Mafia Tournament Sleepover! Game Over! SK wins the game! (ITS LEGIT THIS TIME! LOL)

[Omis]

Posting that because Im confused and dont wish to respond to the other posts against me until my head is straight.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

It's all up to the moderator.

 

[karthik_king]

lol care to point out wehre im not contributing?

I dont feel like quoting 72 posts.

 

[karthik_king]

well great now I have to quote 73 posts. Thanks scumfever.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

lol at pot calling kettle black

 

[McFox]

lol care to point out wehre im not contributing?

First I want you to prove that there isn't a God.

That's a backwards way of looking at the accusation. You can't say "Prove I'm not doing something." If someone calls you out for not contributing, you can either address it by pointing out where you have contributed, or leave it alone. But you can't tell someone else to provide evidence of things you have not done.

Agree with Kev, Marshy, and mentos that Chibo should shoot tonight.

Im Chibo were to shoot me and mafia shoot chibo wouldnt Chibo die and I not be affected?

It would entirely depend on the mod and the precedence he's set for night actions. There's no way to know.

Unvote

Vote: Omis

His recent posts have seemed very faux-town to me. I don't really have a problem with what steel did, and Omis' case against it (that steel would just play it off if someone hammered immediately) doesn't have any merit since steel specifically said he would explain his vote, and he knows we would hold him to that tomorrow, even if Chibo had gotten hammered before he could reply. I don't like his recent responses to the Chibo situation either.

 

[karthik_king]

Happy Scumfever. Here are 73 posts of non-contribution.

It's all up to the moderator.

Do I even need to explain?

lol care to point out wehre im not contributing?

Backwards mind

I crush on Noel IRL.

Do I even need to explain?

EBWOP: Meno also in my mind just posts alot of fluff.


unvote vote Karthik

yeah you can die today.

Do I even need to explain?

Call me Jungle if it's easier.

Anyway, I'm goignt o be completely honest: This game has gone nowhere. Because of this, my scum list is complete bull****.

My suggested course of action is to make a stronger D3 team. Honestly, I think we should get rid of either Karthik or Nix. Nix isnt scumhunting at all he just wants a tracker/watcher/cop to claim then work from there. Karthik is just being blatently unhelpful and whether he is scum or not the town benefits from losing someone who is useless.

H-Y-P-O-C-R-I-T-I-C-A-L What does that spell eh?

Yeah no i totally get that. However, as scum, they are more likely to slip than the other bros, as they are attempting to hide something. Lynching a someone just because they are labeled a bro si stupid and fruitless.

Do I even need to explain?

lol i'm not bothered by being grouped with bros. I'm bothered that people seem to want to lynch the bros simply because they are calling themselves bros.

Do I even need to explain?

I'm not quite sure what he's doing?

Rockin prod him? again?

Do I even need to explain?

Can we just lynch Karthik on the grounds hes unhelpful.

Do I even need to explain how hypocritical he is right now?

we're voting chibo?

okay

unvote whoeverthehell vote Chibo

Low, but why does that warrant a meno vote.

if you had said that rather tan what you said before it wouldve made a ****load more sense.

If you had spelled better your response would have made more sense

wait
so youre case is this

Bros are experienced at mafia. Meno wants bros lynched. This cannot be a coincidence.

how the HELL does this warrant a vote or even make any sense at all.

Do I even need to explain?

has omis posted today either?

Do I even need to explain?

Just because you have a somewhat formulaic method of scum hunting doesn't mean it's predictable by all scum.

Do I even need to explain?

lol because whot eh **** cares if you can say "I tol dyou so?" what good does that do us the next day? If we use conventional scumhunting methods without outing one of our power roles today, we can carry on just fine.

Do I even need to explain?

Nice pic poor contribution

lol i'm grouped with bros?

i voted cacti for reasons that i stated (that i'll go find later) D1. I didn't vote because Kevin said ALL ABOARD THE CACTI TRAIN CHOO F'IN CHOO

Do I even need to explain?

