Rate And Discuss Their Chances: Closed

[DMurr]

Want: 5
Likeliness: 1

He's only reasonably possible because of the Smash polls and popularity among Smash fans. I don't really expect him to happen but I think he's awesome despite never playing Mario RPG.

Nominate Claus x5

 

[jigglover]

You dirty Opposum! You said it was OK! I give you a free bowl! Since I'm nice, I'll tell you to watch your precious Opposum, since an 'accident' might happen. (I'm joking, don't worry!)

Anyway...

Want: 0
Bowser junior and Toad deserves it more.
Likelihood: 1.19

I don't think he's got much of a chance. He isn't in the top 5, hasn't got much move-set potential and his popularity is descending by the month.

 

[Opossum]

Hehehe...

 

[jigglover]

Can you include in your next OP me chasing Marth out and dragging him back in the stadium on the ground with the tip of my sword at his throat? If I ever get to write some then I'll include you in some way! :D

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

You dirty Opposum! You said it was OK! I give you a free bowl! Since I'm nice, I'll tell you to watch your precious Opposum, since an 'accident' might happen. (I'm joking, don't worry!)

Anyway...

Want: 0
Bowser junior and Toad deserves it more.
Likelihood: 1.19

I don't think he's got much of a chance. He isn't in the top 5, hasn't got much move-set potential and his popularity is descending by the month.

You really don't know anything about Geno?

The hell no move set potential?

His fan base is still there, they just aren't as active as they were. They don't think he's the most likely character ever. They'd still love to have him in the game though

 

[jigglover]

It's still descending, I might say that I was under-whelmed by the one on the Geno thread, since it seemed that everything used his beam in some way.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

It's still descending, I might say that I was under-whelmed by the one on the Geno thread, since it seemed that everything used his beam in some way.

How is it descending?

People are seriously not going from "I'd love Geno in the game" to "He sucks"

No one is doing that.

Geno has magic, hidden traps, and weapons. He's got a variety of movesets he can use through that.

 

[jigglover]

No, but it is getting smaller and people are beginning to like him less.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

No, but it is getting smaller and people are beginning to like him less.

No they aren't. They just don't think he's likely

 

[jigglover]

Appreciate him less then. What weapons does he have, how are his traps unique and why is his magic different to that of Peach's and Zelda's?

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

His body is filled with secret compartments that hold weapons such as ancient pistols to cannons to laser guns. He can use star magic, since he's a star spirit, and doesn't have anything such as fireball and when the hell did peach have magic?

His moveset potential could be a lot like the puppets in Naruto as well, giving him a lot of unpredictable attacks.

 

[jigglover]

Peach's bum bounce or whatever it's called does. I've never watched Naruto before so I wouldn't know.The weapons and things sound cool, so maybe he has moveset potential but not much else. Also, I'm going to be at 11 tonight so don't expect another reply from me until the morning.

 

[Venus of the Desert Bloom]

Geno has a lot of move set potential. Just because he uses beams doesn't limit him. It's like saying Bowser can only use his fire breathe. He has a wide assortment of abilities.

And how is Peach's *** bounce a magic attack? Peach doesn't use any type of magic.

 

[Opossum]

Okay, the end of the day has come. Time to tally.


Dun dun dun...

 

[Opossum]

After a whirlwind day of many trials and tribulations, things looked bleak for Geno. Even after his impressive showcase of moves, people highly doubted him, and some even despised him. This reduced his want score to a shaky 2.46. His likelihood was even worse. Geno had scored a pitiful 0.98. Jeers were heard across the stadium. Geno, the high and mighty star spirit, was getting booed off the stage. Even Starfy and Chibi Robo, who had the same fate, joined in to boo off the puppet.

"Quiet you fools!" Geno demanded. "You cannot grasp my power!"

After going into a destructive rage and blowing up half the stadium, all was quiet. Geno had been returned to the Star Road for now. He left behind a strip of paper that gave Really Shy Guy 5 more nominations.

