explain my rationale behind in a little conspiracy theory I'm about to post, entirely non-April Fool's related: how often, over the past week, did you visit my K. Rool support thread, if at all?

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Well, now that Little Mac is more popular than K. Rool, I figure he lost his chance at Smash

 

[Vintage Creep]

Around 60 times a day, why?

 

[N3ON]

I meant more of just an attacking AT, and Lyn was the only one that cam to mind. Reyn might not be the one picked, but he could be. Just like Riki, Sharla, Dunban, etc.

But yes, we do get together so well, don't we?

Ah, so once again it's: "this is what will happen" ... "this probably will happen" ... "this could happen" ... to "I want this to happen" (that's what you say next )

And yes, we have such similar mindsets, your arguments are always so thought-provoking, and just an overall pleasure. How I cherish them.

Spoiler

APRIL FOOLS.

 

[FalKoopa]

More like Ghirahim > Impa > Tingle > Vaati

Hardly. Don't use the pointless recency argument. Link's games have hardly affected the roster, Ghirahim won't be in at least before Impa.

EDIT: I'm serious. It's 12:45 am on 2nd April in my time zone.

Hey guys, I have a quick question for you all that I'll explain my rationale behind in a little conspiracy theory I'm about to post, entirely non-April Fool's related: how often, over the past week, did you visit my K. Rool support thread, if at all?

I take credit for bumping it.

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Ah, so once again it's: "this is what will happen" ... "this probably will happen" ... "this could happen" ... to "I want this to happen" (that's what you say next )

And yes, we have such similar mindsets, your arguments are always so thought-provoking, and just an overall pleasure. How I cherish them.

Spoiler

APRIL FOOLS.

Oh you know you would miss me if I left

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Hardly. Don't use the pointless recency argument. Link's games have hardly affected the roster, Ghirahim won't be in at least before Impa.

He would get in before Vaati and Tingle

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

He would get in before Vaati and Tingle

How many games have Tingle and Vaati been in compared to Ghirahim?

And yet, Ghirahim is somehow more important to Zelda and Nintendo than those two?

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

How many games have Tingle and Vaati been in compared to Ghirahim?

And yet, Ghirahim is somehow more important to Zelda and Nintendo than those two?

Importance? Debatable

Popularity is pretty big among all 3 though

Who is to say Tingle or Vaati get chosen? Who is to say it would be any of those 4?

 

[Oasis_S]

Hey guys, I have a quick question for you all that I'll explain my rationale behind in a little conspiracy theory I'm about to post, entirely non-April Fool's related: how often, over the past week, did you visit my K. Rool support thread, if at all?

16 times.

Once today.
Twice Friday.
Once Thursday.
Five times on Wednesday.
Seven times on Tuesday.

Thank you browser history.

 

[FalKoopa]

He would get in before Vaati and Tingle

If he makes another appearance, I can see him getting in before Vaati.

Tingle is overall more important to Zelda than Ghirahim.

He has been in:
Majora's Mask
Wind Waker
Oracle of Seasons
Oracle of Ages
Tingle's Rosy RupeeLand
Tingle's Love Balloon Flight (or something like that)
Skyward Sword (Cameo)

He is Link's Yoshi.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

I was wondering why I've always had a desire to ride on his back when playing zelda

 

[Deleted member]

How many games have Tingle and Vaati been in compared to Ghirahim?

And yet, Ghirahim is somehow more important to Zelda and Nintendo than those two?

Quality of appearance over quantity my friend.

The reason why Ghirahim stands out above other one-shots is because of his highly important role in Skyward Sword. His game sets in chain in motion of all Zelda games to come. Without Ghirahim, events like Ocarina of Time and Twilight Princess would not exist.

He's not likely to get in Smash, but I'd say he's pretty important to the franchise.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Quality of appearance over quantity my friend.

The reason why Ghirahim stands out above other one-shots is because of his highly important role in Skyward Sword. His game sets in chain in motion of all Zelda games to come. Without Ghirahim, events like Ocarina of Time and Twilight Princess would not exist.

He's not likely to get in Smash, but I'd say he's pretty important to the franchise.

They were just as believably existing before Skyward Sword was ever made

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

I still say it is between Ghirahim and Impa

 

[FalKoopa]

He's not likely to get in Smash, but I'd say he's pretty important to the franchise.

Canonically, yes. But Smash has rich legacy of stomping canon into the ground.

I still say it is between Ghirahim and Impa

I see you have run out of valid arguments.

 

[The Black mage]

I still have yet to wonder what exact info Sakurai will put up soon.

Oh, and that monterny jack tasted SO AWSOME!

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Canonically, yes. But Smash has rich legacy of stomping canon into the ground.



I see you have run out of valid arguments.

Not really, but the Skyward Sword one still stands

 

[Deleted member]

They were just as believably existing before Skyward Sword was ever made

Miyamoto said that this would be one of the earliest games in the chronology and should explain why events in later games occurs (Ocarina of Time specifically IIRC). Skyward Sword's existence was necessary in order for the events of later Zelda games to occur.

 

[N3ON]

Hey guys, I have a quick question for you all that I'll explain my rationale behind in a little conspiracy theory I'm about to post, entirely non-April Fool's related: how often, over the past week, did you visit my K. Rool support thread, if at all?

About ten times I'd say. Too scared to go view this computer's history.

Not really, but the Skyward Sword one still stands

It works about as well as the Twilight Princess one did for Midna. At least those (TP and Brawl) were both on the same system, and only originally planned to be a year apart.

Oh you know you would miss me if I left

Spoiler

I mean, yeah, sure, of course.

 

[Oasis_S]

By now you'd think Micaiah would be his choice for a Zelda rep.

 

[FalKoopa]

Miyamoto said that this would be one of the earliest games in the chronology and should explain why events in later games occurs (Ocarina of Time specifically IIRC). Skyward Sword's existence was necessary in order for the events of later Zelda games to occur.

Neither Tingle nor Vaati are in that game, so Ghirahim definitely isn't necessary.

 

[The Black mage]

Well, the Master sword was first created out of the Goddess sword in the events of Skyward sword, do the math

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Spoiler

I mean, yeah, sure, of course.

You know we have fun going back and forth

By now you'd think Micaiah would be his choice for a Zelda rep.

Except Micaiah is not a Zelda character

 

[The Black mage]

It would have sounded nice, but no.

 

[Deleted member]

Neither Tingle nor Vaati are in that game, so Ghirahim definitely isn't necessary.

Not sure if serious or not.

But if so, I was referring to games like Ocarina of Time. Ganondorf would not exist without Demise, who is the reincarnation of Demise.

 

[lobotheduck21]

Tingles got his own series,

"insert pic of of stan lee that says 'nuff said

 

[DragonSniperNintendo]

Neither Tingle nor Vaati are in that game, so Ghirahim definitely isn't necessary.

None of them are, including Impa

 

[Shorts]

It's pretty much:

Tingle.

 

[Oasis_S]

Yeah, but they're similar magic-wielding females. May as well cut Zelda in favor of Micaiah.