NJ Finder - Tournament Finder Updated (10/8) See new thread for Brawl Rankings

[teh_spamerer]

Knock off Halberd and it's great even though I think PS2 is fine. Oh and make BF the only neutral, the rest are bogus

 

[★J.G WentWorth★]

About Frigate. If you are on a certain part of the Stage while it flips you die. So just be in the air when it flips. The stages warns you when it's about to flip. It doesn't cause any damage percent wise. I really don't think Frigate should be banned at least not yet.

 

[Inui]

I'd much rather have frigate in than brinstar but to be honest, even though the list is restricting I think it's much better that way.

What reason is there to ban Brinstar? There's nothing ridiculous or game-breaking there.

Knock off Halberd and it's great even though I think PS2 is fine. Oh and make BF the only neutral, the rest are bogus

What's bad about Halberd? The stage "hazzards" are very slow and predictable and very easy to avoid.

About Frigate. If you are on a certain part of the Stage while it flips you die. So just be in the air when it flips. The stages warns you when it's about to flip. It doesn't cause any damage percent wise. I really don't think Frigate should be banned at least not yet.

The fact that such things can happen and decide matches means the stage warrants a ban.

 

[Kaiber Kop]

Your reasoning to spam about halberd is why I don't exactly see why you would ban frigate. Yeah it has the ability to kill at 0% but they have a warning signal blaring when its gonna happen. I cant see how anyone would really die at zero there on a constant basis.

Brinstar has lava which I would consider more of a hazard than a stage flipping once in a while. It restricts play to platforms only at certain points so if your character doesnt have good aerials to compete with your opponent, I dont really see any options....

In the end it's your tourny and decision so I don't care either way but thats just my view I was giving

 

[MalcolmM]

so ban halbred then....oh wait thats ur counterpick half the time so ofc u wouldnt ban it. if the criteria is "things can happen and decide matche means the stage warrants a ban" then halbred deserves to go.

i always cp neutrals...im just saying banning every stage because u lose on it to ppl you feel u shouldnt...isnt legit.

 

[teh_spamerer]

What's bad about Halberd? The stage "hazzards" are very slow and predictable and very easy to avoid.

That's like saying the klaptrap on Jungle Japes is predictable. Yeah it comes around at the same time every time so why are you banning it? All the hazards can be exploited. You can TRIP into them. If ZSS dsmashes you into them you get *****. Her double dsmash locks you into the charged laser for all the hits. Speaking of the charged laser the last hit extends the hitbox beyond that initial circle to god knows how much and has retardedly strong knockback. The klaw took away every possible option Azen had in the 2v1 he played you guys in. If you're off stage when the stage goes down the camera will probably screw you because the ledge and the stage is not where you think it is. You can get chaingrabbed by someone into a hazard and die while they live because of controller port garbage.

 

[Alex Strife]

JJ and halberd are not comparable lol

-m2k

 

[NJzFinest]

I have both. Double dash is by farrrr the better game.

False .

 

[Alex Strife]

double dash was fun

-m2k

 

[Max Ketchum]

Wow, Frigate is definitely not banworthy at all. Being in the air prevents stage shenanigans entirely. You won't die off the top unless you're standing on a very specific part of the stage. If anything, leave Frigate on and give two bans. Maybe even allow both Rainbow AND Frigate. The only people who would really counterpick Rainbow most of the time are MK players, and with two bans you can get rid of it right off the bat.

Frigate favors characters with better recovery, yes...but isn't that the point of a counterpick? You're not gonna see something stupid like a Bowser or Falco player counterpicking that, which would make the stage's stupid bull**** come into effect. I strongly disagree with banning Frigate, but I really don't care about Rainbow. It has its stupid shenanigans (they're really not that bad, though) and stuff. Honestly, Frigate is less hazardous than Halberd...Snake alone makes Halberd crazier. Hurr hurr, I hit you with my god tilt and you died at 80%. While you were busy avoiding my crotch of ******ry, you were also paying attention to a claw/laser/bomb. Btw, my good friend MK can camp the hell out of the underside of the floating platform! :D

 

[Steel]

Wow, Frigate is definitely not banworthy at all. Being in the air prevents stage shenanigans entirely.

This, if you just jump you're always safe.

 

[_Yes!_]

Green Hill Zone is neutral.

 

[bajisci]

while ur at it, make lylat a counterpick :D

 

[_Yes!_]

The badger speaks the truth.

while ur at it, make lylat a counterpick :D

yoshi's too :D

 

[Max Ketchum]

Yoshi's is gross.

 

[★J.G WentWorth★]

Yoshi's is gross.

Yea I still have no idea why sakurai put all those dikcs in the bushes. The shy guys are staring at them maaad hard. And the Clouds in the sky are happy that they're there. What is this world coming to? ;/

No homo lol.

 

[Max Ketchum]

All homo intended.

