Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Not really. It might make you feel bad to lynch someone for actions the previous player in their role took, or things the previous player in that role said. However, that does not make your suspicions of that player (and therefore the role they occupied) any less valid. I still support lynching Lance, and I now support lynching smashman. It would make me feel like a bit of a jerk to lynch someone for something they didn't do, but that's the way the game works.
Given the amount of difficulty we're having finding one person to lynch, I don't see how trying to kill two people in the day phase helps us any. It will probably just make the game more stagnant.
You should claim your character role because if you claim a character that someone else has they'll know you're lying. If there's another vigilante they'll be pretty suspicious of you but it's not 100%.I'm not claiming my roe claim was a great move, but chances are I'm not going to be online much so there's not much hurt in it. And I don't know why you would rather have known my character as opposed to my role.
Also, McCloud: there aren't even enough active people to get a lynch vote
It still isn't convincing.
If he doesn't claim, power roles can help themselves to avoid getting killed by the mafia. I doubt the cop will put himself in danger so early in the game, for good reason too. Again, I still think he should make a case against a mafia or independent later on without giving away his role, if he can. I doubt him or the watcher, if there is one, will reveal anytime soon. Just because watchers and jesters commonly appear together in EpicMafia (I think that's why you assume that there is a watcher) doesn't mean you should push for this plan where it's possible that a watcher isn't even present. Especially not when it puts a bullseye on the cop and the doc has to constantly use his protection on the cop when the mafia can just run rampant and kill other townies.
The cop can help himself by not making himself a big target. Looking at the first situation, where the doc is killed and the cop comes out, we lose 2 helpful roles. In the second situation where the cop is killed, at least the doc will be around to help others who may roleclaim, like Virgilijus has done.
What if the cop is paranoid or naive or any of the other variations where he gets false reports? We'd be running the risk of keeping mafia/independents around thinking they're townies. There are ways to "test" if the cop is sane, but they'd be wasting days and nights if we wanted to be 100% sure, and he'd be dead by the end of the game. It's unlikely that the only cop in the game would be any of those variations, but after seeing a jester, I don't know what to think.
You're wrong. Different people have different playstyles, remember that Natirasha guy that ruined our earlier game? He would act scummy even though he was a townie. Couldn't it been possible that Pikanoob might've been trying something like that (I kinda find it unlikely, but it's possible) or maybe he's just not a great player. I am also thinking that Pikanoob might've tried to kill himself because of his character. And if you're gonna kill me, then you're just gonna make yourself scummy since you started the idea to lynch me when I haven't done anything yet.
Dude, smashman you do this all the time. You make these weird role hints that just drive me nuts, I don't know why, but they just do.
You may have not done anything, but Pika did. I think the whole play about him trying to kill himself because of the role is a joke. We already lynched the fool, and I have never seen more than one in a game, so I dont even believe you.
Thats not true! Because you are new here as a player doesn't mean everything your character's done so far should be wiped from the slate.
You didn't understand what I meant, I know that we already had a Jester. What I am saying is that maybe Pika didn't like the character he got and tried to off himself. I too am trying to figure out why he would act like this as it doesn't make sense for his/my character. I am pretty sure my/his character has never been a villain. His/my character is obviously a townie and I don't understand why pika would act scummy. That's what I am trying to figure out, and the best theory I got is that he either didn't like his character and wanted to get lynched, he has a weird playstyle, or he isn't that great of a player (no offense pika if you're reading this). I could kinda see why he would want to have himself killed as I don't like this hero much.
Why me ?
