SmashChu's #101155 said:
Two things
1)People put a lot of emphasis on series made by non-Nintendo developers. This means Golden Sun, Sin and Punishment, and Starfy. These development studios are not owned or controlled by Nintendo. Yet if you look at Smash, the series that get the most representation are ones Nintendo owns directly. Earthbound, Kirby, and Pokemon are the only ones that fall outside of this. Nintendo does have significant influence over HAL and Pokemon in general. Xenoblade is made by Monolith which is wholly owned by Nintendo. This puts it a step above the rest.
2)Xenobalde is very popular. First, the whole Operation Rainfall thing. Second, in a Japanese magazine (Famiutsi I think) gamers out it as the 6th best Nintendo game. Shulk is also requested a bit in the land of the rising sun.
1) I think I can see where you're coming from here, but I think Smash 4 will be the first game since the original to introduce a new second-party franchise to the game. Nintendo seems to have quite a bit of influence over Camelot, with every game they've made since 1999 being on Nintendo platform and many of them being on Mario sports games. I could also easily see Sakurai push for Saki's inclusion as a playable character given how much he seems to like him. So I still feel as both have decent shots at getting in. But I think if neither get it and we got Shulk instead (along with Little Mac and Mii), it'd be more due to preference by Nintendo to stick with 1st party new series newcomers than any licensing issues (which I only see coming up in the Pokemon franchise and third-party characters).
And isn't the Pokemon Company/Game Freaks very controlling of their property? I'd imagine they were one of the most independent second-parties for Nintendo due to how enormously successful Pokemon is.
2) A lot of people do like Xenoblade that is for sure, but I wouldn't call Xenoblade a "very popular" game yet as it has yet to sell a million and probably won't. At best I see it achieving cult status a la Earthbound. Shulk being popular in Japan for requests is a decent point, thought.
Holder of the Heel's #101158 said:
Two of them I can't really argue with, I personally just enjoy Shulk more and can't argue for it, but didn't Sakurai already say no to Little Mac because of no moveset potential? I remember him saying that.
He is only listing off characters that come to mind after he says they are all important. To say that Toad is among his favorites easily is stretching it a bit.
He said "no" to Urban Champion. Whenever or not this keeps Little Mac out remains to be seen, but he has said nothing about Little Mac getting in or not.
I think that Shigeru Miyamoto is saying that he considers all characters he created to be important to him, but I'm assuming that the ones he listed off as his favorites are the ones he consider to be the most important creation to him and the one he likes he most.
GoldenYuiitusin's #101215 said:
Although, the "Flavor of the Month" thing that we tend to dismiss as crap actually holds some merit.
Ness was the latest hero in Mother, and thus was included in Smash (was not because he was international, as Smash 64 was originally going to be a Japan-only release.), and was going to be replaced by Lucas, who was going to be the latest hero by Melee's time.
While he is now in Brawl alongside Lucas, there is no need to worry about him, but still...
I think the Flavor of the Month does work to an extend. It can work for adding newcomers if it's good and can work as a promotion for current/upcoming games, but not as a replacement for a previous character.
Starphoenix's #101224 said:
http://wii.ign.com/articles/122/1223770p1.html
First. Now talk.
Sakurai always does this with each game (which I love, don't get me wrong), but it's mostly reaffirming that there will be connections between the 3DS and Wii-U version.
And like you, I don't think I'll be getting the 3DS version. I don't have the time or money to buy two consoles just to get two versions of the same game. The Wii-U version will suffice as I'm more interested in the multi-player aspect.
---'s #101256 said:
@SSBF: I saw your roster. I'm surprised about Mr. Peepers. lol
Just remember that the roster betting ends in a little while, so you'll have to make up your mind on either Victini or 6th Gen, just for the bet though, I'm not trying to change your roster or anything.
Yeah, I think most of the Smash community is up for a big surprise in him. If he gets revealed, I'll be the first to say "I TOLD YA!" and laugh at the more illogical comments regarding Duck Hunt Dog's hypothetical inclusion.
Oh and as for the bet, I'm going with 6th gen. I believe I said to put me down for it.