Rate the Rosters

[Pupp135]

10
This is probably the roster that I would’ve chosen if I had a series original boss while developing SSB64.

I found this alternate Melee roster online

Veterans:
Newcomers:(Unique)Lip

 

[Butters Stotch]

9.5/10
Normally, I would prioritise Meta Knight over Dedede, but the rest are great choices; Ganondorf has his own moveset, Banjo is in three games early, and Lip is a good retro pick IMO. Jigglypuff is missing, but I never cared for her.

Just curious, where did you find this roster?

Since I did my take on 64, here’s what I’ll do for Melee:
Blood Falcon


Ganondorf is unique. I did consider some cross series clones like Ray, Lip (based on ideas I saw on GameFAQs), and a Wave Race rep, but stuck with safer picks in the end.

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Looks good 9/10

Alternate Brawl roster:
(alternate world, where Nintendo doesn't put 3rd Parties in Games)
Returning roster:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. DK
4. Link
5. Samus/Zero Suit Samus
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Ness
10. Captain Falcon
11. Wario
12. Yoshi
13. Zelda/Sheik
14. Ganondorf
15. Bowser
16. Peach
17. Wolf
18. Mewtwo
19. Black Shadow
20. Marth
21. Ice Climbers
22. Mr. Game and Watch

Newcomers:
23. Pit
24. Mach Rider
25. Meta Knight
26. Krystal
27. Lucario
28. Pokemon Trainer: Charizard, Bayleef and Mudkip
29. Ridley
30. Toon Link
31. K. Rool
32. Ike
33. Lucas
34. Isaac
35. Kamek
36. Diddy Kong & Dixie
37. Olimar
38. ROB
39. Mii Fighter

Hypothetical DLC:
1. Wii Fit Trainer
2. Chibi-Robo
3. Rosalina
4. Captain Syrup

 

[Butters Stotch]

10/10
In addition to realising the Diddy/Dixie duo mechanic, you added a lot of great choices for newcomers, even if I do miss the third parties.

Remember the alternate take on Brawl I did earlier? Well, here's another, except it follows the last two rosters I made

Brawl
Toad

Isaac
Hypothetical DLC:Blood Falcon(Wii Sports/unique)
Similar to how Young Link was replaced with Toon Link, Blood Falcon is replaced with Blaziken.

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Looking nice 10/10

Alternate Universe Smash 4 Roster:
Returning roster:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. DK
4. Link
5. Samus/Zero Suit Samus
6. Kirby
7. Fox
8. Pikachu
9. Ness
10. Captain Falcon
11. Wario
12. Yoshi
13. Zelda/Sheik
14. Ganondorf
15. Bowser
16. Peach
17. Wolf
18. Mewtwo
19. Marth
20. Excitebiker
21. Mr. Game and Watch
22. Pit
23. Mach Rider
24. Meta Knight
25. Krystal
26. Lucario
27. Charizard
29. Ridley
30. Toon Link
31. Ike
32. Lucas
33. Isaac
34. Kamek
35. Diddy Kong
36. Olimar
37. ROB
38. Mii Fighter
39. Wii Fit Trainer
40. Chibi-Robo
41. Rosalina
42. Captain Syrup
43. Roy

Newcomers:
1. Waluigi
2. Bowser Jr.
3. Greninja
4. Robin
5. Lucina
6. Chrom
7. Palutena
8. Medusa
9. Villager
10. Isabelle
11. Little Mac
12. Toad
13. Louie
14. Takamaru
15. Kamek
16. Shulk
17. Duck Hunt

DLC:
1. Corrin
2. Black Shadow
3. Zoroark
4. Marshal (Rythmm Heaven)
5. Viridi
6. K. Rool
7. Sylux

 

[BowserKing]

9/10. Viridi, Zoroark, Louie, Black Shadow and Sylux are fun choices.

Smash 4 Fighters Pass 2 (follows after normal smash bros route)
Lugia, Snake, Wolf, Inkling, King K.Rool, Incineroar and Ray-Man

 

[Butters Stotch]

8/10
I find Lugia a little questionable, but the rest make sense, assuming DLC lasts until late 2016/early 2017 in 's case.

Alternate FP1 with some choices taken from the supposed list leak:

• Captain Toad (replaces )
• Professor Layton (replaces )
• 
• 
• Bandana Dee (replaces )
• Crash Bandicoot (replaces )

Even though this is hypothetical, I just couldn't bring myself to cut Banjo and Hero, the latter for being one of the most successful JRPGs and the former for history with Nintendo and placing high in the Smash Ballot.