Suddenly, a clunky whirring sound was heard in the now silent air. A small, maybe 10 inches across, spaceship landed in the stadium, followed by some Onions. Olimar, a Brawl veteran, stepped out to a bit of applause and was welcomed by the Guy with the Opossum on his Shoulder. His fate of returning would now be determined.



It is now Day 46. You may vote on Olimar while predicting
Mr. Stevenson's score. Anna is now up for revoting.


New Lists Below:

[COLLAPSE="Nominations"]x76 Masked Man
x73 Mach Rider
x64 Shy Guy
x61 Dr. Mario
x61 M. Bison
x59 Lip
x50 Kalas
x48 Groose
x40 Demise (alt. costume for Ganondorf)
x38 Sonic
x35 Lucina
x34 Leon Powalski
x33 Mike Jones
x33 Snake
x31 King Hippo
x30 Bandanna Dee
x29 Medusa
x28 Ike
x28 Funky Kong
x23 Tingle
x22 Andy
x22 Black Mage
x22 Vaati
x20 Baby Mario & Luigi
x18 Duck Hunt Dog
x18 Meowth
x17 Balloon Fighter
x16 Alexandra Roivas
x16 Kamek
x14 Jigglypuff
x14 Captain A
x13 Prince Sable
x13 Pichu
x12 Dillon
x12 Hades
x10 Adam Malkovich
x10 Shadow the Hedgehog
x10 Daisy
x10 Impa
x9 Sheriff
x8 Travis Touchdown
x8 King Boo
x8 Scizor
x8 Nightmare (Soul Calibur)
x7 KOS-MOS
x6 Pokemon Trainer
x6 Diskun
x5 Palutena (Revote)
x5 Animal Crosser
x5 Dr. Mario (alt costume)
x5 Deoxys
x4 Caeda
x4 K K Slider
x3 Toon Zelda
x3 Meta Knight
x3 Dry Bowser (alternate costume)
x2 Slime
x2 Dark Samus (Revote)
x2 Majora's Mask Link
x2 Genesect
x2 Zero Suit Samus
x2 Leaf (Fire Emblem)
x1 Birdo
x1 Zero (Mega Man)
x1 Young Link
x1 Ninten
x1 Micaiah
x1 Ivy (Soul Caliber)
x1 Morrigan (Darkstalker)
x1 Chaos (Sonic the Hedgehog)
x1 Black Knight
x1 Shake King
x1 Terra Bradford
x1 Prince Fluff
x1 Tails
x1 Shadow
x1 Victini
x1 Hoenn Pokemon Trainer
x1 Magnus
x1 Ayumi Tachibana
x1 Pac Man
x1 Fawful[/COLLAPSE]




[COLLAPSE="Standings"]Veterans:
1. Mario (5)
2. Luigi (5)
3. Peach (5)
4. Bowser (5)
5. Donkey Kong (5)
6. Diddy Kong (5)
7. Yoshi (5)
8. Wario (5)
9. Link (5)
10. Zelda (5)
11. Samus (5)
12. Kirby (5)
13. King Dedede (5)
14. Fox (5)
15. Pikachu (5)
16. Captain Falcon (5)
17. Pit (5)
--------------------------------------------
18. Ganondorf (4.98 in likelihood, 4.73 in want)
19. Ice Climbers (4.98 in likelihood, 4.58 in want)
20. Ness (4.94 in likelihood, 4.64 in want)
21. Marth (4.84 in likelihood, 4.55 in want)
22. R.O.B. (4.73 in likelihood, 4.15 in want)
23. Lucario (4.27 in likelihood, 4.34 in want)

