Jem.
Smash Master
omfg i love good charlotte they r better than any band cuz they r more popularzzzzz
here's the thing: when you say the prime of melee, you mean competitive melee. the prime that you need to compare with brawl's current popularity is melee's popularity right after release in 01/02.
either way, brawl is a worse game than melee, easily. sakurai made sure to put effort into making brawl bad for competitive play, whereas in melee, he just made the game the best he could without moderating his ideas since competitive smash wasn't really that popular around that time.
The games tournament atmosphere kicked off in 03 as far as Im concerned, and was at its competitive prime (most people attending events) until 05-06. Most people that play today though didnt even play before 05 so you wouldnt know.
Stop saying brawl is worse, LOL. Get good at the game, it still takes skill to be good and win, as does every game. I could even argue about poker, but, there is no point in causing a flame war.