 

[Pupp135]

9/10, these new characters are all great additions, but Byleth was my favorite from the fighter’s pass.

Here is an alternate Mario Party 5 roster that I just came up with:


Waluigi, Toad, Birdo

Toad would have cyan as his main color (Boo’s color) in this game, and Birdo’s is magenta.

Just curious, where did you find this roster?

I found the alternate Melee roster here

 

[Butters Stotch]

I found the alternate Melee roster here

Thanks.

 

[Perkilator]

7/10

Hypothetical DLC fighters for SSBU

Bonus: Bandana Waddle Dee

Vol. 1

1. Arle
2. Hero
3. Banjo & Kazooie
4. Pyra / Mythra
5. Terry
6. Crash

Vol. 2

1. Min Min
2. Dr. Eggman
3. Sephiroth
4. Edelgard
5. Kazuya
6. Sora

 

[Butters Stotch]

10/10 - I disagree slightly with the removal of Steve, but that's mostly down to personal preference and Minecraft's impact on the industry. Other than that, I agree with pretty much all of this, especially with the choices of Eggman and Bandana Dee.

Since the leak I mentioned above likely isn't true after some searching, I'll provide an alternate version of Ultimate's DLC (FP2 included) that isn't restricted to the list and its choices.

Bonus fighter:

• Toad (replaces )

Fighters Pass 1:

• Travis Touchdown (replaces )
• 
• Bandana Dee (replaces )
• 
  
• 

Fighters Pass 2:

• Dixie Kong (replaces )
• 
• Dr. Eggman (replaces )
• /
• 
• 

 

[Perkilator]

10/10 - I disagree slightly with the removal of Steve, but that's mostly down to personal preference and Minecraft's impact on the industry. Other than that, I agree with pretty much all of this, especially with the choices of Eggman and Bandana Dee.

Since the leak I mentioned above likely isn't true after some searching, I'll provide an alternate version of Ultimate's DLC (FP2 included) that isn't restricted to the list and its choices.

Bonus fighter:

• Toad (replaces )

Fighters Pass 1:

• Travis Touchdown (replaces )
• 
• Bandana Dee (replaces )
• 
  
• 

Fighters Pass 2:

• Dixie Kong (replaces )
• 
• Dr. Eggman (replaces )
• /
• 
• 

8/10

Not as much variety but I can still appreciate it

Revamped Melee Roster if it had another year of development

1. 
2. 
3. 
4. 
5. 
6. 
7. 
8. 
9. 
10. 
11. 
12. 
13. 
14. 
15. 
16. /
17. 
18. 
19. 
20. Ayumi Tachibana
21. 
22. 
23. 
24. 
25. 
26. 
27. 

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

9/10
Ayumi Tachibana should've replaced by ExciteBiker to make it better.

Alternate SSBU roster
Veterans: Everyone returns
Newcomers:
1. Inkling
2. Daisy
3. Andross
4. Springman
5. Dark Samus
6. Lyn
7. Incineroar
8. Isabelle
9. Andy (Advance Wars)
10. Ribbon Girl
11. Octoling

Bonus: Bandana Dee

DLC:
1. Vaati (Zelda)
2. Captain Syrup
3. Captain Rainbow
4. Lord Fredrik
5. Byleth
6. Virtual Boy

1. MinMin
2. Cinderace
3. King Hippo
4. Rex and Pyra/Myhtra
5. Akira Howard
6. Captain N

 

[Butters Stotch]

8/10

Not as much variety but I can still appreciate it.

I understand. I mainly chose Toad, Dixie, and BWD for being big first parties missing from the base roster, Travis for being a creator request like Sonic and Snake, and Eggman for a second Sonic rep. I honestly prefer your roster to mine.

 

[Butters Stotch]

7.5/10 - Good choices here and I like that there are some niche picks here and there, though the lack of third parties kinda sticks out to me (unless that was the intent).

Since Perkilator did a way better job at a delayed Melee than I did, I'll revise another roster of mine.




Ganondorf has a fully unique moveset and the other clones are upgraded to semi-clones. Since this would've released around the time of Wind Waker, I added Toon over Young Link for promotional purposes. Falco was almost reduced to an alt (as was originally intended) and Lyn almost replaced Roy, but I like them too much to go through with either.

