Project M Social Thread

[j00t]

Have you guys fixed GnW's nair yet? That move was super ******** when I played it.

 

[genkaku]

imo they should remove tv smashes, cos if both players get hit to the cieling and 1 tv smashes they lose even if they mighta died later if it were a star ko

No way. I love those.

 

[Revven]

Have you guys fixed GnW's nair yet? That move was super ******** when I played it.

Yes, we did.

 

[Alex19]

I'm not sure whats been covered but peach's down smash destroys everyone it doesn't have to just be spacies or fast fallers lol

 

[GHNeko]

imo they should remove tv smashes, cos if both players get hit to the cieling and 1 tv smashes they lose even if they mighta died later if it were a star ko

imo ceiling KOs above 100% but below 130% should be TV, anything above 131% should be stars.

if anything, the fact that they're random should be removed simply for removing the random chance that both people or both teams get ceiling KO'd at the same time, the winning person/team isnt decided by chance. -_-

That or slow down the TV KO/speed up the Star KO to be the same as the other.

 

[Archangel]

I'm not sure whats been covered but peach's down smash destroys everyone it doesn't have to just be spacies or fast fallers lol

i don't think they want you posting those things here. People freak out about it.

 

[genkaku]

imo they should remove tv smashes, cos if both players get hit to the cieling and 1 tv smashes they lose even if they mighta died later if it were a star ko

Actually, when is this even going to happen?

 

[Laijin]

I just had the privelidge to try out the current version of this, and I spent most of my time playing young/toon link. There's obviously a bit of controversy over having to mash two different characters together, and I understand that. I just want to help combine two parts and not make those parts clash horribly.

I play young link in melee, and I think the most defining aspect of young link is his projectiles. They rock up damage and are meant to combo into other attacks. You added a lot of young links attacks that those projectiles combo into, but the current toon link projectiles don't do that the same way that young link's do. The arrows especially feel weird with the current moveset. They're slow and straight, menaing easy to avoid, and don't do the right thing when they hit. The bombs don't get thrown as far as they do in melee, and I don't see how making his throwing range better can be a bad thing. His boomerang felt a little weird, but there are a million weird melee properties to it. I guess I felt fine with how it handled for the most part.

I know that you have to cater to toon link too, but projectiles were major to young link's game, and without them a lot of his attacks lose half their viability because they can't be comboed into. I don't know what toon links feel about this, but that's just my standpoint from young link's perspective.

This x192412

From my experience with brawl, I can certainly tell you TL's projectiles are complete trash when compared to YL's(Personal opinion. But a lot of people would agree with me).

It might be easier to just list all of the weird Young Link projectile stuff for them, seeing as how most players are not familiar with Young Link at all. Would this help guys?

 

[Grim Tuesday]

This x192412

From my experience with brawl, I can certainly tell you TL's projectiles are complete trash when compared to YL's(Personal opinion. But a lot of people would agree with me).

It might be easier to just list all of the weird Young Link projectile stuff for them, seeing as how most players are not familiar with Young Link at all. Would this help guys?

I also support this.

 

[TL?]

I like TL's projectiles. I might be wrong here but I almost never see YL's bow put to good use. He seems to be all about bombs and boomerang.

 

[AeonClock]

He should definitely keep his Brawl arrows, but the boomerang needs more speed and control on it.

 

[JCaesar]

Have you guys fixed GnW's nair yet? That move was super ******** when I played it.

Yeah, turns out we had the hitbox out for 15 frames when it was supposed to only be out for 10 (like in Melee). It's fixed now.

Unless you mean the animation glitch. We're still working on that one...

imo ceiling KOs above 100% but below 130% should be TV, anything above 131% should be stars.

if anything, the fact that they're random should be removed simply for removing the random chance that both people or both teams get ceiling KO'd at the same time, the winning person/team isnt decided by chance. -_-

That or slow down the TV KO/speed up the Star KO to be the same as the other.

I'll agree with that.

 

[GameWatching]

i need feedback before i export D:

 

[ds22]

i need feedback before i export D:

Looks astonishing.
Good job.

 

[Revven]

That looks a lot better than your Melee Fox (which by the way I wish you'd fix his nose area). But, I'd still much rather you finish YS or Melee FD before doing anymore Melee-esque models.

 

[I R MarF]

Yeah, GameWatching, how is Yoshi's Story coming along?

 

[GameWatching]

i send it to mewtwo_2000 to fix glitchs and collisions !
he will send it back to me on friday ( i think ) !

cause he have exams D:

 

[I R MarF]

Sounds good GameWatching.

I am now looking forward to Friday.

 

[Sora-kun]

Nice Donkey Kong.

