New Smash Bros for WiiU

[Lukingordex]

Even as a devoted fan of the masked man and the mother franchise itself, i don't think adding a second character from mother 3 would work too well considering we already have lucas, which i personally believe we were LUCKY enough to get in brawl.

I agree,I have only said that if a mother 3 character needs to enter,Claus is a better option than the Masked Man.

 

[Shorts]

Well, you saying anything about Krystal would be wrong Golden, especially if you're going after her, a legitimate candidate when we have a good 10 or so who have no chance in hell.

Cuts so far are:
Captain Syrup
Medusa
Mona (2)
Bandana Dee (2)
Black Shadow (2)
Black Mage (2)

Make up YOUR mind on who you think should be cut, Ike or Krom...

And, I would rather LOSE some third parties, not add.

Considering additions:
Victini
Geno

Sometimes I forget that I'm dealing with the general public, not the DG...

 

[Lukingordex]

Not like you're going to notice how his hair is on the "wrong side" while you're playing...

And seriously? Calling him beautiful is wrong on so many levels. I'm talking pedophilliac levels.

The malice is in your head.
The fact that I´m saying that a person is bealtiful means I am a pedophile?

 

[grizby2]

I'd cut:

Mona: I really don't see Wario getting another rep, but if he does I'd rather have Syrup.

Bandana Dee: Kirby is complete imo.

Black Shadow: Samurai Goroh is my F-Zero pick,and it probably won't get three reps.

Black Mage: Keep FF away from Smash.

I think Geno is a worthy add, as he isn't really hated here. No biggie though

i am conspiring in consensus with yani.

 

[yani]

I'm going to say cut Krom. Ike was a starter in Brawl, and he wasn't a clone either. I don't think Sakurai would cut the character IS wanted in the game. I also see Roy coming back because it doesn't make sense to only have one Melee returnee (assuming Mewtwo comes back). Bye bye Krom.

 

[Deleted member]

I agree,I have only said that if a mother 3 character needs to enter,Claus is a better option than the Masked Man.

Claus IS the Masked Man, though. So how could he be a better option than himself?

Well, you saying anything about Krystal would be wrong Golden, especially if you're going after her, a legitimate candidate when we have a good 10 or so who have no chance in hell.

Cuts so far are:
Captain Syrup
Medusa
Mona (2)
Bandana Dee (2)
Black Shadow (2)
Black Mage (2)

Make up YOUR mind on who you think should be cut, Ike or Krom...

And, I would rather LOSE some third parties, not add.

Considering additions:
Victini
Geno

Sometimes I forget that I'm dealing with the general public, not the DG...

Lol, the typical "I <3 Krystal, so if you say anything other than 'she is the most deserving character ever and is the best StarFox character known to man and to dolphins', you are wrong." crap. Never change, Shortie, never change. Even though Krystal is one of those characters with no chance in Hell and is hardly a legitimate choice.
So if it's my choice, cut Ike. and follow suit by adding Micaiah, so that we still have a character to represent Tellius that is a "main" character, and a character that doesn't use a sword.

 

[Shorts]

My cut list:

Syrup - Sakurai doesn't care about Wario Land... end of reasoning

Masked Man - Such an up in the air choice... we really dont know how Sakurai feels about him... and I have a feeling we will never know.


@Golden^^^ A reason why most legitimate posters don't take you seriously.

 

[Lukingordex]

Claus IS the Masked Man, though. So how could he be a better option than himself?

Yeah,but The Masked Man will be more cool if he becomes a Claus´s final smash.

And Claus will fight without his masked man clothes,until he gets a smash ball.
(Can be something like Wario´s final smash)

 

[Big-Cat]

- Tingle
- Sheik
- Waddle Dee - I honestly don't care though.
- Black Shadow - I feel that, if he's made unique, he'd be another K. Rool.
- Zoroark
- Claus
- Mii - I just really hate the idea of Miis being a character.

Neutral: I'm meh with the excess third parties, but I'd cut Bomberman and Pacman in exchange for a Moogle-Chocobo team.