The alts in question:

• 
• /Justin Bailey
• Slippy Toad
• Peppy Hare
• Plusle
• Minun
• Lyn
• Shadow the Hedgehog (seeing him in Melee would've been insane)

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Looks cool.
10/10

"If Melee was released in 2004" Melee roster:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach/Daisy
4. Toad
5. Bowser
6. Geno
7. Link
8. Zelda/Sheik
9. Ganondorf
10. Toon Link/Young Link
11. Samus
12. Ridley
13. Kirby
14. King Dedede
15. Fox/Falco/Slippy/Leon
16. Wolf
17. Krystal
18. Pikachu
19. Pichu
20. Jigglypuff
21. Mewtwo
22. Sceptile
23. Ness
24. Ninten
25. Capt. Falcon
26. Black Shadow
27. Marth/Roy
28. Lyn
29. Ice Climbers
30. ExciteBiker
31. Pit
32. Isaac
33. Olimar
34. Mr. Game and Watch
35. Snake
36. Sonic

 

[txhy8]

Here's My Take of if I made the Smash Ultimate Roster:

Mario
Dr Mario
Paper Mario
Luigi
Peach
Daisy
Toad
Geno
Yoshi
Kamek
Birdo
Rosalina and Luma
Bowser
Bowser Jr
King Boo
Wario
Waluigi
Ashley
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Funky Kong
Dixie Kong
King K Rool
Link
Zelda
Sheik
Ganondorf
Toon Link
Young Link
Impa
Skull Kid
The Champions
Midna
Samus
Zero Suit Samus
Ridley
Dark Samus
Sylux
E.M.M.I
Kirby
King Dedede
Meta Knight
Bandana Dee
Marx
Fox
Falco
Wolf
Krystal
Pikachu
Jiggypuff
Pichu
Mewtwo
Pokemon Trainer
Lucario
Gerninja
Incinaroar
Septille
Zoroak
Toxicritry
Ness
Lucas
Porky
Captain Falcon
Ice Climbers
Mr. Game and Watch
Duck Hunt
R.O.B
Takamaru
Marth
Roy
Lyn
Ike
Chrom
Lucinia
Robin
Corrin
Byleth
Pit
Dark Pit
Paultena
Virdi
Hades
Olimar
Alph
Villager
Isabelle
Tom Nook
Wii Fit Trainer
Little Mac
Shulk
Elma
Rex and Pyra/Mythra
Inkling
Octoling
Spring Man
Min Min
Isaac(Golden Sun)
Andy(Advanced Wars)
Chorus Kids
Mach Rider
Balloon Fighter
Arkia Howard
Ring Fit Trainee
Sonic
Tails
Knuckles
Shadow
Dr. Eggman/ Robotnik
Beyonetta
Joker
Nahiobino
Arle
Mega Man
Ryu
Ken
Chun-Li
Dante
Phoenix Wright
Leon Kennedy
Monster Hunter
Terry Bogurad
Pac-Man
Kazuya
Lloyd Irving
Chosen Undead
Snake
Simon Belmont
Richter Belmont
Bomberman
Pyramid Head
Cloud
Sephroith
Hero
Sora
Lara Croft
Remiu
Scorpion
Heavy
Ryu Hayabusa
Banjo and Kazooie
Steve
Master Chief
Doomguy
Crash Bandicoot
Spyro the Dragon
Rayman
Shovel Knight
Shante
Frisk
Freddy Fazbear
Mii Brawler
Mii Swordfighter
Mii Gunner
Mii Mage

 

[Perkilator]

7/10

How about my hypothetical roster for Capcom vs. SNK 3?

Decided to change this up quite a bit

Spoiler: Base roster

Capcom	SNK
Team World Warrior (Shibuya) Ryu Ken Masters Chun-Li	Team Hero (Great Wall of China) Kyo Kusanagi Benimaru Nikaido Shun’ei
Team Shadaloo (Bangkok, Grand Palace) M. Bison Balrog Vega	Team Neo Geo (Neo Geo Land) Terry Bogard Iori Yagami Nakoruru
Team Metro City (Metro City) Cody Travers Guy Mike Haggar	Team Hungry Wolf (Venice) Mai Shiranui Joe Higashi Kim Kaphwan
Team Saikyo Style (Rio de Janeiro) Dan Hibiki Sakura Kasugano Blanka	Team Kyokugen (Pao Pao Café) Ryo Sakazaki Yuri Sakazaki Marco Rodriguez
Team 3rd Strike (Sydney) Alex Dudley Makoto	Team Garou (Madrid) Rock Howard B. Jenet King of Dinosaurs
Team Night Warriors (Big Ben) Felicia Jon Talbain Hsien-Ko	Team K’ (Vancouver) K’ Kula Diamond Maxima
Team Fatale Fury (Dunnottar Castle) Morrigan Aensland Juri Han Poison	Team Super Heroine (Paris) King Athena Asamiya Akari Ichijou
Team Taiyo Academy (Mykonos Island) Batsu Ichimonji Kyosuke Kagami Hinata Wakaba	Team Ikari (The Sahara) Ralf Jones Leona Heidern Fio Germi