It's plausible to lose two townies that way. Though I guess if you claimed the way he did...Yeah.

Do I even need to explain?

I'm not talking about hte yak >_>

Whatever, I just disagree with outing PR's right now.

Which townie wants town PR's to die?

EBWOP: "Power role" claimed, by that, i mean he wasn't and faked it, and well, you can go read for yourself.

Do I even need to explain?

Go look at Simpsons Mafia. PR claimed, get ***** town.

Do I even need to explain?

Either way, I still don't like the way he was just lynched like that.

Do I even need to explain?

he had 4 more days to claim, and have us discuss the potential consequences....

Do I even need to explain?

urghghghhghgh



*rubs temples*

Do I even need to explain?

KK do you want to actually play this game now?

Do I even need to explain?

Hey KK do you have anything you want to say?

Probably not.

Marshy why are you so insistent on Gheb?

I thought you were ALWAYS okay with a Gheb lynch

I'm still okay with Cacti.

Why do people wanna bandwagon Chibo?

Do I even need to explain?

god damnit since when does gg and bg mean anything?

anyway, I'm still okay with Cacti, and a no lynch with 18 people is >_>.

Do I even need to explain?

If you sign up for a game you should pay attention to it.

Great now pay attention and contribute

unvote vote: cacti

Do I even need to explain?

Yeah, having you around endgame is the perfect scenario.

Do I even need to explain?

I'm still okay with a Cacti lynch.

Do I even need to explain?

I'm not a bro, yo.

Do I even need to explain?

His posts make it seem like he's contributing to town? His posts contribute to nothing no matter how you look at them.

Do I even need to explain?

Dekuu it's okay to say you hate bros.

I hate them too.

Do I even need to explain?

unvote vote: Karthik

until he posts something of even meager substance.

Hypocritical much

I'm okay with a karthik lynch as well.

On what non-hypocritical grounds?

This is one of the most convincing arguments I've seen on this forum.

Do I even need to explain?

I do that too mac :/

Do I even need to explain?

Bay Area?

Can you do the thizzle dance?

Do I even need to explain?

Urg, FF way to completely wreck my last point

Do I even need to explain?

No Nix, you said bandwagon or no lynch. The other option is to, you know, scum hunt.

We know already

Oh, sorry. No I'm not, I just really wish he'd come down off his pedestal and listen (which he is doing).

You need to get off your high horse too

Why is that the only option if we don't bandwagon?

You have no scum tells on anyone? Nothing stands out to you? Are you even trying?

Don't spoonfeed him chap

ebwop = edit by way of post.

YYou infrormed a n00b good job

I actually count 5.

Frozen, Marshy, you, me and Ronike.

I can count too guise

woof?

and yes, RVS does help with this. By how people vote in RVS and what they say about their vote can say alot about htat person and their role.

Do I even need to explain?

it's laugh out loud!

Do I even need to explain?

His second point still stands.

Do I even need to explain?

I always have been and always will be down for a gheb lynch

So thats why you called marshy out on being to insistant on gheb's lynch huh? Good to know.

If that is so. If we all aren't following your logic. Perhaps it's because your statements aren't logical at all?

Do I even need to explain?

Uhm, it's not that we aren't able to follow your logic. It's that your logic tends to look scummy.

Also wtf at all these people about D1. No discussion happens because of that attitude. D1 does suck but that doesn't mean it's completely useless.

Do I even need to explain?

I didn't define WIFOM because i'd do a ****ty job of it, though that was really good Mcfox.


i hate bros.

Great we hate you too

you forgot
omg
wtf

and
WIFOM

OMGWTF you forgot to stop pressing enter

ebwop: something to discuss. why does everyone bandwagon me all the time

noone cares if you get bw'ed all the time focus on this game

Ok Omis, let's all take your initiative and not talk at all.

Then we really get something going.

What was the point in this

Wtf there are so many people in this game.