+ Impa - In her own slot.
+ Meowth
+ Sheeda - She seems cool. What can I say?
+ Kumatora - Ironically, I think she has more potential to be unique compared to Claus.

Kudos for putting in Tom Nook.

 

[Deleted member]

The malice is in your head.
The fact that I´m saying that a person is bealtiful means I am a pedophile?

You're calling a cartoonish kid beautiful. A cartoonish boy, I might add. Kind of speaks for itself. It's as wierd as saying Bowser is sexy. Do you think Bowser is sexy?

 

[Big-Cat]

You're calling a cartoonish kid beautiful. A cartoonish boy, I might add. Kind of speaks for itself. It's as wierd as saying Bowser is sexy. Do you think Bowser is sexy?

He's a Big Beautiful Man, at least that's how he sees himself.

 

[Deleted member]

My cut list:

Syrup - Sakurai doesn't care about Wario Land... end of reasoning

Masked Man - Such an up in the air choice... we really dont know how Sakurai feels about him... and I have a feeling we will never know.


@Golden^^^ A reason why most legitimate posters don't take you seriously.

Why, because I have a differnt view on Krystal than you do?
Sounds like you are salty that I didn't praise the almighty blue breasted space fox.

 

[Shorts]

Sure, Golden, yes.

 

[Lukingordex]

You're calling a cartoonish kid beautiful. A cartoonish boy, I might add. Kind of speaks for itself.

What the problem on it?
If that is true,we have a lot of pedophile girls who think cartoonish kids are beaultiful.

 

[Conviction]

He makes seem as if the hair to wrong side is as a big deal as Sonic's quill difference, size, and eye color from Classic to Modern.

 

[Deleted member]

Sure, Golden, yes.

I bet if I showed you a video of me fapping to Krystal porn, you'd praise me as you would a long lost brother.

 

[grizby2]

What the problem on it?

cartoonish characters are not allowed to be "sexy" or "beautiful"

this means
peach
Zsamus
palutena
zelda....
.........impa

 

[Shorts]

Okay, at five I will stop counting votes and start the cutting process!

 

[Lukingordex]

cartoonish characters are not allowed to be "sexy" or "beautiful"

this means
peach
Zsamus
palutena
zelda....
.........impa

Congratulations,you have the post of the month.

 

[Conviction]

Come off it, what people's opinions on how they view a character (even if not normally socially acceptable) doesn't change the character itself.

In other words, find something else to argue about. Your're not making a good case if you attack the most subjective of points that hold no weight.

 

[Metal Overlord]

"Most legitimate people don't take Golden seriously"

wut

 

[Deleted member]

What the problem on it?
If that is true,we have a lot of pedophile girls who think cartoonish kids are beaultiful.

You don't get it; they go after the "pretty boys" like Sora, Pit, Marth, etc.

This:

Hardly constitues as a "pretty boy". It'd be like calling Mickey Mouse beautiful.

 

[Big-Cat]

What are we arguing about again?

 

[Conviction]

You don't get it; they go after the "pretty boys" like Sora, Pit, Marth, etc.

This:

Hardly constitues as a "pretty boy". It'd be like calling Mickey Mouse beautiful.

Come off it, what people's opinions on how they view a character (even if not normally socially acceptable) doesn't change the character itself.

In other words, find something else to argue about. Your're not making a good case if you attack the most subjective of points that hold no weight.

"Most legitimate people don't take Golden seriously"

wut

You'll be surprised at how most think about a specific person even if not made public 24/7 like Diddy.

Don't worry about it.

@Kuma: Idk, it is slowly dissolving in which pixel or animation looks better in one's eye. Remember this one's eyes are correct from all the others.

 

[Deleted member]

"Most legitimate people don't take Golden seriously"

wut

Pay no mind, Metal. All I am to him is a Krystal hater, which is worse than a Nazi that ***** little children and their puppies.

EDIT: Quit trying to White Knight, Iblis, this doesn't concern you.

