Rate the Rosters

[Perkilator]

Like a 6. Some weird cuts. cutting down series like Kirby only to give Ki and Xenoblade newcomers is weird and you've cut whole series. the third parties are too fsr, several "who?" , several characters who don't even exist,

Rate this smash 6 base newcomer line up

1. Waluigi
2. Pauline
3. Bandana Waddle Dee
4. Tinkaton
5. Edelgard
6. Oatchi
7. Tom Nook
8. Noah
9. Off the Hook
10. Octoling
11. Ring Fit Trainee
12. Ayumi Tachibana
13. Zero
14. Alucard
15. Shadow
16. Professor Layton

8/10 pretty solid.

My base game newcomer lineup for the next Smash game:

Spoiler

• 13 first parties
  1. Waluigi
  2. Raven Beak
  3. Bandana Waddle Dee
  4. Either Meowscarada, Tinkaton or Gholdengo
  5. Alear
  6. Oatchi
  7. Tom Nook
  8. Noah and/or Mio
  9. Marina (ft. Pearl Drone)
  10. Officer Howard
  11. Ring Fit Trainee
  12. Isaac
  13. Ayumi Tachibana
• 3 third parties
  1. Shadow
  2. Chun-Li
  3. Alucard
• 2 Echo Fighters
  1. Dixie Kong
  2. Ninjara

 

[BritishGuy54]

8/10. Solid line-up.

My selection of veterans and newcomers for a new Super Smash Bros. game.

 

[Pupp135]

8/10. Solid line-up.

View attachment 395119
My selection of veterans and newcomers for a new Super Smash Bros. game.

8/10 Most areas of the roster are solidly filled out, and I think the newcomer lineup is good overall. I’d also keep Pokemon Trainer, Icies, and Lucina on my roster though


I’ll try to attempt an SSB6 style roster

()(Waluigi)(Ashley)
()()
(Tinkaton)(Bandana Waddle Dee)
()(/)
(Tom Nook)((Octoling))(Off the Hook)(Oatchi)(Isaac)(Ayumi Tachibana)(Ring Fit Trainee)
(Knuckles)​

 

[MartianSnake]

8/10 Most areas of the roster are solidly filled out, and I think the newcomer lineup is good overall. I’d also keep Pokemon Trainer, Icies, and Lucina on my roster though


I’ll try to attempt an SSB6 style roster

()(Waluigi)(Ashley)
()()
(Tinkaton)(Bandana Waddle Dee)
()(/)
(Tom Nook)((Octoling))(Off the Hook)(Oatchi)(Isaac)(Ayumi Tachibana)(Ring Fit Trainee)
(Knuckles)​

Like a 6/10 if I'm being honest. I don't think any of the choices are bad per se, there's just not a lot of wow factor here... it's just the most wanted/expected newcomers... and knuckles. There's nothing truly giving me any wow factor here.

Here's my roster for a Mario & Sonic Sports game, not Olympics, just sports.

Mario Side:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Daisy
5. Wario
6. Waluigi
7. Donkey Kong
8. Yoshi
9. Bowser
10. Bowser Jr.
11. Rosalina (Unlockable)
12. Birdo (Unlockable)
13. Diddy Kong (Unlockable)
14. Dry Bones (Unlockable)
15. Nabbit (Unlockable)

Sonic Side:
1. Sonic
2. Tails
3. Amy
4. Knuckles
5. Shadow
6. Rouge
7. Silver
8. Blaze
9. Dr. Eggman
10. Vector
11. Cream & Cheese (Unlockable)
12. Metal Sonic (Unlockable)
13. Jet (Unlockable)
14. Sage (Unlockable)
15. Crabmeat (Unlockable)

Feel free to share thoughts if you have any. Might do stages later.

 

[darkvortex]

9. No real issues. All the necessary picks are here and Crabmeat is a fun extra.

Rate this PASBR Reboot roster

 

[MasterCheef]

5/10 makes no sense

1 , 2 , 3 = Mario , Luigi , & , Peach , ( Daisy = echo )
4 , 5 , & , 6 = Yoshi , ( Birdo = echo ) , Bowser , & , Kamek
7 , 8 , & , 9 = Donkey Kong , Diddy Kong , & , King K Rool
10 , 11 , 12 , & , 13 = Link , Zelda , & , Zant , & , Ganondorf
14 , & , 15 = Samus , ( Dark Samus = echo ) , & , Ridley
16 , & , 17 = Kirby , & King DeDeDe
18 , 19 , & , 20 = Pikachu , & , Gholdengo , & , Iron Valiant
21 = Pokemon Trainer : Chesnaught , Quaquaval , Incineroar
22, 23 , & , 24 = Pit , ( Dark Pit = echo ) , Palutena , & , Phosphora
25 = Mii Brawler , & , Mii Gunner , & , Mii Sword Mage
26 = Isabelle , ( Animal Crossing )
27 & 28 = Byleth & Alear ( Fire Emblem )
29 , 30 , 31 = Shulk , & ,( Pyra + Mythra ) , & , Noah + ( Mio = echo )
32 = Inkling , & , ( Octoling = Echo ) Splatoon
33 = Min Min
34 = Idea ( Soma Bringer )
35 = Officer Howard – Astral Chain
36 = Tabuu