Newcomers:
Top Ten:
1. King K. Rool (4.24 in likelihood, 4.36 in want)
2. Palutena (4.12 in likelihood, 3.65 in want)
3. Ridley (4.01 in likelihood, 4.19 in want)
4. Mewtwo (4.01 in likelihood, 4.17 in want)
5. Little Mac (3.8 in likelihood, 3.55 in want)
6. Takamaru (3.65 in likelihood, 3.14 in want)
7. Saki Amamiya (3.42 in likelihood, 3.59 in want)
8. Shulk (3.42 in likelihood, 3.05 in want)
9. Samurai Goroh (3.41 in likelihood, 3.44 in want)
10. Isaac (3.33 in likelihood, 3.62 in want)
--------------------------------------------
11. Zoroark (3.29 in likelihood, 2.52 in want)
12. Mega Man (3.18 in likelihood, 3.79 in want) (Capcom)
13. Roy (3.03 in likelihood, 3.33 in want)
14. Dixie Kong (2.96 in likelihood, 2.67 in want)
15. Krom (2.92 in likelihood, 2.35 in want)
16. Bowser Jr. (2.78 in likelihood, 2.75 in want)
17. Toad (2.74 in likelihood, 2.85 in want)
18. Krystal (2.42 in likelihood, 2.21 in want)
19. Muddy Mole (2.4 in likelihood, 3.03 in want)
20. Starfy (2.32 in likelihood, 2.74 in want)
21. Paper Mario (2.28 in likelihood, 2.88 in want)
22. Mii (2.25 in likelihood, 2 in want)
23. Ghirahim (2.23 in likelihood, 2.77 in want)
24. Waluigi (2.09 in likelihood, 2.2 in want)
25. Dark Samus (1.91 in likelihood, 2.28 in want)
26. Black Shadow (1.72 in likelihood, 1.99 in want)
27. Chibi-Robo (1.63 in likelihood, 2.71 in want)
28. Ray (1.34 in likelihood, 2.94 in want)
29. Lyndis (1.1 in likelihood, 1.93 in want)
30. Plusle & Minun (1.04 in likelihood, 1.12 in want)
31. Geno (0.98 in likelihood, 2.46 in want)
32. Lloyd Irving (0.97 in likelihood, 1.59 in want) (Namco Bandai)
33. Rosalina (0.84 in likelihood, 2.4 in want)
34. Skull Kid (0.64 in likelihood, 2.22 in want)
35. Tom Nook (0.53 in likelihood. 2.04 in want)
36. Sukapon (0.48 in likelihood, 2.18 in want)
37. Anna (0.47 in likelihood, 0.9 in want)
38. Yoshimitsu (0.35 in likelihood, 1.05 in want) (Namco Bandai)[/COLLAPSE]

 

[lobotheduck21]

want 2.5: indifferent

likely hood 4.8: He is the FACE of pikmin, he ain't goin' anywhere

prediction: (although it pains me) 1.25

nominations: baby bros. x 5

 

[Opossum]

Want: 5. My Brawl main + a series I love + No cut mentality.

Likelihood: 5.

Face of the series. He won't be removed for a New Captain, I can tell you. If they were to add a new captain, it would be an addition, not a replacement.

And they're not just gonna cut the series out, no sir re bob.

Prediction: 0.54

Nominate Jigglypuff x5

 

[SmashShadow]

Olimar
Want:5
Likelihood:5
He's the face of Pikmin and with Pikmin 3 coming out he's not even close to irrelevant. He is the sole rep from his series and Sakurai has never cut a character from a single character rep'd series.

Mr Stevenson: .58

5x Masked Man...sigh the last one on my roster left to vote up.

 

[yani]

Olimar

Want: 5
Likelihood: 5

Unique character, series still going, only rep in that series..yeah he isn't going anywhere.

Sonic x 5

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Olimar
Want: 5
Likelihood: 5
I LOVE PIKMIN! And I don't care if he isn't the main charatcer in Pikmin 3, he's still the main character of the series.

Nominations: Doctor Mario x5

Prediction for Stevenson: 1.11

 

[Mario & Sonic Guy]

Olimar gets a 4.75 likelihood from me. Olimar is the main character of the Pikmin franchise, so it would be a big mistake to ditch him.

