Roster Discussion Thread (Closed)

[~ Valkyrie ~]

Etemon would be broken in Rumble Arena. Because he's the Strongest, am I right?

... Right?

Pico doesn't really strike me as stealthy, but hey, he's a turtle? Goroh again made me think of Ike's and Takamaru's playstyles getting a lovechild.

 

[Oasis_S]

It has been way too long since I watched this video.

Also yeah, how dare Chrono just tack on Snake's moveset without giving Pico his chance to shine himself. IS THAT WHAT YOU CALL LOVE, CHRONO? I wanna see him, like, spin around on his back while shooting laser beams. Wouldn't that be so cool.


Oh yeah, and SHORTS, I'll have you know I was eating chocolate chip and cookie dough ice cream while you said what you did. Jerk. I think it's good for my bowels.

 

[~ Valkyrie ~]

It has been way too long since I watched this video.

Also yeah, how dare Chrono just tack on Snake's moveset without giving Pico his chance to shine himself. IS THAT WHAT YOU CALL LOVE, CHRONO? I wanna see him, like, spin around on his back while shooting laser beams. Wouldn't that be so cool.

Now that's a splendid idea good yes very good

(Speaking of ice creams I bought something like that too but it had chocolate brownies in it, Ben & Jerry's Half-Baked, perhaps?

I got a very nasty blister from a burn that day.)

 

[Metal Overlord]

@above video: "All y'all are a bunch of *******es!" "Ridley is TOO BIG. I don't see why y'all don't get that..."
I really hate to sound racist, but n***a please. I couldn't watch the rest of that video. I feared it might set me off too much to the point that I would do something about it....

Lol nah you good, it's not like there's any racist meaning behind it. It's meant to be a joke, only people who would take offense are people who still have that racist chip on their shoulders

 

[dezeray112]

I wonder, what characters would make it in as DLC?

Hmm, I'd wait and see what the final SSB4 character roster is like, then decide on which characters I would like to see as DLC.

 

[Metal Overlord]

If any characters make it in as DLC, they'll most likely or at least should be only made DLC because the devs coouldn't finish them in time for launch

Doubt we'll get that many, either. Maybe 2 or 3

 

[Diddy Kong]

Not really. I will say that Golden Sun is probably one of the most straight forward RPG's out there. Mind you that doesn't mean it's a bad thing, it's still a perfectly good RPG in it's own right, but it doesn't really feel inspiring. It feels like the same song and dance other role playing games have done before, which to me is a disappointment in it's own right. I like it when role playing games play around with RPG fluff, like Mother, Tales, Xenoblade, and the Mario RPG's.

Psynergy as a concept has never been used in another RPG
Djinni and Summons like in Golden Sun have never been used in another RPG
And overall it's just a very solid RPG all around

After Pokemon and Fire Emblem, surely one of the best Nintendo-owned RPGs around.

Well, whatever the case is, I'm sticking to these FE reps (hoping that they'll be 4) for my roster for now: Chromikins, Martha Marthi-pan, Ikey-poo, and Roi

Fixed.

http://shaym.in/fe1/chapter1.html

 

[Arcadenik]

I think that "Psynergy" is just a fancy way of saying "Magic". Psynergy functions the same as battle magic and field magic in other RPG games.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Maybe it's just me, but I never seen a RPG with 'field magic' like Psynergy in Golden Sun...

 

[Oasis_S]

I prefer Chromcakes and Royboy, personally.

Ridley is Riddles by the way.

 

[Frostwraith]

Lol at those nicknames... reminds me of Hades calling Pitty Pat (to Pit), Pretty Palutena, Thanny-poo (to Thanatos) and Pittooey (to Dark Pit) in KIU.

I can totally imagine him in KI codecs calling these silly names at other characters.

 

[Deleted member]

You guys are talking about Digimon, but not Etemon and I really don't understand how that's possible.

Also I dunno why it annoys me so much that Chrono thinks Pico could be a Snake clone, but he also thinks Goroh could be a Takamaru clone so what can you do.

Ah, that explains the whole "Strongest" deal....

Who was it that killed Etemon? WarGreymon or MetalGarurumon? MetalEtemon I mean... I know it was MetalGreymon who took down Etemon during that Pyramid deal. That was one of my favorite arcs in S1. 2nd favorite being the beginning of the Dark Masters Arc with MetalSeadramon, Puppetmon, and Machinedramon.

Maybe it's just me, but I never seen a RPG with 'field magic' like Psynergy in Golden Sun...

Illusion of Gaia for the SNES. You need to play more JRPGs son.

I can totally imagine him in KI codecs calling these silly names at other characters.

As Ridley Prime said before, replacing the MGS codecs with the KI conversations would totally cheapen the experience. If you've ever played MGS the codecs are more than just a notorious cliche of the series, it is also how 90% of the story is told, and since MGS2 and its whole 'Meme vs. Gene' deal it's essentially the identity of the series. If Snake goes, the codecs should go with him.


I doubt KI Convo'c could carry the same charm the MGS codecs can. To see what I mean, just give MGS 1, 2 and 3 a run.