 

[grizby2]

You don't get it; they go after the "pretty boys" like Sora, Pit, Marth, etc.

This:

Hardly constitues as a "pretty boy". It'd be like calling Mickey Mouse beautiful.

hey, link started out as 8-bit and look where HE's on in the "pretty" boy list.

but we should be discussing on who to cut from our "roster game" list.

 

[Conviction]

EDIT: Quit trying to White Knight, Iblis, this doesn't concern you.

Quit trying to dismiss me as if I don't have a right to post. I'll concern myself with what I want.

Here, I'll tell you this. Don't complain about how terribad the thread can get if you are unwilling to let go of "beauty is in the eye of the beholder", an opinionated matter that really won't help a character's chance.

 

[Xhampi]

In this case I will begin to defend Bandanna Dee ^^

He can easily become an important character of the Kirby series in the future and being a playable character in SSB4 can be a huge help to this.

He can represent the whole Waddle Dee specie who have been here since the very beggining of the Kirby series, specie who have many roles in Kirby games : Common foe, Helper or even Playable characters. They have basically the roles of the Toads and the Goombas of the Mario series.

He can also give us a Spear user, something that no character have done this far.

Out of the subject i made a list for the similiraties between Toad and Waddle Dee
-Both are here since the beggining of the series.
-Both are generic species with one prominent being.
-Both appear in nearly every game of their series.
-Both have been playable in a main stream game and a spinoff.
-Both serve royalty.
-Both have been use as a move in a super smash bros.
-Both have been use as a helper for the hero.
-Both are able to use spear (remember Paper Mario).
IT'S A CONSPIRACY, A CONSPIRACY.

 

[Deleted member]

1. I never complained how "terribad" the thread can get.
2. This has nothing to do with Claus' chances.

So I'll tell you this. before you concern yourself with what you want, make sure you know what your're talking about.

And that is the last that will be said of this discussion.

 

[Conviction]

*sigh*

I have to repeat myself. Arguing his "looks" doesn't have anything to do with his chances. My main point.

Carry on.

 

[Metal Overlord]

I guess this place really is more like high school than I thought

 

[Deleted member]

*sigh*

I have to repeat myself. Arguing his "looks" doesn't have anything to do with his chances. My main point.

Carry on.

Read point number 2 again, because clearly you ignore what I say on the basis that I "can't be taken seriously". This had nothing to do with his chances from the getgo, so repeating that fact is pointless.

 

[Lukingordex]

Claus/the masked man chances are something like 0,0001%,so let´s discuss another thing.

NOT IMPA,please.

 

[Shorts]

And just like that, the first seven have been cut.

Mona: She may actually be the only legitimate Wario choice listed for SSB4, but in our perfect world, it seem Syrup is just preferred. So, for now, Syrup is our last stand for a Wario newcomer. Let's see how long that lasts.

Black Shadow: Is viewed by us as just, clone material, and unlikely..? so We dropped him.

Black Mage: Had multiple votes against him, because people don't like final fantasy

Bandana Dee: People feel the Kirby series is "complete"

Pac-Man: We needed to clean out the third party pen, and he was the first blood.

Bomberman: He only had one vote to cut him, but I felt like instead of cutting Krom, an actual contender, we should cut Bomberman... because he will never be in Smash.. we don't even know if he has a future in gaming period.

Masked Man: Has a big ? over him it seems like, and the arguing is annoying, so he's out.

From now on, I want LEGITIMATE PARAGRAPHS about characters you want cut. Give you reasoning for why. I can't judge too well based off of votes anymore. So write up a paragraph per character.

If someone writes about a character you want to stay, feel free to give me reasons WHY THEY SHOULD BE KEPT.

Lastly, if you want characters to be added, WRITE WHY THEY SHOULD BE ADDED. None of the paragraphs have to be forever long, but three or four telling sentences does wonders for me. It gives me more grounds for cutting, other than just "Three people wrote this name down.. so"

No more lists. We've cut the fat, now we need some reasons behind your cuts. Thanks~

 

[Deleted member]

I guess this place really is more like high school than I thought

To be young again...

