An idea I've been thinking about for a while, what do you think the roster would be like if it was made by the Capcom VS team? We get so caught up on "this character is necessary" or "this character deserves to be in the most", I think it'd be nice to try and take a different perspective for once.
What I mean is, while smash tends to go for the 'perfect' roster (characters that have proven staying power and are representative of their series), Capcom Vs games usually go for whatever makes for a fun and interesting roster for that particular game, which means a lot more strange inclusions and a much more rotating cast than smash ever has.
Some weird decisions capcom vs games have had:
-Megaman, despite being the company mascot, has only been in 2 VS titles. The megaman series is most often represented by spin off characters, Like Zero and Tron Bon. Roll is playable in 2 vs games despite only ever being playable in a bonus mode of a psp remake of the first megaman game. This would basically be like if Mario wasn't in smash and instead the series was represented by Paper Luigi and Fawful.
-Black Widow was considered for MVC3, but was cut due to "too many gun people". Hagar and Zangeif can't be in the same game because their both big grappler guys. Capcom games tend to prioritize aesthetically different character archetypes in their roster, even if they mechanically play differently, so I'm sure the swordie haters are happy with this one.
-Several franchises are represented either solely by the main villain, or the main villain got in ages before their actual protagonist. Shuma Gorath before Dr Strange, Dr Doom without the Fantastic 4, Blackheard before Daredevil. Like if Skull Kid got in before Link, or Dark Matter without Kirby.
-They couldnt pick just one Fantastic 4 character for the roster, so they just used Super Skrull because he could copy all of them. Like if they couldn't pick just one Pokemon, so they added Ditto and he turned into every pokemon. Aditionally, when they had trouble getting the rights to Iron Man, they just used War Machine because he looks exactly like Iron Man but gray.
-Cyberbots, the series about giant fighting robots, is represented by one of the robot pilots and he has a completely original moveset. The closest equevalent i can think of is saying "Olimar is too small, so pikmin will be represented by a playable SS Drake".
-MVC2 just had 3 totally made up characters. One is a cut Darkstalkers character and the others are rumored to be (by me), so like imagine if WaPeach just got into the next smash basically.
-Bone Claw Wolverine... i guess this isnt too differant from Young Link, actually.
-Judging by how Darkstalkers gets treated by capcom... if you are a hot lady you are 10x more likely to get into crossover rosters.