Meta Knight
7.5/10: MK is a character I have some trouble rating just because he is so weird: he hails from the Kirby series and yet he is so dark and dramatic. I think that this render achieves the result of representing well MK by just adding the wind effect. However, it's a little too basic, at least to me.
8.5/10: those wings are incredible. I love them. This render is dynamic but in the best way possible. It isn't too dynamic and yet it conveys the idea of movement and speed. Oh, and it's quite menacing as well!
8/10: to me, it's a direct improvement from the Brawl one. They exaggerated the wind effect and made MK more dynamic but I like it. It makes him more ready for the fight.
Overall:
<
<
Pit
8.5/10: this is actually a great render! Maybe it's because they built Pit's personality on his Brawl persona, but I feel like this render greatly conveys Pit's character. He's slightly smiling, boasting a battle-ready stance and yet he's not too serious. Great job!
9/10: I could totally see Pit in this pose right before an important fight, like against Medusa or Hades. You can say Pit's landing, but he may also be ready to fly again. He's serious and concerned and maybe, and just maybe, if he smiled I would have given this render a hot 10/10.
6.5/10: don't get me wrong. This render ain't bad. It's just... awkward. Why is Pit posing in this way? As a side note, I've always liked Palutena's Bow as a complete bow rather than to separate blades, to this render has this flaw too.
Overall:
<<
<
Zero Suit Samus
7.5/10: is it just me or did they give Sheik and ZSS, the two "transformation" characters, very similar renders in Brawl? However, ZSS's version is much more polished and lacks the weird arm-thingy Sheik is doing. It's an overall solid render.
7/10: it's an ok render. I don't really like the positioning of the legs and how her face is turned.
8.5/10: that's a nice render! I love the overall positioning of ZSS: it looks like she's been spotted and she's retaliating. It's great: it's quite dynamic but not too much and any of her limbs is in a weird pose (something Ultimate's render tend to do often).
Overall:
<
<
Wario
7/10: Wario's pose is quite standard, but it does the job pretty well. It conveys Wario's personality pretty well. It's solid.
8/10: fantastic. I love this render: you can tell that THIS is Wario. If only Sakurai didn't stick to the weird WarioWare aesthetic and moves and used more classic Wario Land references...
2/10: what's Wario doing? Is he flexing? Is he jumping? Is he uncomfortable? All these questions show how bad this render really is.
9.5/10: one of the best renders in the series. They got everything right. The dynamicity, the double "W" sign, the huge mouth and the grin. Ever since I saw it, I loved it.
Overall:
<<<
<
<
Snake
2/10: Snake stands there. He does look pretty bad and unreliable. I really dislike this one and his face looks like the one of a low-level criminal.
7.5/10: a great improvement and yet they could do something more. There's not a lot to say (paradoxically I think that we can spend more time on a 5 rather than on a 7), but I like the way he's turned. But why is he trying to measure his heartbeats?
Overall:
<<<
Ike
8/10: a solid render. You can tell you will play with a burly swordsman. The only thing I don't really like is the fact that he holds Ragnell with two hands.
9/10: Ike's huge in this render. He's still. He means no joke. You'll get no sympathy from him.
5/10: why does he look like a dancer? Why do they have to take one step forward (with Smash 4) and then 4 steps back? And I want the name of the GODDAMN PERSON THAT LOVES TO WEIRDLY POSITION LIMBS. Seriously, the left-hand doesn't work at all!
Overall:
<<
<
Pokémon Trainer
6/10: it's basic. It's decent. It's not great, taken alone, but you should look at it with the three Pokémon. That way he would look better (I think).
8/10: neat! They used a very simple yet effective improvement: the pointing hand. He has a determined expression that goes really well with the character, even though Pokémon Trainers are known for their abysmal personality.
8.5/10: I think I like Leaf a little more than Red though. She is so cute and happy I can't resist her. Actually, I can. I never pick Leaf, as she uses weird colors for the Pokémon. But as for the trainer herself, Leaf is stellar!
Overall:
<<
<
Squirtle
7/10: despite its very basic appearance, I like this render. Squirtle looks cute and kinda happy. I also like how it's trying to do its best impression of Bowser: a huge menacing turtle and a cute little one.
5.5/10: Squirtle is doing this weird leap: how is it positioning its legs and arms? It's also weirdly turned. I have to admit I like the color more than in Brawl though.
Overall:
<
Ivysaur
7.5/10: it's very similar to Squirtle's render, but I like this one slightly more because, at least to me, it looks like Ivysaur's Gen 1 artwork. I'm a huge fan of Ivysaur so maybe I'm slightly biased. But it's solid and still.
4/10: why in the holy name of God is Ivysaur leaping in this weird way? I have to say that I like the whips. Without them, it would have probably been a harsh 2.5.
Overall:
<<
Charizard
5/10: the worst part of this render is the huge head of Charizard. Other than that, it's pretty basic, much like the rest of the PT team renders. But the huge head is a big drawback.
7.5/10: Brawl's render done right. As a bonus point, they made Zard stomping. It's good.
9/10: COOL! I'm no Charizard fan, but this render is great and makes me wonder why isn't Charizard a Dragon-type Pokémon. It's aggressive. It's flying towards its victim looking for an opening. I like the beastly vibes this render gives to me.
Overall:
<<
<