Didnt seem to be a problem with Star Fox and the two Link's.
You're right though, they'd be hard to make multiple movesets for.
Well, having an Adult and Child Link, both key protagonists, isn't entirely non-logical. They rep their own style of games.
As for Star Fox, to be fair, all Wolf and Falco are pretty well known and took off as high stand out characters. They're recognizable. Olimar is, but the rest aren't as nearly. It doesn't help that being different animals lets Sakurai make somewhat different moves(well, only Wolf's is fairly different at least).
I'd say the Pikmin leaders aside from Alph all look pretty physically different of Olimar...(head shapes and color) Luigi was just a reskin for a while, and he stood out just fine, so I don't understand why that would be a valid argument for characters who can be told apart from each other from a top-down perspective.
But no, Pikmin can't have a new character ever because Olimar represents it perfectly and it will never need another character but every other non-retro series will.
YA'LL SMASHERS NEED PLASM WRAITH
Being physically different doesn't mean
playing different or standing out fully. Apples and oranges, dude. Looks don't matter, how you play does. Seriously, Luigi plays different in more than one game. He's more than just a reskin(how you start out means little in the looks department). He's also been starring in his own games in something not just called Super Mario Bros.
I love Pikmin as a series. Have played all three to completion. I don't think the series will ever get a second representative simply because all the diversity is in the Pikmin, and Olimar has 'em all. Since they didn't butcher Olimar's play style to incorporate a second playable Pikmin rep, this shouldn't be a surprise to anyone that Brittany got deconfirmed. If they had left Olimar as-is and incorporated Flying/Rock Pikmin into a second rep, I could see it then, but.. again, that's not the case.
Pretty much. It didn't surprise me at all.
That's developer laziness mixed with padding the rosters, plain and simple. Clearly they figured they could get away with it, and were eventually right, 'cause no-one seems adverse to Toon Link anymore, and people have been getting more vocal lately about the possibility of Wolf or Falco possibly being cut.
Wolf isn't padding. He's barely even close to being a clone. Falco was actually padding to the roster. Both of them were highly popular period, and are likely to stay anyway because of it. Neither needs cut.
Like I said, any chance of us seeing a new Pikmin rep flew out the door when we saw Olimar with Flying Pikmin. Rock Pikmin are probably incorporated somewhere into his moveset now as well.
Eeyup.