The Arcade Mode would have a unique twist to it; the Loser's Bracket, where if you lose at any point, you get taken to a separate set of stages where you fight mind-controlled versions of the teams who also lost

Spoiler: Bosses

• Akuma (Loser's Bracket in the Arcade Mode)
• Geese (Win every battle normally)
• Hyo Imawano (Win every battle with a super move)
• Neo Dio (Win every battle with a super move without losing a single round and get a Perfect at least once)

Spoiler: DLC

Season 1	Season 2
Team Other World Love Heart Tessa Mui Mui Team Time Warp Strider Hiryu Haohmaru Sir Arthur	Team Special Forces (Mykonos Island) Guile Cammy White Charlie Nash Team Orochi Chris Yashiro Nanakase Shermie
Boss Challenge: Ω Rugal	Boss Challenge: Goddess Athena
Team New Faces Antonov Alice Nakata Darli Dagger Team Earth Power G Rashid Menat	Team Revelations Chris Redfield Frank West Phoenix Wright Rival Team Billy Kane Kukri Genjuro Kibagami
Boss Challenge: Pyron	Boss Challenge: Firebrand

 

[Perkilator]

Okay, so it’s been a while no responses. So I think we’ll start fresh.

Rate my fantasy Project X Zone Series roster:

Okay, so this is a redo of mine for Project X Zone 1 & 2. I already did that in the roster redo thread, but I wanted to do it here with a more reasonable 40 playable units per game.

Spoiler: Project X Zone 1

Pair Units (in order of who joins you)

Kogoro & Mii​	Reiji & Xiaomu​	Soma & Alisa​	Kite & BlackRose​	Haken Browning & Kaguya Nanbu​
Yuri Lowell & Lloyd Irving​	Xiaoyu & Hwoarang​	KOS-MOS & T-elos​	Chun-Li & Morrigan​	Frank West & Hsien-Ko​
Ryu & Ken​	Dante & Demitri​	X & Zero​	Chris Redfield & Jill Valentine​	Akira Yuki & Pai Chan​
Erica Fontaine & Gemini Sunrise​	Zephyr & Leanne​	Sakura Shinguji & Ichiro Ogami​	Kurt Irving & Riela Marcellis​	Toma & Cyrille​

Solo Units (in order of who joins you)

Lindow Amamiya​	Neneko / Neito​	Heihachi Mishima​	Sänger Zonvolt​	Valkyrie​
Jin Kazama​	Saya​	Tron Bonne​	Devilotte​	Arthur​
Lady​	Batsu Ichimonji​	Juri Han​	Genghis Bahn III​	Vashyron​
Gilius Thunderhead​	Imca​	Rikiya​	Bruno​	Ulala​

Spoiler: Project X Zone 2

Pair Units (in order of who joins you)

Reiji & Xiaomu​	Jin Kazama & Kazuya Mishima​	Kite & Haseo​	Ciel Alençon & Nana Kozuki​	Yuri Lowell & Flynn Scifo​
Chun-Li & Xiaoyu​	Frank West & Chuck Greene​	Morrigan Aensland & Demitri Maximoff​	X & Zero​	Dante & Vergil​
Ryu & Ken​	Strider Hiryu & Hotsuma​	Kazuma Kiryu & Goro Majima​	Akira Yuki & Kage-Maru​	Zephyr & Vashyron​
Sakura Shinguji & Gemini Sunrise​	Ichiro Ogami & Erica Fontaine​	Pit & Bayonetta​	KOS-MOS & Fiora​	Shulk & Lucina​

Solo Units (in order of who joins you)

Heihachi Mishima​	Natsu​	Aty​	Tarosuke​	Valkyrie​
Alisa​	Estelle​	Phoenix Wirght & Maya Fey​	Captain Commando​	Leon S. Kennedy​
Rose​	June Lin Milliam​	Felicia​	Ryo Hazuki​	Ulala​
Axel Stone​	Leanne​	Pai Chan​	Segata Sanshiro​	Hibana​

 

[Pupp135]

10

I don’t play Project X Zone, but it seems cool to me.

