Oh, yes. Smashchu. And that's because Karate Joe excites people more than Ryu ever would. Strange how out of touch you are, indeed.
Did you not read anything I just said. I know why Golden had a problem. You need this spelt out for you. Let's go back
That's nice and all Arcadenik, but what you neglect is Karate Joe is a NINTENDO character and Golden is suggesting for the NINTENDO ALL-STAR fighting game.
First, note how I mention karate Joe as a Nintendo character. I'm putting him in one class.
Ryu is a third party character. Another class. So
Karate Joe: Nintendo Character
Ryu:Third party character
Sakruai doesn't try to flood the game with third party characters.
Alright, so we know Ryu is a third party character, and Sakurai doesn't flood the game with them. What does that mean?
He doesn't look at Karate Joe and say, you know what, let me put Ryu in instead.
OK, so Sakurai doesn't pick one or the other.
Think of it like this. Dixie and K Rool are both DK characters right? But does that mean Sakurai has to chose one or the other. But what if he added Crock man. Does that mean K Rool can't get in. Can Megaman not get in if ROB is in.
What I'm saying is this. It's not one or the other. We can have both, one, or none. SAKURAI DOES NOT LOOK AT THIS IN A POLAR WAY. (I hope you know what Polar means)
He tries not to over do it. He is careful of who he adds and makes sure that the character getting in will excite players. Notice how Brawl had only two
So here is where it gets complicated So Sakurai treats third party and Nintendo characters differently. We know that third parties are limited and the game will not have a lot of them. So than we get to here.
There are a lot of third party characters people want and we can't add too many. So we must
prioritize. We must be choosy (spelling?). So, would Ryu excite people more than Megaman? Probably not. We could even have Simon or Layton. People like them. So if we have limited space, we must be careful.
With that in mind (and the fact that third parties are different) why would we add Ryu just because we could add him over Karate Joe. Why not have our cake and eat it too. Let's add Megaman, who people really like, and Karate Joe, so he have a karate dude. Hey, win/win
This should make sense now. I over explained a paragraph.