Great there are lots of people we get it

>_>
<_<
-.-

unvote vote:mentos

whatisthisidonteven

Iight I'm down.


vote: scumfever

RVS JV

There's alot of people in this game, several of which who have not posted.

WHERE YOU AT.

A useless call out early in game to people who have not posted

I'm always down for a Chibo wagon

Pointless

I don't wanna be a bro.

Been there, done that.

vote bros

RVS JV

vote chibo

why not?

RVS JV


Everything else is pre-game

 

[karthik_king]

Make that 74

lol at pot calling kettle black

Need moar contributions not analogies.

 

[CT Chia]

ok... so a couple of things have been said.
1. ppl think that I might b an sk
2. ppl want me to shoot to clear myself...

... what?

wouldn't not shooting prove that I'm not an sk?
not to mention I didn't shoot n e one last night either.
iv never come across an sk that can pass their night kill in any game

 

[#HBC | marshy]

wow karthik

chibo not shooting doesn't prove you're not an sk

we don't know if you shot anyone last night if we could just take your word then you wouldn't be on the chopping block

 

[DtJ Jungle]

@McFox: It is definitely not the same. he claims I haven't been contributing but won't say where I didn't contribute. If he is going to make the claim it is up to him to prove it.

Also Karthik: i dont know if you just troll every game you are in or are really that stupid, but only maybe 1/3 of htose posts have no content in them. All you ddi was take all my posts and say "Do I need to explain." That doesn't prove your point at all, all it proves is that you, sir, cannot make logical deductions or just can't follow someone elses line of thinking.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Also alot of "WE KNOW ALL READY" agruments you make are stupid. You just took my posts out of the context they were in as if they were stand alone and not within a conversation, if you look at what they are responding to they make sense.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Reading it for the third time. That is probably teh worst post by post analysis I've ever seen.

 

[karthik_king]

They were all useless. Point out 1 post that was a decent scumhunt k?

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Any point you call out as hypocritical. lrn2read.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

EBWOP: I'm done responding to your nonsensical bull****. None of what you did is scum hunting right there. YOu haven't done **** all game, and that big post is a waste of your time and aw aste of everyones time. If you had gone through and done it properly and explained why all those were unhelpful, this wouldn't be the case/

 

[deepseadiva]

In summation: both of you are equally worthless.

 

[Morrigan]

Karthik I think you're doing the same thing as him by doing that, and I'm pretty sure that if I take all your posts it'd look not the same but very similar to scumfever's.

dekuu why did you choose to unvote karthik when all he did after you voted him was help pressure chibo to claim? are you looking at other people to soon move your vote to and if so who?

Yes, I was looking at Chibo, and I was about to cast my vote on him... but everything people have said after I unvoted makes sense. Shoot toNight or get lynched.

 

[KevinM]

In summation all three of you are equally worthless, God why can I never be vig.

 

[Ronike]

BIMafia kevin. BIMafia.

 

[Ronike]

At any rate, I still would rather lynch Chibo, but if not, I guess I'd rather go after Meno or KK, the former more than the latter. At least KK is trying...

 

[deepseadiva]

At least KK is trying...

...are you referring to his half-a-page-long "NO U" post?

 

[CT Chia]

I'm surprised t hat after multiple ppl have called him out, Meno hasn't done too much to help

 

[Ronike]

...are you referring to his half-a-page-long "NO U" post?

Yes, along with the other stuff he has tried to bring to the table. It may not be all that useful, but it is still infinetely more useful than someone that comes in and posts his chart once per game day and says very little beyond that, or an sk.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

urghghgh I think KK is just stupid, not scum.

unvote

 

[Nix2100]

The more I read Kevin's responses to Chibo's claim to Vig...the more odd I find it. You say you want Chibo to shoot because it clears the game faster....yet back when you were the Vig in TLI (The game I happened to replace you, in case you forgot) you never took a shot either......seems sorta hypocritical don't you think?

 

[deepseadiva]

Are you people serious.

I'm... I'm... honestly in complete disbelief.

