Okay, going through the thread.
Still cool with Gargaglione as town. Sure, he was being pri silly to begin with but when he did say relevant things, they were good.
Some of Shadow Moth's early posts are really bleh. So flip floppy and non-commital.
Cool with early BPC too.
Eh, Panta doesn't look as bad as I thought. His case on BPC was ugly but nothing else is particularly noteable. Howeverrr, nothing is notably good either. Pretty much a non-presence. Earned my suspicions, but not a priority.
Acrostic definetely an improvement over SM. Some bleh things, but not a priority either.
WK's push on SW is really bleh, seems so non-comittal in the way he's carrying out, but he's been sticking with it so hard. Like, I don't remember any of his other stances.
Non-presences always suck.
If you were mafia and put at L-1 would you attack the swing vote in that manner? As scum he would be trying to appease me but as town he might try and hold onto the scumKuz read in an attempt to get me lynched after his flip. Do you disagree with this?
Bleh.
As scum, wouldn't suddenly flipping your stance from ScumKuz to TownKuz when they hold the hammer look horribly artificial and suspiciously co-incidental? There's no natural way WK could have changed his stance on Kuz over a few posts. Could not care less for this reason for WK town and I'm not seeing anything else that shows WK to be town.
Now things get interesting. The Phoenix wagon. First off:
I don't understand why so many people are worried about Pheonix being in LYLO. We're not even close to that. He'll be replaced before he even gets in there.
Ding Ding Ding!
SW is right. Inactivity as the reason for a lynch on D1 is just silly. You're relying on chance that they are scum, and odds are they aren't. If they are, great, you got lucky. If they flip town, in D2 you've got the same amount of information as D1, but with one less townie.
Unvote, Vote: Phoenix
Werekill seems to be somewhat innocent, we have no reads, and lynching Phoenix will provide us with some information, plus he's ****ing useless at this point. The deadline is tomorrow and we have nothing to go on.
@BPC: What is this information you'd get on my flip? Where would you look on my town and scum flip?
Honestly? We won't get too many reads on other people, unless he flips scum. If he's scum, anyone who didn't want him lynched is gonna look worse, but it really won't be enough to base a lynch over.
I really just want to get rid of him so that we don't have him as a liability in LYLO.
Right. So it's policy. In other words, if he's town or scum it doesn't matter because either way he is hurting reads by being non-involved.
Bleh bleh bleh bleh bleh.
Werekill the Pheonix wagon is complete BS. I don't like the way people are hopping on him for very little reason at all other than his inactivity. If he goes completely inactive then he will be replaced.
bpc and Kooz have yet to explain their reasoning for getting on that all the sudden.
Thumbs up. Zen's non presence early on really got to me, but his push on SW looked genuine and I like the above post.
Then there's the "scumslip" from SW. SW remains town, but I don't think anyone looks particularly bad for pushing her there.
Pretty much caught up. Question time!
Don't really like the recent posts by BPC either.
@Kuz: Why?
Do you have any reasoning for WK town besides the hammer vote point?
@Acrostic: You seem to be a bit all over the place recently. Why? Who would you be fine with lynching toDay?
@Mod: replacing the nost likely lynch right before deadline? Not cool.
@WereKill: What do you mean by this? I don't think I understand.
A SW lynch is not viable now. Too many people have her as town. You can keep pushing it all you like in D2, but toDay? Not happening. If your only issue with me is my inactivity, and my slot is now going to be active for the rest of the game, where are you going to look now?
Remind me of your read on Panta, Zen and BPC please.
@Panta Do you feel a BPC lynch could happen toDay?
If so, convince us.
If not, move your vote somewhere useful. Who's most likely scum between myself, WK and SW? Why?
@Gargalione Where you at?
I would favour a WK lynch toDay. At a stretch I'd take Panta and Acrostic over a No Lynch. Everyone else is good for toDay.