 

[BKupa666]

Want and Likelihood: 5

Face of Pikmin is face of Pikmin and not going anywhere, ever, especially since he's pretty much the only universally well-known/liked Nintendo IP of the new millennium.

Predicting 0.34 for Stevenson
Nominate Hades x3, King Hippo x2

 

[Jhonnykiller45]

Olimar:
Want- 4
Likelihood- 4.99

He's the cheapest ******* ever face of the series, I don't see Olimar getting cut any time soon.

Prediction for Mr. Stevenson- 0.45

Nominations
Dr. Mario
Snake x3
Mach Rider

 

[---]

Want: 5
Likeliness: 5

No reason to cut. I will admit the possibility of another Pikmin character though, will depend on how many new Pikmin types we get in Pikmin 3.

x5 Ike

 

[Deleted member]

Olimar:
Want: 5
I do not support cuts, even if it's one I would not miss if cut.
Likelihood: 5
He's the star of two of the 3 games, and his whereabouts in the 3rd have been kept secret, which implies he plays some role.

 

[Ember Reaper]

Want: 5 He's Olimar!!!
Likelihood: 5
Face of Pikmin. Huge.

Nom:
Masked Man X2
Vaati X3

 

[Sqid]

Face of Pikmin. Huge.

Actually, he's pretty small.

Want: 4.8
Likelihood: 4.8
He's the face of the series, etc, even though he's not in 3 he won't be removed, just maybe someone else added (Blue haired captain FTW!)

Prediction: Who is Mr. Stevenson?

Nominations: Sonic x5

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Actually, he's pretty small.

And Mr. Stevenson is a guy from an old NES Zapper game, Gumshoe.

 

[shrooby]

Darn, I missed Geno's day. I actually had stuff to say. At least other people basically said for me.

Want: 5
I don't support characters being cut, especially unique characters.
True, he may not be playable in Pikmin 3, but he could (and most likely will) still appear in it. If we were to get a new rep, it would, in the words of Opposum, "be an addition, not a replacement." And face of the series. Yeah, all of that jazz. Likeliness: 5

Nominations:
Mach Rider x2
Tingle x2
Jigglypuff x1

 

[jigglover]

Want: 1 I only want him back if he uses only rock, pink (if they exist, just speculation right now) and the purple ones to return to be playable.
Likelihood: 4.98 Hmm... I wonder why!?

 

[MelMoe]

Nominations

Ike x5

Voting & Discussing

Olimar

Personal Bias: 5
Likelihood: 5

He stays. Olimar is a new fighter from a new franchise. He will not be cut in favor of a new Pikmin character either.

Prediction

Mr. Stevenson: 0.3

 

[deuxhero]

Olimar: 5: Only vet cuts were time constraints and Pichu

Nominate: Alexandra x5

 

[Ghirahilda]

Olimar
Want: 5
He is my Brawl main! Is the best one to represent the pikmin series!

Likelihood: 4.99
Crucify me, but no one knows what happened to him yet in Pikmin 3. Maybe he return. maybe he is older, maybe he is dead.

Prediction for Mr. Stevenson: 0.97

Nominations: Jigglypuff x10

 

[Opossum]

Crucify me, but no one knows what happened to him yet in Pikmin 3. Maybe he return. maybe he is older, maybe he is dead.

Crazy fan theory time: Pikmin 3 takes place in an alternate timeline in which Olimar did not retrieve all 30 parts in time and becomes a Pikmin. Years later, this ragtag team of four must return to the Pikmin Planet and locate the "Olimin" before it is too late and he dies in some way, in order to bring him back to Hocotate to restore his former self.


After that, he is playable, a la President in Pikmin 2.

 

[Robert of Normandy]

Crazy fan theory time: Pikmin 3 takes place in an alternate timeline in which Olimar did not retrieve all 30 parts in time and becomes a Pikmin. Years later, this ragtag team of four must return to the Pikmin Planet and locate the "Olimin" before it is too late and he dies in some way, in order to bring him back to Hocotate to restore his former self.