I posted my last chart probably more than a dozen pages ago, I can't believe that's still being referred to. Since then I've tried nothing more than to be somewhat insightful, while offering my opinion on events. Are my posts being ignored or something?

I know I'm not the strongest player, and placing me next to KK really stings, but do not place me below him in terms of being useful to town.

I'm a respectable player godammit.

 

[Morrigan]

Don't base things off of other games...
If I interpreted his posts correctly, he wants him to shoot to clear Chibo, who has been saying he's protown for the past 50+ posts, from being scum. Yeah, the game clears faster once we nail the scum, what's wrong with it?

 

[Morrigan]

Ebwodp:

I was talking to Nix.

 

[Nix2100]

Things get based off of other games all the time...wasn't one of the main reasons there was a bandwagon on Gheb because of how he played in another game?

 

[Morrigan]

Still, the circumstances are different from game to game, and I don't know exactly what happened in the game you replaced Kevin, so I really can't say much. The bandwagon on Gheb ended way before N1 and then, OMGCASUALITY, he got killed by N1.

 

[Morrigan]

EBWOP
I typod like the worst. I meant OMG COINCIDENCE.
Yeah, coincidence much?

 

[karthik_king]

I posted my last chart probably more than a dozen pages ago, I can't believe that's still being referred to. QUOTE]

What have you done since then besides try to get me lynched for pointless, hypocritical reasons?

 

[karthik_king]

fail quote but no matter point still stands.

 

[deepseadiva]

EBWOP
I typod like the worst. I meant OMG COINCIDENCE.
Yeah, coincidence much?

Just curious since you don't make it 100% clear, you're still pointing out the bros as suspects in Gheb's death?

What have you done since then besides try to get me lynched for pointless, hypocritical reasons?

Here, here, and here, are some of more recent posts with content. I'm offering my opinion and trying to take an active in role in scumhunting. It's an outright lie to say I'm not contributing when those are there. And those aren't even the good ones! I have more *****es!

@Ronike

You're motherly shield over KK throughout the game has been noted.

@Chibo

Fingering yet another person while your cornered? Who woulda thunk.

 

[Morrigan]

Just curious since you don't make it 100% clear, you're still pointing out the bros as suspects in Gheb's death?

Not the bros per se, but the people who bandwagoned him. Or it could be a scum move from someone who never wagoned him.

 

[Rockin]

With 15 people, it takes 8 to lynch

Chibo (3) - Ronike, KevinM, Frozenflame,

Steel (3) - KK, Chibo, Omis

KK (1) - Meno

Omis (1) - Mcfox

Those not voting : Mentosman, Bunbun, Nix, Dekuu, scumfever, Steel

Deadline is Dec 5, 2009

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Yeah Chibo, you either shoot tonight or we have absolutely no reason to trust your claim tomorrow. It's highly unlikely that the mafia is going to let you live tonight so you might as well use your shot and help to narrow the game faster. Hell, you might even hit a scum which would be bonus points for us.

Point is, if you don't shoot there's no way for us to confirm that you're a one shot vig. and that you didn't shoot yesterday. You're boning us by not shooting because then you open up night action deductions into mucky WIFOM land. We don't need that BS.

Unvote: Chibo

KevBro? Broshy? Who's next on your dars?

I'm feeling Omis. The fact that he was so concerned about mafia kill prioriity, and then double posted to try to make it clear it was just out of curiosity so to speak, just gives me scummy vibes. Definitely came off as an OH SHI~ mafia slip up moment to me. Interested to hear what you guys think though.

Vote: Omis

 

[Omis]

Well Im trying to decide whether I think he should shoot or not and that depends heavily on this.

 

[KevinM]

He should shoot anyways

unvote
Vote Omis



Nix: I wasn't the quality of player I am now, I was good but I still had a lot to learn about game theory. Also I was a lot more timid back then. Basing games from 8 months ago doesn't work when players actually feel like evolving and bettering themselves. I understand your point but I must disagree with the fact because of which, that I am merely a different player now.