 

[_Yes!_]

yoshi's is trash. green hill zone is more fair than that stage.

 

[★J.G WentWorth★]

WarioWare is fairer lol

 

[_Yes!_]

no i'm being serious dude. ghz should be legal. if you're dumb enough to pick a character that gets cg'd, AND you get grabbed, you deserve to be cg'd across the stage. surriously everyone in this **** state mains metaknight or ddd anyway so i don't see what the problem is.

 

[bajisci]

im the only one that likes yoshi's island >:|

 

[Inui]

Wow, Frigate is definitely not banworthy at all. Being in the air prevents stage shenanigans entirely.

I played Keitaro in tourny back in the summer on that stage.

He was in the air when it flipped.

He died.

I won because of the stage, not me outplaying him.

Yesterday in doubles, Bum was in the air when the stage flipped, and he died.

I don't see why people are debating it. I'm a stubborn elitist person. You're not going to change my mind because I've seen those stages win matches instead of players since the start of Brawl. I'm tired of it. They're gone. Don't like it, don't show up. I don't know what else to say. I hope the absense of ******** stages doesn't cause you to miss out on the best tournaments in the state.

APEX is going to keep them on, but have two stage bans.

 

[Keitaro]

I was stupid though so it was my fault

And I'm still stupid cause I forgot what to do when it's going to flip.

Do I stay on the stage or jump? The physics of that stage suck balls.

 

[Inui]

Well, some people just said "stay in the air and you're fine" but they are obviously very wrong since I've seen people die in the air plenty of times.

Btw, I kinda just banned MK's two best counterpicks, so I hope people don't dare accuse me of bias based on my characters or some crap, lol.

 

[_Yes!_]

Well, some people just said "stay in the air and you're fine" but they are obviously very wrong since I've seen people die in the air plenty of times.

Btw, I kinda just banned MK's two best counterpicks, so I hope people don't dare accuse me of bias based on my characters or some crap, lol.

you banned two good rob stages so now chibo won't come to your events

 

[Keitaro]

SQUIRTLE CUUUUMMM!!!!! *presses b button*

 

[★J.G WentWorth★]

That Avi gooo harddd

 

[Max Ketchum]

I'm gonna extensively test Frigate's flipping. If it kills me when I'm in the air, I'll agree with its ban. I'm still gonna come to your tournaments, of course, but like...I really disagree with banning that stage.

 

[Inui]

I'm sorry, but I've seen it kill a lot with people in the air. The results of your testing aren't going to change my mind. Keitaro even just said it happened to him, which it did, in a tournament match with me.

 

[Turbo Ether]

So many stages banned, lol. I still like Mario Circuit and Pictochat, old school.

 

[Max Ketchum]

Meh. I guess I'm just gonna pick Brinstar from now on.

****ing Metroid and its silly stages.

 

[Snakeee]

Inui you might as well make it FD and Battlefield only at this point dammit. Now, I have like 0 good stages for my character left. What's ironic is ZSS is probably the worst on the neutrals compared to counterpicks >_>

 

[teh_spamerer]

I like Mario Circuit and Green Hill Zone

KDJ is amaaaaaazing: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vNbgyMBt8LM&feature=related

 

[Inui]

Inui you might as well make it FD and Battlefield only at this point dammit. Now, I have like 0 good stages for my character left. What's ironic is ZSS is probably the worst on the neutrals compared to counterpicks >_>

Nah. I don't see too much wrong with the other stages at this point. The acid damage on Brinstar is trivial and the acid actually stops stalling a lot. Brinstar's actually LESS gay now because you can't really death combo off of it. Castle Seige is probably the gayest stage left...and I've yet to see it break gameplay or cause too much nonsense.

ZSS is still really good at Lylat Cruise.

 

[Snakeee]

Lylat isn't even really good for her, only against certain characters. She can't even grab on that stage -_- .

 

[Inui]

Since when is grabbing a big part of ZSS's game?

How is she not good on FD?

You're telling me that the absense of Rainbow Cruise has destroyed you?

Come on, Frank......

 

[Snakeee]

Since when is grabbing a big part of ZSS's game?

How is she not good on FD?

You're telling me that the absense of Rainbow Cruise has destroyed you?

Come on, Frank......

I hate FD bc ZSS is much better with platforms (plus it makes me have to camp harder and have a boring match), I need to grab once in a while to mix things up, and RC was a very strong counter against certain characters. RC was always allowed in Melee, and now it's banned with minimal differences???

Oh and ZSS' grab is actually very good for shield grabbing ranged attacks, or grabbing people out of the air sometimes

 

[Turbo Ether]

Delfino is at least as gay as Castle Siege.

 

[teh_spamerer]

Delfino is at least as gay as Castle Siege.

Delfino isn't gay

 

[Inui]

RC was always allowed in Melee, and now it's banned with minimal differences???

Minimal differences?

In all my years of playing Melee, I've never seen RC consistently win matches instead of the players.