After that, he is playable, a la President in Pikmin 2.

My theory: he is the new Hocotate president. He was the only employee of any merit at the company, after all.

 

[SmashShadow]

@Really Shy Guy
wrong prediction...we're doing Mr.Stevenson

 

[Ghirahilda]

@Really Shy Guy
wrong prediction...we're doing Mr.Stevenson

Uh-Oh!!!
Thanks for that! LOL

 

[Opossum]

The day is over. Head back to your onions and await my return.

 

[Opossum]

The day came to a close. Olimar, worrying about the sunset, had to be reassured that he and his troop were safe. After some quick reassurance, he was ready to face the music. To his surprise, he did really well, with a 4.52 in want. After this, his troop of Pikmin also cheered. Well, except the Purple, who just sort of sat there. Not even Olimar was ready for what came next. He had received a 4.96 in likelihood. Even the Purple Pikmin stood up and cheered at this. The crowd roared as Olimar took a bow. As he left in the ship, one Red Pikmin waltzed up to MelMoe and gave him an additional 5 nominations.

The night sky left as the morning sun came up. A wayward detective came onto the scene. He was an older man. Many have never heard of the guy. Mr. Stevenson had a couple of quirks. For one, he could only jump if someone tried to shoot him. That made getting him up on stage was a chore. Nonetheless, he was still ready to show that he still had something in him, despite being retro.



It is now Day 47. You may rate Mr. Stevenson while predicting Masked Man's score for tomorrow. Plusle and Minun are up for revoting.


Lists Below:


[COLLAPSE="Nominations:"]x76 Mach Rider
x67 Dr. Mario
x64 Shy Guy
x61 M. Bison
x59 Lip
x50 Kalas
x48 Sonic
x48 Groose
x40 Demise (alt. costume for Ganondorf)
x38 Ike
x36 Snake
x35 Lucina
x34 Leon Powalski
x33 Mike Jones
x33 King Hippo
x30 Bandanna Dee
x30 Jigglypuff
x29 Medusa
x28 Funky Kong
x25 Baby Mario & Luigi
x25 Vaati
x25 Tingle
x22 Andy
x22 Black Mage
x21 Alexandra Roivas
x18 Duck Hunt Dog
x18 Meowth
x17 Balloon Fighter
x16 Kamek
x15 Hades
x14 Captain A
x13 Prince Sable
x13 Pichu
x12 Dillon
x10 Adam Malkovich
x10 Shadow the Hedgehog
x10 Daisy
x10 Impa
x9 Sheriff
x8 Travis Touchdown
x8 King Boo
x8 Scizor
x8 Nightmare (Soul Calibur)
x7 KOS-MOS
x6 Pokemon Trainer
x6 Diskun
x5 Palutena (Revote)
x5 Animal Crosser
x5 Dr. Mario (alt costume)
x5 Deoxys
x4 Caeda
x4 K K Slider
x3 Toon Zelda
x3 Meta Knight
x3 Dry Bowser (alternate costume)
x2 Slime
x2 Dark Samus (Revote)
x2 Majora's Mask Link
x2 Genesect
x2 Zero Suit Samus
x2 Leaf (Fire Emblem)
x1 Birdo
x1 Zero (Mega Man)
x1 Young Link
x1 Ninten
x1 Micaiah
x1 Ivy (Soul Caliber)
x1 Morrigan (Darkstalker)
x1 Chaos (Sonic the Hedgehog)
x1 Black Knight
x1 Shake King
x1 Terra Bradford
x1 Prince Fluff
x1 Tails
x1 Shadow
x1 Victini
x1 Hoenn Pokemon Trainer
x1 Magnus
x1 Ayumi Tachibana
x1 Pac Man
x1 Fawful[/COLLAPSE]