 

[Metal Mania1321]

Edit: Ignore this ****

 

[Conviction]

I wanted to do this in the beginning.

*sigh*

I have to repeat myself. Arguing his "looks" doesn't have anything to do with his chances. My main point.
Carry on.

Quit trying to dismiss me as if I don't have a right to post. I'll concern myself with what I want.

Here, I'll tell you this. Don't complain about how terribad the thread can get if you are unwilling to let go of "beauty is in the eye of the beholder", an opinionated matter that really won't help a character's chance.

Read point number 2 again, because clearly you ignore what I say on the basis that I "can't be taken seriously". This had nothing to do with his chances from the getgo, so repeating that fact is pointless.

Okay, read the bold. I've read and reread your post and I don't see why you've missed my point on 3 occasions

You'll be surprised at how most think about a specific person even if not made public 24/7 like Diddy.

Don't worry about it.

@Kuma: Idk, it is slowly dissolving in which pixel or animation looks better in one's eye. Remember this one's eyes are correct from all the others.

This striked out part is me informing Metal that there are people are disliked by multiple people even if they don't always make it publically known.

Maybe this is where you think I don't take you seriously, there's no subliminal message or shot I'm taking at you. Read it for face value I have yet to make it clear who I like or dislike.

I would say this isn't the place for playground fights but it happens all the time so I might as well follow through for once.

 

[grizby2]

In this case I will begin to defend Bandanna Dee ^^

He can easily become an important character of the Kirby series in the future and being a playable character in SSB4 can be a huge help to this.

He can represent the whole Waddle Dee specie who have been here since the very beggining of the Kirby series, specie who have many roles in Kirby games : Common foe, Helper or even Playable characters. They have basically the roles of the Toads and the Goombas of the Mario series.

He can also give us a Spear user, something that no character have done this far.

Out of the subject i made a list for the similiraties between Toad and Waddle Dee
-Both are here since the beggining of the series.
-Both are generic species with one prominent being.
-Both appear in nearly every game of their series.
-Both have been playable in a main stream game and a spinoff.
-Both serve royalty.
-Both have been use as a move in a super smash bros.
-Both have been use as a helper for the hero.
-Both are able to use spear (remember Paper Mario).
IT'S A CONSPIRACY, A CONSPIRACY.

hmmm, those are all good points. but the only problem i have is that THE waddle dee was never avidly adressed as much as THE toad was for each of their respective game series.
its like an unspoken part of kirby. we all KNOW theres that ONE waddle dee, but not many of us purposly point it out.
EDIT: its not that much of a problem though.

 

[Shorts]

In this case I will begin to defend Bandanna Dee ^^

He can easily become an important character of the Kirby series in the future and being a playable character in SSB4 can be a huge help to this.

He can represent the whole Waddle Dee specie who have been here since the very beggining of the Kirby series, specie who have many roles in Kirby games : Common foe, Helper or even Playable characters. They have basically the roles of the Toads and the Goombas of the Mario series.

He can also give us a Spear user, something that no character have done this far.

Out of the subject i made a list for the similiraties between Toad and Waddle Dee
-Both are here since the beggining of the series.
-Both are generic species with one prominent being.
-Both appear in nearly every game of their series.
-Both have been playable in a main stream game and a spinoff.
-Both serve royalty.
-Both have been use as a move in a super smash bros.
-Both have been use as a helper for the hero.
-Both are able to use spear (remember Paper Mario).
IT'S A CONSPIRACY, A CONSPIRACY.

* applause*

There is a GOOD chance, he will be back. Thank you for taking time to write out reasoning~

 

[Lukingordex]

So I updated my roster again.

Opinions? Oh yeah, I'll also be doing an alternate character skin roster too, so don't get butthurt over Toon Link, Krom, or Impa * looks at Diddy Kong....
*Edit: Hold on a sec...

Why Bowser Jr. with Shadow Mario?

Bowser Jr. alone,please.