Btw, are you planning on doing melee samus? That would be awesome.

 

[Revven]

There's really not much different between Melee Samus and Brawl Samus other than the shoulder pads... and the color, which there's already a Melee Samus texture on SWF if you look hard enough. Plus, with the models being resized she doesn't look as big or whatever as she did in Brawl...

In other words, there's not much different to justify a model change.

 

[GP&B]

I doubt this would be considered, but have you guys looked at implementing Samus' super sexy 64 Bair? Or is her air game already sufficient enough? Honestly, I've felt that Bair is just not that useful and I end up using Nair more when I went to kill with an aerial.

 

[Revven]

Her Bair is perfectly fine the way it is, it has Melee KB so it is plenty useful if you hit with the sweetspot.

 

[ZeroUnderOne]

What is the stance/tolerance on chain grabs? Seems like space animals/fast fallers still get chained by pika till about 50% with forward throw.

 

[Revven]

What is the stance/tolerance on chain grabs? Seems like space animals/fast fallers still get chained by pika till about 50% with forward throw.

Pika forward throw (and all throws in general) have remained unchanged right now (except a select few) so there's no real defined stance on it yet because throws (in Brawl) are generally ******** and don't work right compared to Melee.

Phew, you guys ask a lot of questions.

 

[GP&B]

Her Bair is perfectly fine the way it is, it has Melee KB so it is plenty useful if you hit with the sweetspot.

Excellent. I felt like even sweetspotting it in Brawl+ was a joke compared to a fresh Nair which came out near-instantly and was much safer.

 

[DaAnimeKidTooch]

do they have any gameplay of toon link out yet?,i have been wondering how he is in p:m,a melee toon link,a copy of young link,are a mixture of both

edit:or a mixture of both,grammar error

 

[ZeroUnderOne]

Pika forward throw (and all throws in general) have remained unchanged right now (except a select few) so there's no real defined stance on it yet because throws (in Brawl) are generally ******** and don't work right compared to Melee.

Phew, you guys ask a lot of questions.

You're awesome for the rapid fire responses

 

[GP&B]

do they have any gameplay of toon link out yet?,i have been wondering how he is in p:m,a melee toon link,a copy of young link,are a mixture of both

edit:or a mixture of both,grammar error

He's a hybrid, but I think a ton of things about him are WIP.

 

[SymphonicSage12]

He's a hybrid, but I think a ton of things about him are WIP.

Dude did you read higher up the page? They were just talking about his hybrid-ness :X

 

[GameWatching]

these are huge difference between Melee DK and Brawl one ôo

 

[FireBall Stars]

The ears are a little odd gamewatching. But still, impressively accurate

The DKs only got better (in design) after each smash IMO. Brawl DK is great.

 

[Sneak8288]

Yea.. i still stand by brawls dk look and colors

 

[GP&B]

Dude did you read higher up the page? They were just talking about his hybrid-ness :X

Tell that to DaAnimeKidTooch, he's the one who asked. I just answered him >_>.
Unless you meant something else.

 

[Sora-kun]

There's really not much different between Melee Samus and Brawl Samus other than the shoulder pads... and the color, which there's already a Melee Samus texture on SWF if you look hard enough. Plus, with the models being resized she doesn't look as big or whatever as she did in Brawl...

In other words, there's not much different to justify a model change.

Oh, ok. My bad.

 

[CheeseBurger]

brawl dk

melee fox falco

 

[I R MarF]

If I remember correctly it was Strong Bad who asked GameWatching to make the Melee DK.

Still, I think it would be cool if every veteran character had an optional melee outfit that replaced one of their non-team releated color swaps sometime down the road. (With the exception of Pikachu because he only has 4)

 

[ConnorTheKid]

I really hate the way Brawl Kirby looks. Do you think you could work on making a Melee Kirby next please?

 

[NAMQ_DrunkeNFeasT]

I heard the greatest Project in this section of Brawl discussion found a way to crack the Melee .iso :O

what stuff were craked out? only the characters attributes?


how further would craking the .iso be helpful?

and can hitboxes be found if further research been done?


if all that could be figured out, perfect top tiers, high and middle tiers can truly return, and low tiers can keep their good stuff and get buffed to match some others.


Great Work Project M Staff

 

[GHNeko]

They ported all the melee character physics 100% from cracking **** from Melee. :V

They play identical gravity/physics wise and the only reason they'd feel off is because of landing detection.

 

[Archangel]

If I remember correctly it was Strong Bad who asked GameWatching to make the Melee DK.

Still, I think it would be cool if every veteran character had an optional melee outfit that replaced one of their non-team releated color swaps sometime down the road. (With the exception of Pikachu because he only has 4)

I think it's a good idea.