[COLLAPSE="Results:"]Veterans:
1. Mario (5)
2. Luigi (5)
3. Peach (5)
4. Bowser (5)
5. Donkey Kong (5)
6. Diddy Kong (5)
7. Yoshi (5)
8. Wario (5)
9. Link (5)
10. Zelda (5)
11. Samus (5)
12. Kirby (5)
13. King Dedede (5)
14. Fox (5)
15. Pikachu (5)
16. Captain Falcon (5)
17. Pit (5)
--------------------------------------------
18. Ganondorf (4.98 in likelihood, 4.73 in want)
19. Ice Climbers (4.98 in likelihood, 4.58 in want)
20. Olimar (4.96 in likelihood, 4.52 in want)
21. Ness (4.94 in likelihood, 4.64 in want)
22. Marth (4.84 in likelihood, 4.55 in want)
23. R.O.B. (4.73 in likelihood, 4.15 in want)
24. Lucario (4.27 in likelihood, 4.34 in want)

Newcomers:
Top Ten:
1. King K. Rool (4.24 in likelihood, 4.36 in want)
2. Palutena (4.12 in likelihood, 3.65 in want)
3. Ridley (4.01 in likelihood, 4.19 in want)
4. Mewtwo (4.01 in likelihood, 4.17 in want)
5. Little Mac (3.8 in likelihood, 3.55 in want)
6. Takamaru (3.65 in likelihood, 3.14 in want)
7. Saki Amamiya (3.42 in likelihood, 3.59 in want)
8. Shulk (3.42 in likelihood, 3.05 in want)
9. Samurai Goroh (3.41 in likelihood, 3.44 in want)
10. Isaac (3.33 in likelihood, 3.62 in want)
--------------------------------------------
11. Zoroark (3.29 in likelihood, 2.52 in want)
12. Mega Man (3.18 in likelihood, 3.79 in want) (Capcom)
13. Roy (3.03 in likelihood, 3.33 in want)
14. Dixie Kong (2.96 in likelihood, 2.67 in want)
15. Krom (2.92 in likelihood, 2.35 in want)
16. Bowser Jr. (2.78 in likelihood, 2.75 in want)
17. Toad (2.74 in likelihood, 2.85 in want)
18. Krystal (2.42 in likelihood, 2.21 in want)
19. Muddy Mole (2.4 in likelihood, 3.03 in want)
20. Starfy (2.32 in likelihood, 2.74 in want)
21. Paper Mario (2.28 in likelihood, 2.88 in want)
22. Mii (2.25 in likelihood, 2 in want)
23. Ghirahim (2.23 in likelihood, 2.77 in want)
24. Waluigi (2.09 in likelihood, 2.2 in want)
25. Dark Samus (1.91 in likelihood, 2.28 in want)
26. Black Shadow (1.72 in likelihood, 1.99 in want)
27. Chibi-Robo (1.63 in likelihood, 2.71 in want)
28. Ray (1.34 in likelihood, 2.94 in want)
29. Lyndis (1.1 in likelihood, 1.93 in want)
30. Plusle & Minun (1.04 in likelihood, 1.12 in want)
31. Geno (0.98 in likelihood, 2.46 in want)
32. Lloyd Irving (0.97 in likelihood, 1.59 in want) (Namco Bandai)
33. Rosalina (0.84 in likelihood, 2.4 in want)
34. Skull Kid (0.64 in likelihood, 2.22 in want)
35. Tom Nook (0.53 in likelihood. 2.04 in want)
36. Sukapon (0.48 in likelihood, 2.18 in want)
37. Anna (0.47 in likelihood, 0.9 in want)
38. Yoshimitsu (0.35 in likelihood, 1.05 in want) (Namco Bandai)[/COLLAPSE]

 

[Deleted member]

Mr. Stevenson:

Want: 2.5
I don't not want him, but don't want him either. Barely even heard of him.

Likelihood: 0.1
A forgettable Retro. I know Sakurai likes to include them, but this one is very obscure to the point that he'd be completely random. At least the Ice Climbers had some recognition prior to Melee.