 

[Frostwraith]

As Ridley Prime said before, replacing the MGS codecs with the KI conversations would totally cheapen the experience. If you've ever played MGS the codecs are more than just a notorious cliche of the series, it is also how 90% of the story is told, and since MGS2 and its whole 'Meme vs. Gene' deal it's essentially the identity of the series. If Snake goes, the codecs should go with him.


I doubt KI Convo'c could carry the same charm the MGS codecs can. To see what I mean, just give MGS 1, 2 and 3 a run.

Not sure if serious. Have you played KI Uprising?

Besides, Star Fox characters also have secret convos, thus making your argument null and void.

 

[Vintage Creep]

MGS codes, StarFox conversations, Hades/Palutena interventions... I hope they all make it in. They're such good easter eggs.
It would be awesome if the Trainer could do something like this, with Prof. Oak describing the opponents pokédex-style.

 

[Deleted member]

Not sure if serious. Have you played KI Uprising?

Besides, Star Fox characters also have secret convos, thus making your argument null and void.

I haven't actually. I'm not saying KI convos shouldn't be in, they should. But they should not replace the MGS codecs should MGS get cut.

 

[Frostwraith]

MGS codes, StarFox conversations, Hades/Palutena interventions... I hope they all make it in. They're such good easter eggs.
It would be awesome if the Trainer could do something like this, with Prof. Oak describing the opponents pokédex-style.

Your last point wouldn't be a bad idea, but sounds a little odd, though.

Star Fox and MGS had convo Easter Eggs mostly because the games are dialogue-heavy. Same applies to Kid Icarus Uprising, in which Palutena even plays a similar role to the Colonel in MGS, by instructing Pit with missions and such, alongside with humor, which MGS also has.

I haven't actually. I'm not saying KI convos shouldn't be in, they should. But they should not replace the MGS codecs should MGS get cut.

Who's to say they're necessarily replacements? o.O

If Snake is removed, what's stopping Pit (and other eventual KI characters) from having their own convo easter egg?

Also, if the MGS series is removed in SSB4, it's damn obvious that the codecs are removed too. >_>

Besides, Star Fox already had convos since Melee (where Snake was nowhere to be seen), so your arguments are horrible.

 

[Diddy Kong]

 

[FalKoopa]

with Prof. Oak describing the opponents pokédex-style.

Everyone would be described as Fighting type.

 

[Deleted member]

Your last point wouldn't be a bad idea, but sounds a little odd, though.

Star Fox and MGS had convo Easter Eggs mostly because the games are dialogue-heavy. Same applies to Kid Icarus Uprising, in which Palutena even plays a similar role to the Colonel in MGS, by instructing Pit with missions and such, alongside with humor, which MGS also has.



Who's to say they're necessarily replacements? o.O

If Snake is removed, what's stopping Pit (and other eventual KI characters) from having their own convo easter egg?

Also, if the MGS series is removed in SSB4, it's damn obvious that the codecs are removed too. >_>

Besides, Star Fox already had convos since Melee (where Snake was nowhere to be seen), so your arguments are horrible.

Ahh, I was harkening back to a suggestion a couple posts ago about KI convos replacing MGS codecs. I'd much rather the KI convos, if implemented, do something unique rather than fill the gap that Snake left.

Everyone would be described as Fighting type.

I can see Mario, Bowser and Ike get described as Fire types. Ganondorf as a Dark type, and the Ice Climbers as Ice types.

Link and Zelda would be

Spoiler

Light Types

 

[BluePikmin11]

Mr. Game and Watch would be normal type.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Donkey Kong, Ground type. Also probably Fighting.
Diddy Kong, Fighting Type
Kirby, MetaKnight Dedede and Pit: Flying types.
Luigi: Dark Type

 

[FalKoopa]

Mr. Game and Watch would be normal type.

I'll say electric/dark. He is the source of shadow bugs.

 

[BluePikmin11]

Makes sense, but dark types would describe something at night, Game and Watch isn't based on that.

 

[Diddy Kong]

I'm going to my girl's house again. I'll be back after the weekend. See ya all later peeps.

 

[BluePikmin11]

I'm going to my girl's house again. I'll be back after the weekend. See ya all later peeps.

girlfiend for SSB4

 

[Frostwraith]

Smash characters Pokémon types? This is how I think:

Spoiler

Mario: Fire
Luigi: Fire
Peach: Normal
Bowser: Fire
DK: Fighting
Diddy: Fighting
Yoshi: Dragon/Flying
Wario: Poison (dem farts )
Link: Steel/Fighting
Zelda: Fire/Electric
Ganondorf: Dark/Fighting
Toon Link: Steel/Fighting
Samus: Electric/Steel
Zero Suit Samus: Electric/Fighting
Pit: Normal/Flying
Ice Climbers: Ice
R.O.B.: Steel
Kirby: Normal (changes with copy abilities)
Meta Knight: Dark/Flying
King Dedede: Normal
Olimar: Normal
Red Pikmin: Grass/Fire
Blue Pikmin: Grass/Water
Yellow Pikmin: Grass/Electric
Purple Pikmin: Grass/Fighting
White Pikmin: Grass/Poison
Fox: Normal
Falco: Normal/Flying
Wolf: Dark
Captain Falcon: Fire/Fighting
Marth: Steel
Ike: Steel/Fighting
Ness: Psychic
Lucas: Psychic
Mr. Game & Watch: Normal
Snake: Fighting
Sonic: Normal
Dr. Mario: Electric
Roy: Fire (or should I say... PH1R3!)