Base 3rd party

37 = Pac-Man
38 = Sonic ( Knuckles = echo )
39 = Yumia ( Ryza = Alt ) = Atelier , via , Koei Tecmo
40 = Monster Hunter , via , Capcom ; MHST2 , design
41 = Force , rep ; Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis
42 = Harvard , from ; Deca Police
43 = Geno
44 = Persona 6 rep
45 = Vault Boy

DLC

46 , & , 47 = ( Ahri & Lux ) - League of Legends , via Riot Games
48 = codename : Legacy = XenoBlade Origins : protagonist
49 = Effy Starlight Re:Volver
50 = New Resident Evil Rep
51 = New Final Fantasy Rep
52 = New PokeMon Rep
53 = New ( Tales of ) rep from New ( Tales of ) game , via , Bandai Namco
54 , & , 55 = Master Chief & Arbiter ( Halo )

 

[darkvortex]

5/10 makes no sense

If I can ask why it make no sense?

 

[Masked Borb]

5/10 makes no sense

1 , 2 , 3 = Mario , Luigi , & , Peach , ( Daisy = echo )
4 , 5 , & , 6 = Yoshi , ( Birdo = echo ) , Bowser , & , Kamek
7 , 8 , & , 9 = Donkey Kong , Diddy Kong , & , King K Rool
10 , 11 , 12 , & , 13 = Link , Zelda , & , Zant , & , Ganondorf
14 , & , 15 = Samus , ( Dark Samus = echo ) , & , Ridley
16 , & , 17 = Kirby , & King DeDeDe
18 , 19 , & , 20 = Pikachu , & , Gholdengo , & , Iron Valiant
21 = Pokemon Trainer : Chesnaught , Quaquaval , Incineroar
22, 23 , & , 24 = Pit , ( Dark Pit = echo ) , Palutena , & , Phosphora
25 = Mii Brawler , & , Mii Gunner , & , Mii Sword Mage
26 = Isabelle , ( Animal Crossing )
27 & 28 = Byleth & Alear ( Fire Emblem )
29 , 30 , 31 = Shulk , & ,( Pyra + Mythra ) , & , Noah + ( Mio = echo )
32 = Inkling , & , ( Octoling = Echo ) Splatoon
33 = Min Min
34 = Idea ( Soma Bringer )
35 = Officer Howard – Astral Chain
36 = Tabuu

Base 3rd party

37 = Pac-Man
38 = Sonic ( Knuckles = echo )
39 = Yumia ( Ryza = Alt ) = Atelier , via , Koei Tecmo
40 = Monster Hunter , via , Capcom ; MHST2 , design
41 = Force , rep ; Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis
42 = Harvard , from ; Deca Police
43 = Geno
44 = Persona 6 rep
45 = Vault Boy

DLC

46 , & , 47 = ( Ahri & Lux ) - League of Legends , via Riot Games
48 = codename : Legacy = XenoBlade Origins : protagonist
49 = Effy Starlight Re:Volver
50 = New Resident Evil Rep
51 = New Final Fantasy Rep
52 = New PokeMon Rep
53 = New ( Tales of ) rep from New ( Tales of ) game , via , Bandai Namco
54 , & , 55 = Master Chief & Arbiter ( Halo )

Sorry, 4/10 from me. ...would've been a 5 if you didn't just copy and paste this exact same roster already. And some of these options don't make too much sense to me. Like... All these Mario characters, but no Wario? Why Zant in particular for the 4th Zelda rep? TWO Kirby characters? And then FOUR Kid Icarus characters right after? (No hate to KI, I LOVE Uprising, but c'mon-) Three Paldean Pokemon, and one from Kanto, Alola, and Kalos. I know people detest that Gen 1 gets so much love, but wouldn't that mean that we should... SPREAD the representation, and not FLOOD another Gen? Why is Mio an echo of Noah? Doesn't she use a totally different weapon from him? No Pikmin? I might be able to understand the lack of the Retros, Wii Fit, Little Mac & all of Star Fox, but Pikmin not getting a crumb feels odd in this day and age. Who wants Knuckles to be an ECHO of Sonic exactly? When Shadow & even Metal Sonic exist? And doesn't Knuckles have unique stuff that he can do that Sonic can't? I just-

It's trying too hard to not be what everyone else would say they want, and it just doesn't feel that well though-out.

...

