Say if echoes were still a thing next game and we got some more, who do you think are no brainers?
for me:
- if Joker returns, Violet. There is at least precedence with the Jane in Joker’s DLC file string that had a ponytail
- Jin Kazama as a Ken-style Kazuya echo
- Octoling, though they could also pass as a semi clone
- Ninjara as a Min Min echo maybe, we don’t have a male echo for a female original fighter yet. If you wanna go semi-clone instead of full echo I’d pick Dr. Coyle
- Roxas as a Sora echo if Disney’s willing to play ball for an echo
Disagree on Violet and Roxas because imo they are far far too different to make as an echo of their respective bases. Maybe a semi clone but I think that is pushing it. Jane stuff was likely worked on much earlier, since there is evidence that originally Violet would have been a FeMC instead of just a party member in Royal but this was scrapped in development.
If I had to name a few free echoes, here is what I would go with.
- Dixie Kong
- Octoling
- Black Shadow
- Impa
- Ninten
- Medusa
- Shadow
- Ms Pac Man
Jin wouldn't work as an Echo, as of now at least. I know Tekken 3 is a thing, but that's the only game (well that and Tag 1, which is not canon game) where Jin uses the Mishima Fighting style. It's literally a big story element that Jin forgoes the Mishima Fighting style due to the people associated with that Style. This is also the major reason for Devil Jin's existence, to have Jin's Tekken 3 moveset without messing up his Story arc
I feel like that's also a Main reason Jin wasn't chosen as a rep. You would have to make 2 different movesets for Jin/Devil Jin, to have both Jin's Current style and the Classic Mishima fighting style with Devil Jin
Now Tekken 8 might change it up.
The ending has Jin seeming to at least embrace his Devil State somewhat. so we might see Jin actually revert back to using his old style willingly. If that's the case, I could see the arguement for Jin being some sort of Echo being more possible, though honestly I think he'd be more of a Semi-Clone probably.
Roxas could work, but you would have to forgo the Dual wielding aspect, which is one of the most Iconic parts of the character. Nomura would also have to agree to forgo the lack of it
Black Shadow could work, kind of. I think he'd have a Blend of Falcon and Ganondorf's Moveset, but I think his Speed would be similiar to Falcon. I believe the Black Bull is faster than the Blue Falcon, so that could apply here also. That seems overpowered though unless they gave him a Crippling weakness
Octoling seems like the most Shoo-in Potential echo here, though I could see them also just as an Alt of Inkling as well. The thing is that Inkling only uses Splatoon 1 weapons in this game, so unless Smash 6 gives extra Specials to characters, I Imagine they want those weapons to be represented somewhere, and that could require different balancing, but maybe not. At the least, I see Octoling sharing the Same Physical normals like Tilts and Aerials
Ms Pac-Man honestly could just be an alt. I don't think she has shown off that much difference to even warrent being an echo. I believe Ms Pac-Man the game was Faster, and also harder, so you could have her be faster, but harder to kill with compared to Pac-Man, but I don't think it's needed
If Dixie really was a shoo-in for an Echo spot, I Imagine she would already be in. I can't imagine her being less of a priority than Dark Samus, no offense. It always seemed Dixie was a bigger request, and Japan would be more familiar with Donkey Kong Country anyway than Metroid, along with also appeasing the West
If her Upgraded Spirit is any indication, Sakurai might try to attempt the Duo idea that was originally planned for Diddy and Dixie, and have Dixie be a Duo character with another Kong, perhaps Kiddy like in DKC3
Similiar deal goes with Shadow. I know Sonic was at a rough patch during 2015-2016 when Ultimate started development, and Japan really isn't the most keen on Sonic as a franchise, but Sonic still is an Iconic franchise, Shadow had been a requested character even before Ultimate (But Ultimate was where he really blew up) and SA2 is the Highest Selling Sonic game in Japan along with SA1, and the Most well-regarded game there. That's a big deal since Sonic games aren't the biggest there
If they wanted to Make Shadow an Echo, they would have. The fact that they didn't likely showcases that Shadow, while he theoretically could echo Sonic, wouldn't get in as an Echo.
I know I was very Adamant about Shadow getting in as an unique character throughout the entirity of Ultimate's Lifecycle. I crashed and burned in terms of this game, but the thing Is I know he will become playable in the future, it's only a matter of time, and the fact this was the supposed perfect opportunity to add him as an echo and they didn't kind of proves that he would have more to him the Shadowing Sonic's Moveset