 

[BluePikmin11]

King Dedede should be flying type.

 

[FalKoopa]

Zelda should be psychic.
ROB should be electric/steel.

 

[Frostwraith]

King Dedede should be flying type.

He doesn't exactly fly, but floats. So, Kirby and Dedede have the Levitate ability.

Zelda should be psychic.
ROB should be electric/steel.

Both make sense.

 

[Deleted member]

I'm going to my girl's house again. I'll be back after the weekend. See ya all later peeps.

Thanks for the information chief...

Smash characters Pokémon types? This is how I think:

Spoiler

Mario: Fire
Luigi: Fire
Peach: Normal
Bowser: Fire
DK: Fighting
Diddy: Fighting
Yoshi: Dragon/Flying
Wario: Poison (dem farts )
Link: Steel/Fighting
Zelda: Fire/Electric
Ganondorf: Dark/Fighting
Toon Link: Steel/Fighting
Samus: Electric/Steel
Zero Suit Samus: Electric/Fighting
Pit: Normal/Flying
Ice Climbers: Ice
R.O.B.: Steel
Kirby: Normal (changes with copy abilities)
Meta Knight: Dark/Flying
King Dedede: Normal
Olimar: Normal
Red Pikmin: Grass/Fire
Blue Pikmin: Grass/Water
Yellow Pikmin: Grass/Electric
Purple Pikmin: Grass/Fighting
White Pikmin: Grass/Poison
Fox: Normal
Falco: Normal/Flying
Wolf: Dark
Captain Falcon: Fire/Fighting
Marth: Steel
Ike: Steel/Fighting
Ness: Psychic
Lucas: Psychic
Mr. Game & Watch: Normal
Snake: Fighting
Sonic: Normal
Dr. Mario: Electric
Roy: Fire (or should I say... PH1R3!)

>Ike
>not fire

He's the Hero of the Blue Flame. He's technically more deserving of that attribute than Roy.

 

[BluePikmin11]

If I relate to Jigglypuff, it makes sense.

 

[Frostwraith]

Thanks for the information chief...



>Ike
>not fire

He's the Hero of the Blue Flame. He's technically more deserving of that attribute than Roy.

Roy uses the Sword of Seals, which is a fire sword.

Ike's sword Ragnell never had fire attributes. Sure he's called the Hero of the Blue Flames, but that is because he was one of the chosen of Yune, who blessed him with her power which manifests itself as blue flames (remember Lehran's Medallion). At the very least, Yune is the Fire-type one.

 

[Deleted member]

Roy uses the Sword of Seals, which is a fire sword.

Ike's sword Ragnell never had fire attributes. Sure he's called the Hero of the Blue Flames, but that is because he was one of the chosen of Yune, who blessed him with her power which manifests itself as blue flames (remember Lehran's Medallion). At the very least, Yune is the Fire-type one.

Well I was referring to the fact that Blue Fire > Red Fire.

Also, what's more fiery? Someone who uses a tool to produce fire? Or someone who is blessed with the power to create flames?

 

[BluePikmin11]

fire is fire, the color doesn't matter.

 

[Deleted member]

fire is fire, the color doesn't matter.

Exactly, Ike is Fire.

/thread

I gotta go to work anyway.

 

[FalKoopa]

fire is fire, the color doesn't matter.

Well, Blue flames are much hotter than Red flames.

 

[BluePikmin11]

I totally knew that.

 

[Frostwraith]

Well I was referring to the fact that Blue Fire > Red Fire.

Also, what's more fiery? Someone who uses a tool to produce fire? Or someone who is blessed with the power to create flames?

By the end of RD, his blessing are gone, though.

And Ike doesn't seem to be blessed in Brawl... where's the blue flame aura? His Eruption attack is just an attack Sakurai intended for Roy, but put it in Ike after ditching the former.

Just saying. The typings are merely assuming Brawl, otherwise, Luigi would have an Electric type attached, since in the M&L RPGs he uses thunder.

 

[BluePikmin11]

By the end of RD, his blessing are gone, though.

And Ike doesn't seem to be blessed in Brawl... where's the blue flame aura? His Eruption attack is just an attack Sakurai intended for Roy, but put it in Ike after ditching the former.

Just saying. The typings are merely assuming Brawl, otherwise, Luigi would have an Electric type attached, since in the M&L RPGs he uses thunder.

What about Ghost Type? (Luigi's Mansion)

 

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

Im gonna overhype and say MEWTHREE

[collapse=Image]

[/collapse]

If a Pokemon like that ever existed, chances are, it might end up succeeding Arceus in the base stat total amount.