...anywho. Here's a roster where everyone gets to be Ice Climbers and Banjo & Kazooie and Duck Hunt. Smash Bros. Duos, or something. Rate away!

Because many popular characters that would usually be here don't exactly HAVE friends or family that can fight alongside them, certain familiar faces just couldn't make the cut. For some duos, I had some trouble figuring out who and who could go together. Especially for the Pokémon.

 

[MasterCheef]

5/10 Too much bad ( Star Fox ) too much Splatoon , lack of quality Pokemon characters , should have used TOTK heroes , too much Fire Emblem,

1 , 2 , 3 = Mario , Luigi , & , Peach , ( Daisy = echo )
4 , 5 , & , 6 = Yoshi , ( Birdo = echo ) , Bowser , & , Kamek
7 , 8 , & , 9 = Donkey Kong , Diddy Kong , & , King K Rool
10 , 11 , & , 12 = Link , Zelda , & , Ganondorf
13 , & , 14 = Samus , ( Dark Samus = echo ) , & , Ridley
15 , 16 , 17 = Kirby , & King DeDeDe , & , President Max Profitt Haltmann
18 , 19 = Fox , ( Wolf = Echo ) , & , Krystal
20 , 21 , 22 , & , 23 = Pikachu , Mewtwo , Lucario , & , New PokeMon Rep
24 = Pokemon Trainer : Chesnaught , Quaquaval , Incineroar
25 , 26 = Pit , ( Dark Pit = echo ) , Palutena
27 = Mii Brawler , & , Mii Gunner , & , Mii Sword Mage
28 = Isabelle , ( Animal Crossing )
29 , 30 , 31 = Byleth , Alear , & , Tsubasa Oribe , ( Fire Emblem )
32 , 33 , 34 = Shulk , & ,( Pyra + Mythra ) , & , Noah + ( Mio = echo )
35 = Inkling , & , ( Octoling = Echo ) Splatoon
36 = Tabuu

Base 3rd party

37 = Pac-Man
38 = Sonic , ( Knuckles = echo )
39 = Yumia ( Ryza = Alt ) = Atelier , via , Koei Tecmo
40 = Force , rep ; Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis
41 = Harvard , from ; Deca Police
42 = Legend of Heroes Rep
43 = Geno
44 = Persona 6 rep
45 = Vault Boy
DLC


46 , & , 47 = ( Ahri & Lux ) - League of Legends , via Riot Games
48 = New ( Tales of ) rep from New ( Tales of ) game , via , Bandai Namco
49 = Monster Hunter , via , Capcom ; MHST2 , design
50 = New Resident Evil Rep
51 = New Final Fantasy Rep
52 = Officer Howard – Astral Chain
53 = codename : Legacy = XenoBlade Origins : protagonist
54 , & , 55 = Master Chief & Arbiter ( Halo )

 

[darkvortex]

Please stop posting the same roster

anyway 6\10. Pikmin, Star Fox, Wario and most of FE being cut is odd. Some of the echos make no sense. Mio and Knuckles don't work as echos and why would Wolf suddenly become an echo. Third parties are okay but putting "x rep" instead of committing to choose a character is kinda lame imo, and why are there several characters who don't exist yet.

rate this King of Fighters style smash \ Nintendo Roster

Team Mushroom Heroes
Mario
Luigi
Yoshi

Team Princess
Peach
Lucina
Daisy

Team Kong
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Cranky Kong

Team Great Kings
Bowser
Ganondorf
King K. Rool

Team Hyrule
Link
Zelda
Sidon

Team Popstar
Kirby
Bandana Dee
King Dedede

Team Space
Samus
Fox
Olimar

Team Pokemon
Pikachu
Jigglypuff
Lucario

Team Starter
Charizard
Sceptile
Greninja

Team Psychic
Shulk
Ness
Mewtwo

Team Squid
Inkling
Callie
Marie

Team off the Hook
Pearl
Marina
Agent 8

Team Three Houses
Edelgard
Dimitri
Claude

Team Crossing
Tom Nook
Isabelle
Villager

Team Fist
Little Mac
Min Min
Captain Falcon

Team Rivals
Wolf
Wario
Meta Knight

Team Skyworld
Pit
Palutena
Bayonetta

Team Retro
R.O.B.
Duck Hunt
Mr. Game & Watch

Team Guest
Sonic
Mega Man
Pac-Man

 

[Pupp135]

9/10 I like the trios, and the only changes I’d make are just picky.

Here is a Fire Emblem fighting game roster (20 fighters base game, 8 DLC fighters)

Marth
Tiki
Celica
Sigurd
Lief
Roy
Lyn
Hector
Ephraim
Lyon
Ike
Elincia
Chrom+Robin
Lucina
Corrin
Camilla
Edelgard
Dimitri
Claude
Alear

DLC: Micaiah, Camilla, Zephiel, Caeda, Byleth, Nino, Veyle, Grima