Please rate this list of 5 fighters to add into Smash Remix:

Diddy Kong
Meowth
Ayumi
Cloud
Banjo-Kazooie

Here is the current roster for reference

Spoiler: Smash Remix Roster

Mario
Luigi
Bowser
Dr. Mario
Donkey Kong
Link
Young Link
Ganondorf
Sheik
Samus
Dark Samus
Marth
Yoshi
Captain Falcon
Kirby
King Dedede
Fox
Falco
Wolf
Wario
Ness
Lucas
Pikachu
Jigglypuff
Mewtwo
Sonic
Marina Liteyears
Conker

 

[LoZ00]

9/10
I can't rate this selection any higher because I personally consider Princess Peach to be the character we need the most in Smash Remix, so I'd add her over Meowth, who I still like. Diddy Kong, Cloud, and Banjo & Kazooie are top-tier choices, though!

How about this Bandai-Namco roster I made?

Spoiler: Roster

PAC-MAN

• Pac-Man
• Ms. Pac-Man
• Blinky/Pinky/Inky/Clyde (cycle through them via alternate costumes, like with Hero)

Fighting games

• Heihachi Mishima (Tekken)
• King (Tekken)
• Ling Xiaoyu (Tekken)
• Mitsurugi (SoulCalibur)
• Ivy (SoulCalibur)
• Nightmare (SoulCalibur)

Series with two characters

• Lloyd Irving (Tales of Symphonia)
• Velvet Crowe (Tales of Berseria)
• Agumon (Digimon)
• Tailmon (Digimon)
• The Tarnished (Elden Ring)
• Soul of Cinder (Dark Souls)

Arcade characters

• GALAGA (Galaga)
• Valkyrie (Valkyrie)
• Gilgamesh (Tower of Druaga)
• Rick Taylor (Splatterhouse)
• Wonder Momo (Wonder Momo)
• Taizo Hori (Dig Dug)
• Toby "Kissy" Masayo (Baraduke)
• Mappy (Mappy)

Miscellaneous series

• Reiko Nagase (Ridge Racer)
• Klonoa (Klonoa)
• Alisia Ilinichina Amiella (God Eater)
• Don-chan (Taiko no Tatsujin)
• Aty (Summon Night)
• KOS-MOS (Xenosaga)
• Huckebein 30 (Super Robot Wars)

 

[Perkilator]

9/10 it’s a solid roster.

Project X Zone 3:

Spoiler: Pair Units

New heroes​	Reiji & Xiaomu (Namco x Capcom)​	Paul & Law (Tekken)​	Velvet & Laphicet (Tales of Berseria)​	Louis & Mia (Code Vein)​	Haken & Aschen (Super Robot Wars OG Saga: Endless Frontier)​
Ryu & Ken (Street Fighter)​	Morrigan & Lilith (Darkstalkers)​	X & Zero (Mega Man X5 / Mega Man Zero)​	Leon & Claire (Resident Evil: Degeneration)​	Akira & Sakura (Rival Schools)​	Frank & Chuck (Dead Rising 2: Case West)​
Sakura S. & Sakura A. (Sakura Wars)​	Akira & Aoi (Virtua Fighter)​	Kiryu & Ichiban (Yakuza: Like a Dragon)​	Joker & Akechi (Persona 5)​	Vyse & Aika (Skies of Arcadia)​	Mr. Y & Ms. Y (Streets of Rage 4)​
Edelgard & Dimitri (Fire Emblem: Three Houses)​	Noah & Mio (Xenoblade Chronicles 3)​	Samus & C. Falcon (Metroid Dread / F-ZERO: GP Legend)​	Dante & Bayonetta (Devil May Cry / Bayonetta 2)​	Pit & Valkyrie (Kid Icarus: Uprising / The Legend of Valkyrie)​	KOS-MOS & Aigis (Xenosaga / Persona 3)​

Spoiler: Solo Units

Jin Kazama (Tekken 7)​	Magilou (Tales of Berseria)​	Haruka Amami (The iDOLM@STER)​	Solaire (Dark Souls)​	Sänger Zonvolt (Super Robot Wars Alpha Gaiden)​	Tarosuke (Yokai Dochuki)​	Hugo Pennywort (God Eater 3)​
Chun-Li (Street Fighter)​	Demitri Maximoff (Darkstalkers)​	Strider Hiryu (Strider)​	Edward Falcon (Power Stone)​	Ruby Heart (Marvel vs. Capcom 2)​	Rolento (Final Fight)​	Viewtiful Joe​
Ulala (Space Channel 5: Part 3)​	Alis Landale (Phantasy Star)​	Selvaria Bles (Valkyria Chronicles)​	Sketch Turner (Comix Zone)​	Raidou (Devil Summoner)​	Floyd Iraia (Streets of Rage 4)​	Gilius Thunderhead (Golden Axe)​
​	​	Claude von Riegan (Fire Emblem: Three Houses)​	Malos (Xenoblade Chronicles 2)​	Dark Pit (Kid Icarus: Uprising)​	​	​